Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
Bargains and busts abound with salary figures
by Ridge Mahoney, October 2nd, 2009 5:30PM
Subscribe to Soccer America Confidential



The updated list of MLS salaries always offers plenty of interesting material, especially regarding who provides the best bang for buck, and those players who are basically stealing money.

When TFC signed forward Argentine forward Pablo Vitti on loan, for example, it must have assumed he'd perform well enough to merit $303,000 in compensation, particularly since he'd be playing with Dwayne De Rosario, signed as a max-salary player ($425,750 base) after some sensational years - including four MLS Cup titles -- at San Jose and Houston.

With just two goals and one assist in 24 games, Vitti is further down the value list than, say rookie midfielderSam Cronin, a real steal at $36,000 base and $84,000 total compensation. Chad Barrett (five goals and three assists in 26 games) might also seem a bit pricey at ($195,000/$202,500).

Such examples can be found on the rosters of most teams, and despite rumors of the per-team salary cap ($2.3 million for 2009) going up sharply as a condition of a new collective bargaining agreement currently being negotiated, it's doubtful the MLS Board of Governors will permit the union to set salary-cap figures. Under the current CBA, there is a minimum benchmark each team must allot to salaries, but the actual cap is adjusted annually and approved by vote of the Board.

DeRo, on the other hand, has put up good numbers (11 goals, five assists) while playing 25 of 27 games, and just might have recharged the movement to install grass at BMO Field. His complaints about the surface early in the season, while certainly not the first such utterance, dovetailed with pleas from fans and concerns voiced by TFC coaches and executives. The statements last year of Quakes midfielder Darren Huckerby, whose MLS rights were first claimed by TFC by the discovery mechanism, citing FieldTurf as one reason he wouldn't play in Toronto, spurred the change as well.

On Wednesday the Toronto City Council approved a project by which grass will be installed at BMO Field in time for the 2010 MLS season. The estimated cost of the project is $6 million, which the team will pay for, as well as the Designated Player salary of Julian de Guzman, whose deal is worth $ 909,600.00/$956,350.00, according to figures listed on the MLS Players' Union Web site .

What is more prevalent than ever before on MLS rosters are loan players and their various salary figures, which is why a rock-solid defender like Jhon Kennedy Hurtado of Seattle has a base salary of $36,000, and his teammate, the exciting young forward Fredy Montero, is listed at $155,000. The most extreme example is Houston forwardLuis Angel Landin, who has been signed on loan as a Designated Player yet for this season counts only $120.000 in salary, which is more than three times more than dynamic Dynamo midfielder Stuart Holden, who might be the bargain of 2009 at a salary of $34,728.75.

Whether or not players on loan to MLS are also being paid salaries or other compensation by the clubs or other entities does not factor in negotiations, according to MLS vice president Todd Durbin, who oversees all player matters. The league is much more aggressive and adamant about getting options to buy written into loan agreements, and more teams and players are willing to deal with MLS than in the past.

"I do believe the profile of our league has grown significantly in the past few years," says Durbin, who worked with former MLS deputy commissioner Ivan Gazidis prior to his move to Arsenal last December. "I think that not only clubs, but players, respect the level of the league and regard it as an outstanding place to potentially play the rest of their career, but also play and continue to develop their skills."

Durbin also refutes reports that MLS has concluded a deal to buy Montero's contract, though there is a pre-negotiated transfer price written into the loan agreement. He also stipulates that the league negotiates with no other agencies other than clubs. " We have options on both players and we'll visit it at the end of the year," says Durbin.

"From the league's standpoint, we're not involved in any negotiations at this point. It's fair to assume we'll be having those discussions as soon as the season is over. If we're not acquiring the player from a club, there won't be a loan fee or transfer fee involved."

How's this for an all-bargain squad of 20, for players who earn $36,000 or thereabouts in total compensation (it does not include Generation Adidas players who earn significantly more in total compensation than their base salaries):

Goalies: Brad Knighton (Revs), Jon Conway (Chivas USA).

Defenders: AJ DeLaGarza (Galaxy), Darrius Barnes (Revs), Eric Brunner (Crew), Jair Benitez (Dallas, on loan), Hurtado (loan), George John (Dallas).

Midfielders:Andre Luiz (San Jose), Jeff Larentowicz (Revs), Corey Ashe, Geoff Cameron, Stuart Holden (all Houston), Sinisa Ubiparipovic (Red Bulls).

Forwards:Kheli Dube (Revs), Steven Lenhart (Crew), Bryan Jordan (Galaxy), Jesus Padilla (Chivas USA, loan), Jorge Flores (Chivas USA), Dominic Oduro (Houston).


  1. I w Nowozeniuk
    commented on: October 2, 2009 at 5:11 p.m.
    Pablo Vitti has not fit into the TFC program or he's out of his element. In either case his 300K salary is money thrown down the shute. Carl Robinson is another TFC player of questionable worth. His 315K salary based on his team contributions is highly questionable. If Emilio of DC UTD and Schelotto of the Crew command an almost equal 750K salary, something is amiss. It's time for the MLS to restructure its salary cap and provide a DP with a 75K - 100K range plus a play0ff bonus clause..
  1. Dave Oyer
    commented on: October 5, 2009 at 9:24 a.m.
    Unbelievable! C'mon one in this league should be making $35,000 a year....ridiculous. The maintenance men working at the stadiums make more than that. I am absolutely FOR the designated players and high dollar player being brought into the league......its been a great success. But there is no way the minimum MLS salary should be less than 50k! Get with the program!

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent Soccer America Confidential
Dynamo can't afford to stumble again in wake of Coyle departure    
Both former head coaches of the Houston Dynamo are natives of Scotland, and were born in ...
Il caso Giovinco: Italy's loss is MLS's gain    
Sebastian Giovinco isn't going to the Euros. Italy's loss is MLS's gain. More particularly, Toronto FC ...
Philadelphia Union embarks on its toughest stretch of games to date    
The Philadelphia Union, the Eastern Conference leader, plays in Orlando Wednesday, flies halfway across the country ...
Perry Kitchen finds a new niche in Scotland    
Perry Kitchen left MLS after five seasons though the destination turned out to be somewhat of ...
Howard leaves Everton for a much different MLS and USA    
Is the time right for Brad Guzan to take over as the U.S. No. 1? Both ...
Kamara deal shakes up stagnant Revs    
Nobody can match the production of Kei Kamara since he joined Columbus prior to the 2015 ...
Busy midweek schedules add to unique travel woes in MLS    
No MLS head coach or executive has ever praised the league's schedule-makers. Conflicts with other competitions ...
It's time for Klinsmann to go young    
At first blush, there is nothing startling about the 40-player list from which Jurgen Klinsmann will ...
NYCFC's Pirlo problem won't go away    
Jason Kreis, New York City FC's head coach for its expansion season, never came out and ...
Recent incidents sharpen focus on how video replay can improve the game    
MLS and other North American soccer leagues are awaiting specific guidelines to be issued by FIFA ...
>> Soccer America Confidential Archives