Join Now | 
HomeAboutContact UsPrivacy & SecurityAdvertise
Soccer America DailySoccer World DailySpecial EditionAround The NetSoccer Business InsiderCollege Soccer ReporterYouth Soccer ReporterSoccer on TVSoccer America ClassifiedsGame Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalkSoccer America ConfidentialYouth Soccer InsiderWorld Cup Watch
RSS FeedsArchivesManage SubscriptionsSubscribe
Order Current IssueSubscribeManage My SubscriptionRenew My SubscriptionGift Subscription
My AccountJoin Now
Tournament CalendarCamps & AcademiesSoccer GlossaryClassifieds
Comedic SuperClasico caps first weekend of playoffs
by Ridge Mahoney, November 2nd, 2009 1:46PM



Thank god for god-awful defending.

Sometimes playoff soccer is a mesmerizing matrix of synergy and skill and speed, and sometimes it is ineptitude run rampant. And sometimes it takes on a cagey, cat-and-mouse persona common around the world, with the home team pushing the issue, and the away team sitting back.

All variations were on display in the first games of the MLS conference semifinals, which suggested that blame for dull play or credit for exciting fare has not much to do with the format utilized, but rather the teams themselves and the strategies they adopt.

Crew head coach Robert Warzycha benched Guillermo Barros Schelotto and Alejandro Moreno Saturday and deployed two holding midfielders -- Brian Carroll and Danny O'Rourke -- in an effort to stymie Real Salt Lake at Rio Tinto Stadium. The Crew attacked mostly through the headlong charges of Steven Lenhart, who nearly scored in the opening minutes, and soaked up pressure successfully until substitute Yura Movsisyan cut a ball to the near post in the 89th minute that Robbie Findley steered underneath keeper Will Hesmer for a 1-0 win. For the record, O'Rourke fired a shot just wide from distance with one of the Crew's very few scoring opportunities.

Warzycha is obviously banking on the home leg to carry his team into the conference finals, and had the games been spaced further apart, might have used Schelotto and/or Moreno, who both have been banged up in a busy season of domestic and international games. But only five days separate the first leg from the return game Thursday in Columbus, and Warzycha's pragmatic approach - steeped perhaps in his Easter European roots, Poland to be specific - is to be replaced by aggression and pressure from his strongest lineup. With RSL sporting a minus-15 goal differential in away games this year, who can blame him? Everbody outside of Salt Lake City will, of course, if it doesn't pan out.

New England hosted Chicago in the early game Sunday shorthanded, as usual, and surely going down early to a Chris Rolfe goal wasn't in the game plan. But once again in this injury-decimated season the Revs rebounded; Emmanuel Osei headed an equalizer from a free kick in first-half stoppage time for his first MLS goal, and Shalrie Joseph, who else, banged home a loose ball during a goalmouth scramble for the winner (2-1).

If the Fire is beset by a crisis of confidence going back home down by a goal after holding the lead it has only itself to blame. It has not played well at home (5-4-6) this season, though the Revs' 2-1 win increased the record of home teams in playoff meetings between these foes to 13-0-1. Chicago is in the same position as the Crew -- one goal down heading into the home leg -- but does it have the same confidence? It would not appear to be the case.

Chivas USA and the Galaxy betrayed the very concept of organized defensive play by their comedic displays Sunday at Home Depot Center Sunday afternoon. Atrocious mistakes lent a Keystone Kops flavor to the first Superclasico playoff match, which ended 2-2 and could have been 4-4 or 5-5 if all the defensive gaffes had been efficiently punished.

The nadir may have occurred when Landon Donovan tucked a roller through keeper Zach Thornton's legs after Maicon Santos, whose goal in the fourth minute opened up the game immeasurably, shanked a Paulo Nagamura clearance back into the goalmouth, and Donovan nipped between two opponents to tap the ball into the net.

I speak of Chivas USA-Galaxy in glowing terms not solely for its entertainment value but rather as a reminder as to the maddening ambiguity of playoff soccer, and indeed, soccer in general. Some strange force came into play at Home Depot Center and on the day after Halloween magic spells or trances spooked players into bad decisions, three of which became goals.

At Qwest Field in a memorable encounter Thursday, Houston and Seattle served up a frustrating yet fascinating 0-0 in which both teams deserved at least a goal, or perhaps two, by their crisp buildup play, quick strikes in transition, and efficient execution on set plays. It may have been the best-played game of the four first legs, and certainly conveyed the best atmosphere, yet it produced no goals.

All four games featured rookies or newcomers enduring their initial playoff tests; some faltered, others excelled. Galaxy defender Omar Gonzalez erred on both Chivas USA goals, Revs counterparts Darrius Barnes and Kevin Alston performed admirably. Some very experienced players committed atrocious errors, and the luck and bounces that generally even out over a seven-month season may not be neatly so squared up in a compressed time frame. So it goes when a season's worth of effort is boiled down to a few games.

The playoffs are flawed, but they work, and they're not going away. They ratchet up the intensity and pressure, they reward competence - most of the time -- and they punish inefficiency, on the field and in the stands. Seattle sold nearly 36,000 tickets for its home game, New England couldn't hit 7,500. Those discrepancies are functions of the teams and their markets, not the two-leg format or short lead time to sell tickets for the first legs.

Only New England and Real Salt Lake were able to win their home legs, and they won only by a goal. The other two series are tied. As is usually the case in the playoffs, after one game nothing is decided.

Can Columbus overturn a one-goal deficit and overcome a defeat incurred with two of its offensive stars on the bench, and can Crew management pump up the crowd to give its team something of a homefield edge? In three days we'll find out.


  1. Raymond Dreyfuss
    commented on: November 2, 2009 at 2:46 p.m.
    About the super clasico, its to bad about rooky Gonzalez that is well lked by the l.A. fans blew two goals but after all he is inexperienced and young. but I amwilling to give him the benefit of the dought, hopefully he will get his feet on the ground, and hope Bob Bradley will try him for center half, because he needs one like yesterday, Gonzalez has all to do it on next sunday 2nd round. as for Donavan & Becks they seem to have other things on their mind, Milan for Becks & Paris Saint Germain for Dononvan. well half the battle is done for Becks. he will play for Milan. and hopefully will be chosen for England, and Donnvan he will be able to go also. Noww what I want to see as a Galaxy fan is production by both of these stars, because last sunday they did not show up, this ussually hurts the team, I want to see a good Galaxy team.

  1. I w Nowozeniuk
    commented on: November 2, 2009 at 3:14 p.m.
    Crew's high school display of defensive marking in the late stages of the game puts them a goal down. I'm not so sure Crew coach did the right thing; showing up to play for a tie is inexcusable. The game tactic makes no sense when the opponentr has played in a defensive shell all season. In his case, the defense lost total concentration and were punished. I remember back in the NASL days when the Cosmos had 3 games left in the season and needed to score at least one goal (goal point earned at that time) to qualify for the playoffs; they lost all 3 games by 1 - 0. Goals are not guaranteed, especially in the MLS where the best offensive team averaged 1.65 goals per game in league play.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent Soccer America Confidential
We hand out our MLS Midseason Awards    
Can a newcomer win the MVP award? Is the defending Goalkeeper of the Year destined to ...
Soccer's scandals poison Gold Cup playing field    
As a child in the early 1960s, I was a college football fan, or as much ...
It's time to re-think the MLS All-Star Game    
As the league expands and teams sign more star players, limiting the MLS representation to just ...
USA gets reminder the red, white, and blue is not sacrosanct on Concacaf fields    
Defeat to Jamaica in the semifinals changes the U.S. landscape for the next few months. With ...
So you think you've been Concacafed?    
The Gold Cup is the tournament everyone loves to hate on, from the refereeing to the ...
USA has no one cut from Dempsey's mold -- thankfully, his exit is a ways off    
Before bagging a hat trick against Cuba, Clint Dempsey had scored three of the four U.S. ...
New MLS process twists its already labyrinth-like financial underpinnings    
In just over a week, two teams -- Portland and the Galaxy -- have announced deals ...
Galaxy breaks new ground with Dos Santos signing    
Is the signing of Giovani dos Santos another example of the rich getting richer in MLS, ...
FIFA hearing: Power, politics, the two-choice equation and why U.S. Soccer sells itself short    
According to U.S. Soccer's latest Form 990 return, secretary general Dan Flynn was its second highest-paid ...
Major roster changes reflect concerns over U.S. play at Gold Cup    
Tepid performances in the group phase prompted U.S. head coach Jurgen Klinsmann to bring on DaMarcus ...
>> Soccer America Confidential Archives