High Point ranked Appalachian State its first loss of the season, prevailing, 2-1, on goals by Scott Rojo and Hilaire Babou.
Goalie Michael Chesler kept Appy State off the board until the 89th minute when Ryan Maloney scored.
William & Mary held Loyola to a 0-0 tie. Loyola managed 10 shots in the match, but Daniel Ankrah's first-half strike was the only one on goal.
The shutout was the fourth of the season for the Greyhounds (5-0-1) and the 11th straight home shutout.