Join Now | 
HomeAboutContact UsPrivacy & SecurityAdvertise
Soccer America DailySoccer World DailySpecial EditionAround The NetSoccer Business InsiderCollege Soccer ReporterYouth Soccer ReporterSoccer on TVSoccer America ClassifiedsGame Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalkSoccer America ConfidentialYouth Soccer InsiderWorld Cup Watch
RSS FeedsArchivesManage SubscriptionsSubscribe
Order Current IssueSubscribeManage My SubscriptionRenew My SubscriptionGift Subscription
My AccountJoin Now
Tournament CalendarCamps & AcademiesSoccer GlossaryClassifieds
Bonus bickering clouds SuperLiga final
by Ridge Mahoney, August 5th, 2008 12:30PM



According to MLS Players' Union executive director Bob Foose, the decision by New England and Houston players to share their portion of the prize money for contesting the SuperLiga final Tuesday night is a direct response to MLS blocking an attempt by team ownership to pay separate bonuses.

Foose sent out a release Monday morning which read: "The players on the Houston Dynamo and the New England Revolution have agreed in advance of tomorrow night's SuperLiga final that they will split evenly the bonus money at stake in the game.

"The players have made this decision to show their solidarity and in protest of the league's violation of the Collective Bargaining Agreement with respect to the negotiation of bonuses for this tournament."

By decree of MLS, the winning team receives $1 million, of which $150,000 is apportioned to the players. The players' share of the runner-up pot is $100,000.

Dynamo operator-investor AEG proposed it pay a scale of bonuses for the team's performance in SuperLiga but was prevented from doing so by MLS, prompting the MLSPU to file a grievance. The MLSPU contends this action violates the CBA, which the parties negotiated last year. It expires in 2009. In an e-mail, Foose stated the grievance would go to arbitration in October and a decision is expected a few weeks after that.

At issue may be whether SuperLiga is a compulsory tournament, for which the CBA stipulates bonuses must be paid, or a non-compulsory competition not covered by the CBA. In an interview with the Washington Post Soccer Insider, commissioner Don Garber said: "Within our CBA, there is a separate agreement on bonuses for compulsory tournaments and it is up to the league's discretion to even pay bonuses for non-compulsory tournaments.

"SuperLiga is non-compulsory. If a Mexican team doesn't want to play or an MLS team doesn't want to play, they are not required to. It is an invitational tournament."

Garber also says - without providing a single financial detail, which the league is loathe to do -- that MLS and its marketing branch, SUM, incur significant risk by staging matches and paying travel costs for the Mexican teams.

What he doesn't say, but is quite true, is that as a single-entity league that pays player salaries as well as many operational costs, MLS is empowered to run and fund outside competitions as it sees fit. What he also doesn't say is to give the tournament credibility, rather than automatically including Hispanic soccer hotbeds like Houston, Los Angeles and Dallas, not to mention the massive New York market, MLS used competitive criteria to determine its SuperLiga participants rather than marketing concerns.

The tournament's format, which matches four teams from the Mexican league against four MLS teams in group play and subsequent knockout rounds, is a creation of the respective leagues and SUM, which has also consolidated Mexican league participation in the Copa Libertadores by staging a qualifying competition, the InterLiga, in the United States. Like InterLiga, all SuperLiga games are played in the U.S.

Unlike InterLiga and the CONCACAF Champions' League, the winner of which plays in the FIFA World Club Championship, there is no reward for the SuperLiga other than the prize money at stake. The prize money and stipulated players' share was publicized last year when SuperLiga kicked off; had Los Angles not lost to Pachuca on penalties in the final, the schism between AEG and MLS about bonuses might have surfaced then.

Without a Mexican team in the final, the tournament's true appeal among MLS fans will be tested. New England drew an announced crowd of 8,302 for its semifinal against Atlante last week.

  1. David Borts
    commented on: August 5, 2008 at 2:54 p.m.
    The Super Liga has been horrible. The Mexican teams behavior on the fields has been abysmal. The MLS' behavior off the field has been "scroogish" When will the MLS learn that spending money on its players and raising the salary cap are what is needed for our sport to move to the next level. I have been a season ticket holder since year One of the League and cannot understand how players such as the Revs rookie Dube are paid $15,000.00 per year and this League cries poverty. When the SuperLiga was originated with the idea of a $1,000,00 purse, I was impressed. Now the League and the Revolution are asking people to pay premium prices for a "friendly" while a Rookie of the Year candidate tries to add a paltry 2,000 dollars to his poverty level salary. Are MLS Developmental Players eligible for Food Stamps? David Borts President Rhode Island Soccer Association

  1. Paul Bryant
    commented on: August 5, 2008 at 5:35 p.m.
    This is partly the reason why the best U.S. talent is playing in Europe. Mr. Garber's statement that "the players are playing for a trophy" is absurd. The reason why money is not mentioned in the World Cup is because most of the players are making anywhere from 6-8 figure annual salaries. I do recall reading a dispute that the U.S. national team players had with U.S. Soccer prior to the 2006 World Cup concerning World Cup pay and bonuses. Mr. Garber, money isn't everythig, it's the ONLY THING!

  1. Philippe Fontanelli
    commented on: August 5, 2008 at 7:09 p.m.
    Coach Gullit, should strengthen the midfield. Klein should play at the right side of the midfield and Beckham in the middle. Klein is wasted in the back. Or maybe using two attacking midfielder one being Donovan playing behind Buddle and Ruiz or Gordon. Keep the opposition busy instead you are being busy with the opposition. Also check Ruiz out for 90 minutes, see if he is up to it mentally and physically. Find out his attitude. He could be a pesky player, but he could also be a pain in the a....... But you still need a quality defensive midfielder. Forget about Vagenas and Franchino, they "went out with Dick Clark". Even in their at their best, they were good but mediocre players, the bar has been raised and the MLS has been much approved since their days. One question I have what happened to the transfer window? Most of the teams made use of it, but not the Galaxy. Look at San Jose, they got four new players that will help them. I could see them as a much approved team. By the way I have liked Alvarez, he doesn't seem to get the breaks. Philippe Fontanelli -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Looking for a car that's sporty, fun and fits in your budget? Read

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent Soccer America Confidential
MLS in Yankee Stadium completes New York City soccer tapestry    
Three days. Not much time to soak in a city's soccer culture. But this is New ...
Randy Bernstein: 'LA's a special market'    
The Los Angeles market is more than ready for a Galaxy rival, believes Randy Bernstein, who ...
Women's World Cup all primed to be prime-time hit    
You heard it here first: With a little luck, Fox will break the record for the ...
Orlando City staff sends right messages but lacks wiggle room    
Expansion team Orlando City SC finally won a game at home, and did so impressively by ...
Friedel's retirement ends a memorable saga    
One of the best keepers ever to pull on a U.S. jersey, Brad Friedel's retirement announcement ...
College or pro? Soccer in America increasingly faces a choice of how to develop players    
The rusting, gray Commodore Barry Bridge overlooked PPL Park, wind whirled on the pitch, and patches ...
Keith Tozer: 'USA is ready for pro futsal'    
The Professional Futsal League (PFL) is slated to launch in November 2016. Keith Tozer, who has ...
USA grooms new goddess of the air    
As sports teams go, the U.S. women's national team is tough to break into. But once ...
New York derby exceeds Marsch's expectations    
If you ever questioned MLS's wisdom of putting two teams in New York, that was answered ...
The other Great Debate: how do you define a derby?    
New York City FC and the Red Bulls kick off their rivalry Sunday that some believe ...
>> Soccer America Confidential Archives