Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
MLS SuperDraft is 'Unrealistic'
New York Sun, January 29th, 2008 4PM
Subscribe to Section 2 Around the Net

MOST READ

MOST COMMENTED

Major League soccer for years has tried to emulate the National Football League and the National Basketball Association by turning its annual college draft into a major media event. However, Paul Gardner of the New York Sun points out that the "SuperDraft," as it's known, is unique to the United States in the worldwide game of soccer, and as MLS takes greater steps toward becoming part of the global game, he suggests it should leave the meaningless draft behind. "The flimsy fiction that college soccer can supply pro-level players cannot be maintained for much longer," he says. "Nothing short of radical changes in the college game can alter the outlook."

Unlike college basketball and football stars, Gardner says there are almost no college players who can go straight into the professional game and become superstars, as "the level of the sport in college is so far below the level of the pro game." He adds that MLS coaches readily admit (off record) "that they spend little time or money assessing college players." Faced with that reality, MLS continues to take steps that undermine the significance of the college game. First came Project-40 -- now called Generation Adidas -- which was designed to allow the 40 best high school players to skip college soccer and train with MLS clubs. Meanwhile, MLS has forced teams to develop youth academies of their own. Says Gardner: "MLS's support of the college game is laudable, but it is unrealistic."

Read the original story...



No comments yet.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now




AUTHORS

    ARCHIVES
    FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

    Recent Section 2 Around the Net
    Youth soccer fights back against 49ers    
    Northern California youth soccer advocates, including Santa Clara Youth Soccer League President Tino Silva, have launched ...
    Cal South TOPSoccer Program Turns 25    
    "We're all soccer players, special needs or not," says Sandy Castillo, chair of the Cal South ...
    How Neymar Played in Childhood    
    Neyrmar: "I used to pick up the ball, set up the furniture and go around dribbling ...
    Roma Partnering with U.S. Youth Clubs    
    Italian Serie A club Roma, which has American ownership, aims to forge partnerships with seven U.S. ...
    LVG: Falcao "Has to Prove Himself"    
    Manchester United coach Louis van Gaal has responded to criticism over dropping Radamel Falcao by claiming ...
    Report: Adidas to Assist Messi Move?    
    According to Spanish sports daily AS, Lionel Messi's sponsor Adidas could be the key to the ...
    Toure Admits Man City Future in Doubt    
    Speaking ahead of the opening games of the African Nations' Cup in Equatorial Guinea this weekend, ...
    Ronaldo Blasts 'Defensive' Atleti Tactics    
    Cristiano Ronaldo blasted Atletico Madrid for its unattractive style after the Rojiblancos ousted Real Madrid from ...
    Fabian Johnson's 'Spat' with 'Gladbach Coach Favre    
    According to Bild, USA defender Fabian Johnson is in a "spat" with Borussia Monchengladbach coach Lucien ...
    Serie A to Introduce Goal-Line Technology    
    Serie A will introduce goal-line technology next season after the Italian soccer federation (FIGC) gave its ...
    >> Section 2 Around the Net Archives