Join Now | 
HomeAboutContact UsPrivacy & SecurityAdvertise
Soccer America DailySoccer World DailySpecial EditionAround The NetSoccer Business InsiderCollege Soccer ReporterYouth Soccer ReporterSoccer on TVSoccer America ClassifiedsGame Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalkSoccer America ConfidentialYouth Soccer InsiderWorld Cup Watch
RSS FeedsArchivesManage SubscriptionsSubscribe
Order Current IssueSubscribeManage My SubscriptionRenew My SubscriptionGift Subscription
My AccountJoin Now
Tournament CalendarCamps & AcademiesSoccer GlossaryClassifieds
Great Goals, Rotten Refereeing in Champions League
by Paul Gardner, April 9th, 2009 12:48AM



By Paul Gardner

Let me dismiss the coaches, for a start. I do not believe that any of the eight coaches involved in the first-leg Champions League games this week played a particularly significant role. The games -- and what superb games they have been -- were largely controlled by the players.

I squirmed indignantly when I read how Alex Ferguson had made a "master" substitution for Manchester United, sending on Carlos Tevez late in the game to very quickly score what looked like the winning goal. What nonsense. It is just as logical to argue that Ferguson screwed up -- Tevez should have been on the field earlier, maybe he would have got a hat trick. Why not? Rafa Benitez gets blamed for going with zonal marking, but the blame belongs with his Liverpool defenders. As for Bayern Munich -- who ever said that Juergen Klinsmann was a master tactician? The sideline shots showed him looking utterly bewildered. As well he might -- not by Pep Guardiola's tactics, but by the sheer brilliance of his players. To say nothing of the embarrassing ineptitude of the Bayern players.

That was the thing about these games -- they so firmly placed the players at the center of things. Some of the goals, individual efforts, were wonderful to behold: Emmanuel Adebayor's extraordinary gymnastic volley for Arsenal; Lionel Messi's first for Barcelona, so beautifully and neatly rolled into the net; Fernando Torres' sweet strike for Liverpool; Cristian Rodriguez's perfectly hit shot for Porto. And of course, Marcos Senna's rocket for Villarreal.

What all of this suggests -- correctly -- is that these were teams looking to score. Only one of the eight teams didn't put the ball in the net -- Bayern. But even if Bayern had been thinking of playing an attacking game, it barely had a chance! From the opening whistle, Barcelona was all over them and was two goals up within 12 minutes. Anyone who might want to start analyzing Bayern's tactics at that point, trying to decide whether the team was playing defensively, is wasting his time. Bayern was forced on to the defensive for virtually the whole of the first half by a rampantly offensive Barcelona. In the second half, OK, maybe Bayern was more interested in damage control. Certainly, it did manage to survive without giving up any more goals - but it was absurdly lucky.

What we'll remember about the game will be Barcelona's beautifully woven passing movements and, inevitably, the sheer brilliance of Messi.

Messi's control and his passing -- mostly cunning short passes -- are exceptional -- as is his dribbling, where he seems to have the same knack that Pele had, of bouncing the ball off opponents' legs and getting it back, under control. Luck? I think not. It's quickness and anticipation and instinct and experience, and it's exhilarating to watch.

Which brings me to the one real downer of these four Champions League games. If a player has a woeful first half, you can pretty safely predict that he'll be on the bench for the second half. I think the powers that be might want to consider a similar arrangement for referees. At this level, it should be unthinkable that a referee should make such a mess of things as Howard Webb did of the first 45 minutes of the Barcelona vs. Bayern game.

At the 17th minute he made two awful errors -- firstly, by not awarding Barca a penalty kick when Messi was blatantly tripped by Christian Lell, then adding an even worse gaffe by giving Messi a yellow for diving. This was simply incredible. It so incensed Guardiola that Webb ejected him (no, I don't have a problem with that -- I sympathize with Guardiola's outrage, but he should know better than to repeatedly assail the fourth official).

A little later Webb managed to award a free kick to Barcelona when Thierry Henry tripped over himself in midfield. He then brought his woeful first half to a spectacular climax when, during the buildup to Barcelona's fourth goal, he ignored a brutal elbow to Messi's face by Mark van Bommel -- a red card, if ever there was one.

Alas, Webb did appear for the second half -- but maybe someone had a word with him, for he performed somewhat better. Of course, Messi's yellow card should be canceled. If UEFA can just show some plain common sense it will be, for the injustice screams out for correction. But don't hold your breath. Probably the best we can hope for is that Webb be removed from the Champions League officiating list after that first-half display, which was nothing short of scandalous.


  1. Austin Gomez
    commented on: April 9, 2009 at 11:50 a.m.
    'Bah, Humbug'! ! ! Players make MISTAKES, as evidenced in Bayern's mis-matched contest! So manifestly do Referee Officials: the Human Element. Do we viewers want "Robot-Type Officiating"?.......never an OPTION to the wont "Human-Factor Officiating," of course But FUTBOL is a Game of Errors because of the "Human-Participants' (all 26 Participants in every Professional match)! Let's leave the Referees alone! --- REFs need never to be frightened to take Risks & Actions and make Decisions consequently ---- and, if mistakes are made by any of the Participants, "c'est la vie"....such is life! Spectators (a most vital element in these Contests) sometimes mistakenly believe that the Game of Football should be "perfect," devoid of errors, by the Players, Coaches, and Officials! Let's therefore show a modicum of RESPECT toward the Officials (a very necessary element in the Game for purposes of Safety, primary, & also Fairness & Enjoyment reasons), wherein those officiating Decisons must be issued in split 'nano'-seconds, sans benefit of "instant-replay!" Let's keep this "Beautiful Game" untouched............of course, "mistakes" (or supposed ones) will always be a 'Part-of-the-Game' axiom..........But do "robot-type" machines need to be injected into these Game for these 'supposed' errors, via the spate of the omniscent media, unless we do certainly want these Futbol Games to be re-titled: "World Football 1984?" But 'bah, humbag' and SHAME to all those who don't realize that mistakes ('supposed'or 'real'), by all involved Participants, WILL & DO occur some= times in this 'Most Beautiful' (but always 'Memorable in Nature') Game of Association Football. AmG

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner
Time is running out on violent goalkeeping     
Employing former players as TV experts is now well established as the thing to do. Like ...
Joe Morrone: Soccer's Determined Pioneer    
Joe Morrone. I have quite a few memories of Joe, all of them pleasant and friendly. ...
Should PRO have revealed, during the game, that the Red Bull trick play was illegal?    
This really rather ridiculous business of the Red Bull corner-kick trickery continues to reverberate.
Trickery, incompetence and ignorance -- the tale of a Red Bulls corner kick     
So the Red Bulls got away with one against Chicago last week -- their use of ...
It's time for FIFA to move out of the Alps    
It has occurred to me at regular intervals during the past decades that one of the ...
Beware the banalysts and the blight of banalysis     
The usual tripe from the TV commentators this past weekend: "The more they can get the ...
Soccer and Metrics (Part 2): A troubled partnership     
OK then. The aim of metrics in soccer is to improve player performance. After that, the ...
Soccer and Metrics (Part 1): Beyond the marketing silliness     
Now here's a nice example of the extravagances, the exaggerations the deceptions, and, yes, the downright ...
Impeding the goalkeeper, tackling from behind -- difficulties of definition    
The new FIFA Rule book for 2015-2016 presents the usual problem. What has been changed? The ...
A Soccer Rarity -- A Triumph for Common Sense    
There are three heroes in this story -- though heroes is really much too dramatic a ...
>> SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner Archives