Join Now | 
HomeAboutContact UsPrivacy & SecurityAdvertise
Soccer America DailySoccer World DailySpecial EditionAround The NetSoccer Business InsiderCollege Soccer ReporterYouth Soccer ReporterSoccer on TVSoccer America ClassifiedsGame Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalkSoccer America ConfidentialYouth Soccer InsiderWorld Cup Watch
RSS FeedsArchivesManage SubscriptionsSubscribe
Order Current IssueSubscribeManage My SubscriptionRenew My SubscriptionGift Subscription
My AccountJoin Now
Tournament CalendarCamps & AcademiesSoccer GlossaryClassifieds
Floreat Fredy!
by Paul Gardner, March 23rd, 2009 2:43AM



By Paul Gardner

As you'd expect, the seven games of the opening weekend of MLS had a bit of everything -- the good, the bad, the remarkable, the absurd and whatever else you can think of.

The best of the best came from Sigi Schmid's Seattle, with a combination of remarkable enthusiasm and atmosphere, and a superb individual performance from young Fredy Montero. In Montero, the Sounders are giving MLS exactly the sort of player it needs - a lively goal-scorer, one who can also make a defense-splitting pass, as he did for Brad Evans's goal.

We got a reminder, too, of just how good a player Landon Donovan is, with his wonderfully quick movement and uncanny anticipation; how could he get so open when he scored his second goal, and not be offside? Well, he could, and his move was timed to perfection. So perfect that it literally left everyone else - both teammates and opponents - standing and watching.

That Galaxy vs. D.C.United game was probably the best of the lot -- highly competitive, four goals, two penalty kicks (one of them of the mystery variety), a dramatic comeback by the Galaxy, and the result in the balance right up to the final whistle.

Donovan's goal was headed in from the edge of the six-yard box, a truly close-range effort. But we had long-range stuff, too. A couple of ferocious, unstoppable blasts from outside the penalty area by Davy Arnaud for Kansas City; and then one of the more remarkable goals you'll ever see - Dallas's Kenny Cooper thumping a shot from his own half of the field that sailed into Chicago keeper Jon Busch's net over 50 yards away.

And if you were looking for finesse, you got it later in that game when Cuauhtemoc Blanco stroked home a 20-yard free kick, a smoothly struck shot that sent the ball spinning up and over the wall and satisfyingly into the net. Effortless and a joy to watch.

But joyful watching is hardly a term that could be applied to the Chivas vs. Colorado game. This was pretty dire stuff. Chivas' Jesse Marsch has let it be known in the past that he thinks physical fouls are the necessary way to begin a game. Given that Gary Smith clearly wants his Rapids to play a no-frills physical game (despite his fanciful talk of "playing like Arsenal"), this was a game that was destined to be scrappy from the moment it began.

Marsch, whose team won this mess of a game, admitted that it was something of a "dogfight," but declared that "It's the first game of the year; all in all, not a bad start." Heavens help us.

Even so, the crudities of Chivas vs. Rapids did not mark the low point of MLS First Kick. That came from the ESPN announcers' booth, where John Harkes managed to ignore the Seattle Sounders' second goal as he droned on and on with some totally irrelevant drivel, only shutting up when the ball had actually entered the net! What was he talking about? Who knows - but it seemed he was so entranced with his own voice that he totally failed to notice what was going on down on the field.

This is utterly absurd. What kind of a commentary is it that overlooks one of the neatest plays of the game? Fact is, when the action gets near either goal, when the possibility of at least a shot on goal looms, Harkes should not be talking at all. That is when play-by-play guy JP Della Camera should be in charge, interrupting Harkes if necessary. I mean when necessary.

But it will not be the verbally incontinent Harkes who sticks in the mind from that game. It will be Montero, and the freshness and liveliness and inventiveness of his soccer. He looked like a superstar -- but he has a way to go yet. This was his first MLS game. A thrilling performance that will have alerted opposing coaches that he spells trouble for them -- and he will be treated accordingly. Tougher times are on the way for Fredy, but the skill and self-assurance he showed last week strongly suggest he will flourish in MLS.

  1. Gus Keri
    commented on: March 23, 2009 at 9:52 a.m.
    I like your point about the announcers. This actually goes for all the announcers of ESPN and FSC. They should focus on the game when the ball is in the attacking third part of the field. Their chat is necessary, sometime, to provide some historical information; but this should only be done when the game is slowing down and it is being played in the diffensive end or the ball is outside the playing field. Both announcers should be aware of where the ball is, at all the time.
  1. Austin Gomez
    commented on: March 23, 2009 at 10:20 a.m.
    "FLOREAT FREDY" ---- as a retired Latin profesor, may I translate this illustrious title that the sagacious columnist, Paul Gardner, gave to his enamored readers? "MAY FREDY FLOURISH".....using the Subjunctive Mood of the Latin verb: "florere." Paul always tickles us readers with his excellent, inventive lead-ins, along with intelligent & mind-thinking, creative-explosive ideas about this world-wide "Most Beautiful Game."
  1. Linda Price
    commented on: March 23, 2009 at 5:59 p.m.
    couldn't agree more, Paul! i often have to mute the TV so i can watch the game. i might add, what kind of commentary overlooks any part of what is happening on the field?!! they say, when you notice the referee too much, something's wrong. same holds true for the announcers!
  1. Doug Huston
    commented on: March 25, 2009 at 11:12 a.m.
    Trouble with American commentators is they think they have to talk all the time. I love the English braodcasts on FSC. Soccer doesn't need constant talk. By the time they try to make a point in their jabber the play has moved on. As for the play of this weekend, I, also, found the Sounder game the most entertaining. I watched the Dynamo-Crew, the Chivas-Rapids game, the Galaxy-DC game and attended the Quakes-Revs game and found them all to be dreadful displays of long balls to no one and little midfield creativity. By the way, are the Sounders that good or are the Red Bulls that bad? They were absolutely without a clue.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner
Arena and the Lawnmower: Why, Bruce, why ...?    
Bruce Arena's signing of Nigel de Jong is a shameful episode. The most experienced American coach ...
Losing Miazga, Gonzalez, Villafana -- How is that good for MLS?     
Let's see now. Matt Miazga -- we can define him, at age 20, as one of ...
Coming soon: a slimmer, snappier -- and maybe better -- rulebook     
Right now, I'm thinking that IFAB -- you know, the soccer rule-making guys -- have really ...
The MLS PseudoDraft and other obstacles that Latino Americans face in American soccer     
Time for another MLS SuperDraft. It would be better called the MLS PseudoDraft. It might also ...
A new type of coach -- appointed by the sponsors     
Keeping up with the changes and additions to the English language -- I'm talking now about ...
Good luck and bad luck for the Foxes     
You hear it often enough: a team should rest assured that, over the course of a ...
Pawson's Pause gives the game away     
I continue not to understand the negativity that pervades -- though possibly less than it used ...
Will Computer SAM kill off the soccer pundits?     
Mark Lawrenson was once a top defender. He played for the Republic of Ireland, even though ...
The English get a timely reminder from Jurgen Klopp     
I have a problem with Jurgen Klopp: I find it difficult to take anything he says ...
Don Garber is right -- MLS deserves more respect. But it doesn't help its own cause.     
Commissioner Don Garber sounded off recently on the subject of respect, and how he feels that ...
>> SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner Archives