For the top-ranked Hornets, it was their first National Junior College Athletic Association Division III title in any sport.
Broome had entered the national finals with a 111-6 scoring margin and had not trailed since the third game of the season, but it fell behind in both games at the final four.
After trailing early on a own goal, the Hornets crushed host Herkimer, 7-2, thanks to a four-goal barrage in a 22-minute period.
Texas powerhouse Richland's took third with a shootout victory over Howard (Md.) Community College in the consolation game.
Broome-Gloucester report from Binghamton Press & Sun-Bulletin
Broome-Gloucester report from Salem Sunbeam
Broome-Howard report from Binghamton Press & Sun-Bulletin