Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
Red Bull Arena: A new era for New York soccer
by Paul Gardner, April 20th, 2009 12:21AM
Subscribe to SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner



Paul Gardner

It looked like a burned-out aircraft hangar. It was certainly big enough, a towering hulk of intertwined metal beams with a gaping hole in the middle. A huge metallic donut.

That's the way it looked last week. But this is not a ruin. Something vital is being born here. People are busy here, things are changing rapidly. This surreal skeleton is about to acquire some flesh, the gaps and the spaces are about to be filled in, as the new Red Bull Arena emerges in Harrison, New Jersey.

As I stumbled around there (well, it is a construction site, you know) I was astonished by the size of the place, it seemed at times to be as big as Wembley stadium. It won't be of course -- Wembley holds 90,000. This one will have a capacity of only 25,000. But in its current empty mode -- no people, no seats, really nothing inside the framework, it gives the impression of spaciousness.

No doubt, it will be the best pure soccer stadium in this country. As each new soccer venue goes up, the sophistication of the design improves. There's no reason to doubt that RBA will improve on the already admirable Home Depot Center.

Well, of course, I knew that -- I'd read the press releases and seen the architects' projections. Wonderful stuff. But who pays any attention to those slick drawings of buildings-to-be?

Not I. I remind myself that Pecksniff was an architect and turn the page. But slithering about on the site itself, dwarfed by the framework of metal columns and arches, that's another matter. This is not one of those prim little drawings with the sun shining on an ethereally beautiful structure surrounded by hopelessly artificial looking trees and groups of stick like people.

This is reality. And for a while, I'm not quite taking it in. Nearly 50 years ago I attended my first pro game in New York. At Downing Stadium on Randall's Island. A stadium that had been built in 1934, not specifically for soccer, but for athletic events of any sort. It worked quite well for soccer, as it happened, but it was allowed, over the years to disintegrate. A sad process.

On my last visit to Downing Stadium, maybe 10 years ago, death was in the air. The wreckers arrived soon afterward, and for a short while the Downing Stadium site probably resembled the RBA construction site. But nothing was being born there. An old stadium was being killed, and an era of New York soccer went with it. A stadium where Bill Cox's International Soccer League had flourished and where England had beaten the USA, 10-0. A stadium that had been at the center of the 1960s era of touring foreign teams, when Pele and Santos and Eusebio and Benfica, and the great Inter Milan team of that era had played there. Pele had returned there in 1975 to play with the Cosmos, which called it home for a while. The field was always awful, the fans sat on hard concrete, the press accommodation was atrocious, there was no cover. So good riddance.

Well, I suppose so -- but it tears at the heart to realize that history, the past, one's own memories, are so fragile that a bulldozer can crush them to dust in the space of a few hours.

In those primitive days did we ever think there would be such a thing as a state-of-the-art soccer stadium? And just a few miles away, across the Hudson River? I don't think we ever thought about it. It was probably too outrageous an idea to waste time on.

Funny thing. It was the Great Depression that brought about the building of Downing Stadium -- it was a creation of the WPA. Now, 75 years later, we have another financial crisis -- and another stadium.

Red Bull Arena will open next year, if all goes according to plan. It has, I think, only one negative. It's not in New York. But that is almost offset by the fact that it can be reached easily from Manhattan by public transit, the so-called PATH trains, which are, in effect, an extension of the New York subway system into New Jersey.

Stadium building is evidently the rage in this area -- we have new stadiums for the Yankees and Mets and the Giants, all open or about to open. Huge structures, massively impressive, that make the RBA look like small change.

But I expect the RBA to have an advantage. It will surely be fan-friendly. The huge stadiums suffer from something they cannot correct: they are cold, impersonal. Red Bull Arena will be the right size for coziness, for character, and for atmosphere. It has everything to make it a place where fans can feel at home, feel warm. When did anyone ever feel like that in a super-stadium?

Admittedly, I'm getting ahead of things here. The stadium will play its part. But there has to be a team. A winning team. Overlooking that New Jersey location for the moment, the team will have to live up to the title the Red Bulls have given themselves -- the New York Red Bulls. It has to be a New York team. Should you wonder what that might mean -- think Cosmos.


  1. Austin Gomez
    commented on: April 20, 2009 at 8:44 a.m.
    As a retired Latin teacher, the only thing that comes to mind is that most beautiful Vergilian phrase in the AENEID that evokes: "MIRABILIE VISU" (pardon this descriptive Latin Adjective and Supine), referring, of course, to the olden 'Trojan Horse' but now perhaps transfering that "epithet" to the newish NY Bull Arena also. Yes, "Marvelous To See! Yes, the Latin language is still meaningful today in this our 21st. century, wherein the ANCIENT surely collides with/meets the MODERN & wherein this "modern marvel" may, in time, be reminiscient in its prestige & glory & fame to that ancient Greek B.C. machination! That is the Question!?! AmG
  1. Paul Bryant
    commented on: April 20, 2009 at 11:17 p.m.
    I promised myself I would not attend a professional soccer match played with football yard markers on the pitch. I welcome with open arms Red Bull Arena. It will probably be my first time watching a professional soccer game in a soccer specific stadium in the U.S. I live between the RBA and Chester, PA, the site of the New Philadelphia franchise stadium. I have not decided where to place my allegiance. Maybe I will choose based on the stadium.
  1. Britt Orr
    commented on: April 22, 2009 at 3:24 a.m.
    i think that MLS has done a disservice to itself and soccer fans by trying to distance itself, in many ways, from its roots. New York should so obviously be the Cosmos. I was so happy to see Seattle write in the Sounders versus what the owners suggested, and to see Portland and Vancouver keep the Timbers and Whitecaps as a nod to their own roots. Let people remember the stops and starts that are part of the history of soccer in America. Some fans remember and new fans have a history to explore that explains the story of the game in their own communities. I think that MLS has done an impressive job in getting the game to go big time in some communities that is not necessarily dependent on only the Hispanic communities. While extremely important what is the draw of just a pro team in their area when they can trace the history of a Chivas or America for generations?

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner
Soccer's new-look rulebook (Part 2): Making room for the Spirit the Game    
Alongside the changes in the organization and wording that David Elleray and his team have brought ...
Soccer's new-look rulebook (Part 1): Much improved but still a way to go    
No doubt it was asking too much of ex-referee David Elleray and his colleagues to turn ...
Two badly botched PK calls -- but the MLS remedy is misguided    
Well, not that brilliant a weekend for MLS refs. Specifically, a couple of dead-cert penalty kicks ...
Soccer, from the Heart    
A small book, the classic "slim volume" if you like ... but Brian Glanville's "The Man ...
How long for Nigel de Jong?    
So the talk is now focused on what sort of punishment the MLS Disciplinary Committee will ...
Fernando and Joe Hart share the blame for Man City fiasco    
The recent tragic, disastrous and possibly hilarious screw up by Man City that allowed Zlatan Ibrahimovic ...
One Nation, One Team -- a tainted slogan for U.S. Soccer    
I, like you, have to live with the daily insults to our intelligence provided by the ...
Klinsmann's cronyism reaps its reward: A calamitous Olympic flop    
Jurgen Klinsmann decided to give the U.S. Olympic team job to Andreas Herzog. Make that his ...
Maybe we're asking ARs to do the impossible    
We are still waiting for a look at the new -- rewritten, and greatly condensed -- ...
R.I.P. #14    
Johan Cruyff, dead at the far too early age of 68, will surely not be forgotten. ...
>> SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner Archives