Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
Ref Watch: Plenty of tough calls in Week 1
by Ridge Mahoney, March 25th, 2009 7AM
Subscribe to Soccer America Daily


MOST READ


[MLS] Obviously, the Galaxy shouldn't have been awarded a penalty kick when a ball bounced off the underside of defender Rodney Wallace's leg and not his arm in its 2-2 tie with D.C. United Sunday, but should referee Jair Marrufo have given a penalty earlier when Christian Gomez and Dema Kovalenko got tangled up at the edge of the penalty area?

No. Kovalenko did foul Gomez (and was cautioned) but initiated contact outside the box and Gomez fell into the penalty area. In the case of foul outside, fall inside, Marrufo got it correct. Both players also had their arms extended, though it appeared Kovalenko had grabbed hold of Gomez's jersey with one arm and the other extended in a traditional, "Look, ref, no hands!" gesture designed to demonstrate absolute innocence.

There were plenty of handball situations in the first week of play. Before awarding Toronto FC a penalty when Michael Harrington used his arm to swat the ball, referee Jorge Gonzalez let play continue on two other occasions.

Dwayne De Rosario knocked the ball down with his arm and should have been punished, even though he was in Kansas City's penalty area. On the other occasion, TFC defender Adrian Serioux, under a stiff challenge from Josh Wolff as they dueled for a bouncing ball, grazed the ball with his upraised right arm at shoulder height. Gonzalez may not have seen the contact, which was slight, and several other players besides Serioux and Wolff were in his line of sight.

Harrington drew the whistle when he closed down De Rosario, who flicked the ball in the air as the Wizards defender approached with both arms raised high, which is never a good idea for a player in his own penalty area. Harrington's left arm hit the ball with a downward motion and tweet! DeRo skied the penalty over the bar yet still TFC won, 3-2.

FCD Dallas defender Drew Moor got caught handling to provide Brian McBride the opportunity to drill home Chicago's second goal, which he did, in a 3-1 Fire win. It was a rough day for the FCD back line; errors by Steve Purdy enabled Chicago score its first and third goals, and Moor's right arm blocked the ball after Justin Mapp had short-hopped it with his first touch.

It was a bang-bang play, as Moor was marking closely as Mapp trapped the ball and Mapp's arms were close to his side, not upraised or extended wide. FCD endured a tough day, as it hit the woodwork twice with shots, either one of which would have tied the match, 2-2, after McBride's penalty broke a 1-1 tie.



No comments yet.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now


AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent Soccer America Daily
Charlotte remains unbeaten with 2-2 tie    
[USL PRO REWIND: Week 10] The Charlotte Eagles (3-0-4) remained unbeaten with a 2-2 tie against ...
Tijuana concedes late tie; Hoffenheim coasts    
[AMERICANS ABROAD] Americans Edgar Castillo and Joe Corona will have to head back to Brazil in ...
Busch Stadium friendly draws standing-room crowd    
[CHELSEA-MANCHESTER CITY] Manchester City kicked off the international summer friendly season with a bang, rallying from ...
Soumare deal is win-win for all parties    
[MLS TRANSACTIONS] Few deals seem to work out for all parties, but the Bakary Soumare trade ...
New York and FC Dallas look to solidify leads    
[MLS SCHEDULE: Week 13] MLS finishes its third month Memorial Day weekend with six games Saturday ...
Red Stars rookie Quon switches allegiances    
[NWSL SCHEDULE: Week 8] Weekend play in the NWSL begins Friday night when the Western New ...
Wolfsburg snaps Lyon's 119-game unbeaten streak    
[UEFA WOMEN'S CHAMPIONS LEAGUE] Wolfsburg's 1-0 win over Lyon in the final of the UEFA Women's ...
What They're Saying    
"They're the new guys coming in and I'm looking forward to smashing them in 2015, to ...
German rivals in London to claim the crown    
[UEFA CHAMPIONS LEAGUE] Validating Bayern Munich's historic season at Wembley on Saturday means winning the Champions ...
Dortmund: One club. One game. One dream.     
[VIDEO PICK: One Dream] On Wednesday Borussia Dortmund's official YouTube site released a two-minute video chronicling ...
>> Soccer America Daily Archives