Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
Ref Watch
May 8th, 2007 6AM
Subscribe to Soccer America Confidential

MOST READ
TAGS:  mls

MOST COMMENTED

If the MLS disciplinary committee can review incidents like Andy Herron's elbow into Jay Heaps' face and Sacha Kljestan's tackle from behind on Andy Williams and mete out fines and suspensions after the fact, why can't red cards like the one Terry Vaughn handed out to Shalrie Joseph in last week's Revs-D.C. game be reviewed and perhaps rescinded?

Herron's elbow wasn't seen and Kljestan's tackle wasn't punished with a card, yet the disciplinary committee suspended Herron four games and Kljestan two. And these punishments were justified: Herron clearly cocked his elbow and swung it into Heaps jaw; Kljestan's tackle was an attempt to win the ball but he clearly slid into Williams from behind and caused an injury serious enough to sideline the RSL attacker for at least a month.

MLS rules prohibit the rescinding of cards except if the referee misidentifies the player being disciplined. In that case, it will rescind the incorrect card and transfer it to the player whose name/number should have been taken.

There's certainly an inconsistency inherent in punishing players but not rescinding cards after the fact, but the decision to caution or eject a player is a judgment call, like so many of the decisions referees must make. Perhaps Vaughn saw the Joseph tackle from behind, believed that Joseph had stuck his outstretched foot into Ben Olsen's from the side or thought Joseph had gone over the ball.

Actually, Joseph lunged in front of Olsen and the ball, perhaps anticipating a dribble or pass forward. Instead, when Olsen cut the ball to the side, Joseph either missed it entirely or barely nicked it as Olsen's momentum carried him forward and he tripped over Joseph's leg, as in singular, as in Joseph did not fly in with both feet.

A foul had to be called but nothing about the tackle could be deemed cynical nor violent. Joseph did not clip Olsen's heels as the D.C. midfielder went past him, which would have merited a caution.

Vaughn's awarding of a penalty whenJaime Moreno was shouldered off the ball by James Riley also drew criticism. The players were running side-by-side as a ball rolled into the penalty area and Revs keeper Matt Reis came out to collect it. The contact was shoulder to shoulder and not violent, but Riley, who had inside position on Moreno, did raise his arm somewhat and Moreno crashed to the grass.

Only a severely stretched interpretation of the rules could deem this to be the use of  "unnecessary force," the only possible criteria for a foul to be called, as Riley didn't elbow, grab, trip, or impede Moreno. The ball was within playing distance and thus players are empowered to shoulder charge each other in their attempts to control the ball.

Moreno is certainly one of the more adept divers in MLS, perhaps in retaliation for all times he's hacked and grabbed and kicked. This was a tough, scrappy, hard-fought game and Vaughn, one of the top U.S. refs, tried to call it close yet not too tight.

Top-class attackers should be protected by the referees, but they shouldn't be gifted, and in this case, Terry Vaughn played Santa Claus.



No comments yet.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now




AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent Soccer America Confidential
New NASL owner expects to see difference in how league operates    
The interlocking and overlapping elements of North American pro soccer are among the issues facing owners ...
So far, Jordan Morris' decisions have been the right ones    
U.S. forward Jordan Morris turned down a move to German club Werder Bremen, which is rooted ...
MLS Playoff Watch: Breaking down the Eastern Conference's battle of bubble teams    
With a month of the regular season to be played, no Eastern Conference team has clinched ...
Strenghtened Sounders set aside distractions to focus on postseason quest    
The midseason arrival of Nicolas Lodeiro and the return to fitness of Roman Torres has bolstered ...
Talk of treble not heard at FCD    
Tuesday night the U.S. Open Cup final sold out, and most of the 16,612 in attendance ...
Rested Revs will be tested by defining run of games    
A formation changed and renewed commitment to defense has tightened up a porous Revs' back line, ...
Pulisic helps USA play low and win high    
I had high expectations of Christian Pulisic. He delivered -- and then some.
Christian Pulisic must start on Tuesday    
Coaches like to be secretive about their starting lineups, which is the only way to explain ...
More than a Hexagonal berth is on the line for USA in Caribbean tests    
Does U.S. head coach Jurgen Klinsmann take dramatic steps to revamp his team In qualifiers this ...
Doyle departure starts crucial new era in San Jose    
With only two playoff appearances since it rejoined MLS in 2008, San Jose hasn't been able ...
>> Soccer America Confidential Archives