Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
John Terry, Captain Cheat, Gets Last Laugh
by Paul Gardner, September 18th, 2008 7AM
Subscribe to SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner



English referee Mark Halsey is in trouble -- when he should be receiving some sort of award for making a brave game decision. What Halsey did, this past weekend, was to red-card John Terry -- the Chelsea and England captain.

His decision came as a huge breath of fresh air, it brought on -- for me and plenty of others -- a great feeling of relief that, at last, a referee had seen fit to severely punish a cynical -- and physical -- tactical foul. I'll give Terry his due -- he played his role perfectly. More or less at the halfway line, Terry was beaten for skill by Manchester City's Brazilian forward Jo. As Chelsea was pressing forward, there was a real danger that if Jo got past Terry he could sprint in unchallenged on goal. So Terry did what defenders have been doing -- and getting away with -- for decades now. He fouled Jo -- firstly he tried to trip Jo, but Jo was too quick for him, and then he threw his body at Jo and ended up bringing him down with a clumsy football tackle.

It looked like, indeed it was, the typical tactical foul. A flagrant breach of the rules, a game-destroying foul. Terry turned his back on the play and walked calmly away, a smug, satisfied look on his face. He had done his job. He didn't need to look at referee Halsey, he knew he would be yellow-carded, but breaking up a possibly dangerous Man City attack was worth it.

Then came the funny bit. The camera, tight on Terry's face when he finally did turn around, showed his bewilderment as he found he was staring at a red card. Off the field he trudged, facing a three-game ban for his offense. Bravo Halsey!

But, sad to say, Terry has had the last laugh. Chelsea -- a very rich club -- lodged an appeal against the red card for Terry -- the England captain. A special independent commission was called into action by the English Football Association and in no time at all this special commission issued an utterly appalling judgment. It canceled Terry's red card. So Terry the cynic, Terry the cheat (and Terry the England captain) had won after all. No punishment at all, Terry was now free to play the next Chelsea game this weekend -- which happens to be against its great rival, Manchester United.

Well, the argument against "denying a goalscoring opportunity" was a strong one -- Jo, after all, had nearly half the field in front of him. But it turned out that was not the reason for the red card. Halsey said he had given it for "serious foul play." An offense that involves the use of "excessive force or brutality" -- and the commission said there was no evidence of that.

I beg to differ. True, Terry did not swing a punch or smash into Jo's ankles. But he did enough -- with his attempted body block and trip and his round-the-waist tackle -- to warrant being found guilty of using excessive force. That is what the commission could -- and in my opinion -- should have decided. Instead, it chose to view Terry's intervention as a minor matter, something not worth punishing. And in the process of doing that, it undermined the authority of referees in general and sullied the reputation of a particular referee. Worse: as this was a controversial decision that could just as easily have been resolved by confirming Halsey's actions, it raised suspicions that Terry was getting off lightly because he is the England captain -- and because having him suspended for the next three league games would not help his preparation for England's next World Cup qualifiers.

But worst of all, is the damage this awful decision will do to the game. Terry's foul was a blatant piece of cheating, a cynical act to break up an attacking play, the cowardly (that is not too strong a word) action of a defender who had been outfoxed by an opponent. And the commission, whatever its intention, has sent an unmistakable message that such cheating is a minor matter, that it is not that big a deal.

Worth thinking about. This type of foul -- it was once called a "professional foul," more lately it has become the "tactical foul" -- has become the curse of the modern game. Precisely because it is so lightly punished, treated so frivolously, defenders employ it in every game. And our wonderful TV commentators usually come up with another term to describe it, a "good foul." And in game after game, the cheats get away with it. It has become an acceptable part of the game.

But it is an ugly business, one that should be eradicated from soccer. That was what I meant when I described Halsey's red card to Terry as a "breath of fresh air" -- because it was just that, a moment of triumph, a rare reminder that the bad guys don't always win.

But it was just that -- a moment. This misguided "independent commission" has ruined that moment, has chosen to take the side of the cheats, to cancel the action of a brave referee. They should be ashamed of themselves.

And what of John Terry -- the captain of England? Is that not a title that should demand some respect? And how are we supposed to respect a cheat? Is that not a title that should set an example of fair play? And what sort of example is Terry offering to England's, to the world's, young players?

To Mark Halsey, a brave referee who knows a blatant, cheating foul when he sees one, my congratulations. To this ludicrous independent commission, utter damnation.


  1. Heather Scott-molleda
    commented on: September 18, 2008 at 10:17 a.m.
    And to add insult to injury, wasn't the ref punished for refusing to rescind the red card, pulled from premier league duty and relegated to a 2nd division game? Loud & clear message to other refs who demand respect for the laws of the game, no? What Terry did brings the game into disrepute, which itself should be punished.
  1. John Foust
    commented on: September 18, 2008 at 11:14 a.m.
    Heather is spot-on - disgusting, and worthy of considering the EPL not longer watchable. And Paul's closing comment in the second-to-last paragraph is the telling hypocrisy, regarding how young players will view the "Respect" campaign. The FA has become laughable, and it would be nice to see some sort of reconsideration in light of the monstrous outrage resulting from the overturn.
  1. Jeff Butler
    commented on: September 19, 2008 at 2:13 p.m.
    What no one seems to notice is that Terry was not the last man back. The other fullback on that side of the field was between Jo and the goal. Since Terry did not prevent an unmolested breakaway according to the rules as I understand for a red card in that situation Terry should not have gotten a red card.
  1. Kathy Hill
    commented on: September 20, 2008 at 11:26 a.m.
    John Terry sucks! Chelsea sucks! And so does this ruling!

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner
Soccer's new-look rulebook (Part 2): Making room for the Spirit the Game    
Alongside the changes in the organization and wording that David Elleray and his team have brought ...
Soccer's new-look rulebook (Part 1): Much improved but still a way to go    
No doubt it was asking too much of ex-referee David Elleray and his colleagues to turn ...
Two badly botched PK calls -- but the MLS remedy is misguided    
Well, not that brilliant a weekend for MLS refs. Specifically, a couple of dead-cert penalty kicks ...
Soccer, from the Heart    
A small book, the classic "slim volume" if you like ... but Brian Glanville's "The Man ...
How long for Nigel de Jong?    
So the talk is now focused on what sort of punishment the MLS Disciplinary Committee will ...
Fernando and Joe Hart share the blame for Man City fiasco    
The recent tragic, disastrous and possibly hilarious screw up by Man City that allowed Zlatan Ibrahimovic ...
One Nation, One Team -- a tainted slogan for U.S. Soccer    
I, like you, have to live with the daily insults to our intelligence provided by the ...
Klinsmann's cronyism reaps its reward: A calamitous Olympic flop    
Jurgen Klinsmann decided to give the U.S. Olympic team job to Andreas Herzog. Make that his ...
Maybe we're asking ARs to do the impossible    
We are still waiting for a look at the new -- rewritten, and greatly condensed -- ...
R.I.P. #14    
Johan Cruyff, dead at the far too early age of 68, will surely not be forgotten. ...
>> SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner Archives