Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
The phantom 'elbow'
by Ridge Mahoney, July 2nd, 2008 7AM
Subscribe to Soccer America Daily

MOST READ
TAGS:  mls

MOST COMMENTED

[REF WATCH]The first point to be made about Marcelo Gallardo's elbowing of Landon Donovan in the face Sunday at RFK Stadium during D.C. United's 4-1 beatdown of Los Angeles is that it didn't happen, at least not in the manner that so many reporters and broadcasters have described.

Gallardo's forearm or wrist - not his elbow - hit Donovan in the face as he tried to pull himself free of Donovan's jersey-grab as they tussled in midfield. In fact, Gallardo, who was facing away from Donovan at the time, at first fended off Donovan with his arm across Donovan's chest, and came up higher on a second attempt.

This doesn't exonerate Gallardo from disciplinary action but it may explain why referee Jair Marrufo chose to issue a yellow card to both players. Officially, Donovan's caution listed as "dissent" for his tirade at the officials as blood seeped from his nose, but he could have been cautioned for his grabbing and pulling of Gallardo's jersey.

Only if Marrufo ruled the contact accidental could he permit Gallardo to stay on the field. (Obviously Galaxy coach Ruud Gullit, who complained bitterly that Gallardo deliberately hit Donovan and should have been sent off, didn't agree.) A "reckless foul" is punished with a yellow card. For the red to be shown to a player not already cautioned, "serious foul play" or "violent conduct" must have occurred in most cases.

Marrufo could have deemed the incident as serious foul play, regardless of Gallardo's intent, but this didn't seem equivalent to a wild, two-footed tackle that goes over or misses the ball and plows into an opponent's ankle. And if Gallardo truly meant to drill Donovan in the face, the American's nose wouldn't have been recognizable as such.

One of the assistant referees and the fourth official weighed in with their opinions, so either, (a) all three officials missed this blatant elbowing of Donovan; or, (b) Marrufo blew it and declined to send off a prestigious player on his home field in a nationally televised game; or, (c) it simply didn't constitute violent or vicious play.

A deliberate blow to the face, regardless of how severe the contact, is a sending-off offense, which is why Andre Rocha was sent off for violent conduct during a melee in the Houston-FC Dallas game May 28.

Rocha didn't punch Eddie Robinson, but did strike the defender in the face with his hand, and that was enough for referee Alex Prus to pull out the red card. (Prus was also about to send off Robinson for a second yellow card.)

Since Marrufo cautioned Gallardo after consulting with his fellow officials, the MLS Disciplinary Committee will review such an incident only if it believes the foul is so egregious or reckless a red card should have been issued. It does review incidents in which the referee took no action, which doesn't apply in the case of Gallardo.



No comments yet.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now




AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent Soccer America Daily
What They're Saying: Jozy Altidore    
"When Haiti qualified I just thought it'd be a cool thing, because they haven't qualified for ...
TV Report: Fox twinbill draws combined 1,613,000 viewers    
Last Saturday's FA Cup-MLS doubleheader on Fox reached a combined 1,613,000 viewers. Manchester United's 2-1 overtime ...
Concacaf turns to NBA for new CEO    
In another step to rehabilitate itself after five years of scandal, Concacaf hired Philippe Moggio out ...
Women's players' strike motions go to judge for decision    
Judge Sharon Johnson Coleman took under advisement competing motions for summary judgment made by attorneys for ...
What They're Saying: Louisville City keeper Scott Goodwin    
"I would like to begin by saying how great it is to be part of this ...
Video Pick: Neymar, his wax figure, and 31 Barca goals    
Brazil star Neymar met his Madame Tussauds wax figure -- poked it, checked under the shirt, ...
What They're Saying: Arbroath FC chairman John Christison    
"Our thanks to Guinness for clearing that up, that's tremendous news. We would probably have had ...
USA-Ecuador: Nagbe makes it a feel-good friendly    
It felt at times as if one were watching a scrimmage, the USA-Ecuador Copa Centenario preparation ...
MLS Week 13: Results & Standings    
The Philadelphia Union played Orlando City to a 2-2 tie at Camping World Stadium in front ...
What They're Saying: Mike Francesa    
"I know I get accused of knowing nothing about soccer, and I don't, I know absolutely ...
>> Soccer America Daily Archives