Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
Schedule Congestion Beyond Critical Point
by Ridge Mahoney, July 28th, 2009 10:02AM
Subscribe to Soccer America Confidential



Additions and subtractions to the MLS All-Star team that will face Everton Wednesday at Rio Tinto Stadium (ESPN2, Galavision, 9:30 p.m. ET) are removing much of the luster that is supposed to emanate from one of the league's showcase events.

True, the All-Star Game is an exhibition, nothing more, and Everton will use the game to help prepare its players for the upcoming English Premier League season. Yet while conflicts with other competitions are inevitable, the scheduling of Concacaf Champions' League matches for this week has exacerbated congestion beyond the critical point.

MLS officials say all the right things about cooperating with U.S. Soccer, Concacaf, and other entities for national team callups, and cause some logjams themselves through SuperLiga, but they do regard games matching league teams - or an All-Star squad - against foreign foes as important, both as a television product and a competitive frame of reference.

While there are enough deserving, talented players to replace those All-Stars unable to participate, the absences focus more scrutiny of a league already burdened by fitting FIFA dates and other international commitments into its schedule. How the league can work out its conflicts with Concacaf events, U.S. Open Cup, SuperLiga, and other matches is a serious issue this year, and will only intensify next year with a World Cup to squeeze into the calendar.

Dwayne De Rosario is not in Salt Lake City; he will play for Toronto against Puerto Rico Islanders Wednesday and has been replaced by Cuauhtemoc Blanco of Chicago.

Despite compiling one of the best records in the league, D.C. United won't have any players in the All-Star Game, as it faces Salvadoran club Chalatenango Tuesday in the CCL. New York's dismal season would probably preclude it from sending any players, anyway, yet its match Thursday against W Connection (Trinidad & Tobago) has excluded them.

Under terms of the Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) negotiated by the MLS Players' Union and the league, for purposes of paying bonuses and other considerations MLS is obligated to announce a squad of 32 players, as if it was staging an Eastern Conference vs. Western Conference All-Star Game. While the wisdom of playing an All-Star Game can be debated, the league has tried to upgrade its stature by playing foreign teams rather than a intraleague exhibition, but is running into too many conflicts to field its strongest team.

Houston doesn't play in this round -- its Concacaf Champions' League schedules starts next month -- yet Brian Ching - bruised and battered from playing in the Gold Cup -- has been withdrawn and replaced by Fire defender Bakary Soumare. Injured Dynamo keeper Pat Onstad has also been pulled; he's being replaced by Chivas USA goalie Zach Thornton.

All-Star coach Dominic Kinnear certainly wants to beat Everton, yet he can't be blamed for looking ahead to an important league match Saturday against D.C. United. He must consider that one of his two players who will play in the All-Star Game, Stuart Holden, is also coming off an arduous stretch of Gold Cup matches.

There are always alterations to All-Star rosters, in all sports, because of injuries or fatigue or other complications. Compromises are inevitable. The fans will get to see many of the league's best players take on a solid English Premier League team, and subplots like the initial All-Star appearance for longtime national-team goalie Kasey Keller, and ex-MetroStar goalie Tim Howard taking on many of his U.S. teammates and former MLS rivals will shape interesting storylines.

A glorified exhibition like the All-Star Game isn't the most serious situation regarding schedule congestion. But at some point, MLS and U.S. Soccer and Concacaf must get on the same page to lessen the suffering on all sides.




  1. commented on: July 28, 2009 at 11:23 a.m.
    Cutting back on regular season matches to focus on international competitions makes sense. Look at interest and ticket sales for World Football Challenge and the international friendlies this summer, then look at double-digit decreased attendance at eight clubs in June and the quality of some of those games. Dogmatic adherence to the regular season schedule as it stands is pointless and no matter what Blatter says, playing in a foot of snow in January and February is not an option.
  1. Alvaro Bettucchi
    commented on: July 28, 2009 at 12:16 p.m.
    I think that the MSL needs to schedule soccer like the rest of the world. Begin in September, play half a schedule, take a winter break, and then play the next half of the schedule. During the summer, have the exhibitions.
  1. Raymond Dreyfuss
    commented on: July 28, 2009 at 6:54 p.m.
    this should hve been reached 5 years ago, after all we in U.S. soccer should all be on the same page!
  1. Michael Polonski
    commented on: July 28, 2009 at 10:44 p.m.
    I have advocated a bundesliga-style format for MLS for several years. Start in August, break from mid-December until February, conclude in May and run Superliga, the all-star game, and exhibitions in July before the season begins. Despite the potential logic of this plan, many still refuse to comprehend the idea of the league playing in February. If we never go to a fall-spring calendar, the next best idea would be to start the first weekend in March and conclude with MLS Cup in early December. By adding four weeks on to the present schedule, greater flexibility will be gained and we should be able to respect all competitions. We do, however, have to say no to some events in a World cup year though.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent Soccer America Confidential
MLS Awards: Giovinco leads list of MVP candidates    
Voting closed Monday for the MLS individual awards and without knowing who the three finalists will ...
Whitecaps own up to their shortcomings in 2016    
The plight of defending champion Portland has been a running saga all season yet its foe ...
Drogba and Saputo show the power of 'big personalities'    
Players on big salaries often bring along big egos as well. Montreal owner Joey Saputo has ...
What was the value of the USA's bumpy win in Cuba?    
The USA's 2-0 win in a friendly over Cuba on Friday marked its first return to ...
Paul Arriola takes advantage of opportunities for USA    
On and off the field, fast starts are normal for Paul Arriola. He scored a goal ...
Options could lead to makeover of U.S. midfield    
Strong performances by several players in friendlies against Cuba and New Zealand could create a logjam ...
Bob Bradley steps into a tough new world    
Last season, 11 of 20 Premier League clubs changed managers, including major stars such as Louis ...
New NASL owner expects to see difference in how league operates    
The interlocking and overlapping elements of North American pro soccer are among the issues facing owners ...
So far, Jordan Morris' decisions have been the right ones    
U.S. forward Jordan Morris turned down a move to German club Werder Bremen, which is rooted ...
MLS Playoff Watch: Breaking down the Eastern Conference's battle of bubble teams    
With a month of the regular season to be played, no Eastern Conference team has clinched ...
>> Soccer America Confidential Archives