Join Now | 
HomeAboutContact UsPrivacy & SecurityAdvertise
Soccer America DailySpecial EditionAround The NetSoccer Business InsiderCollege Soccer ReporterYouth Soccer ReporterSoccer on TVSoccer America Classifieds
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalkSoccer America ConfidentialYouth Soccer InsiderWorld Cup Watch
RSS FeedsArchivesManage SubscriptionsSubscribe
Order Current IssueSubscribeManage My SubscriptionRenew My SubscriptionGift Subscription
My AccountJoin Now
Tournament CalendarCamps & AcademiesSoccer GlossaryClassifieds
Despair not - Kreis and Donovan Offer Hope
by Paul Gardner, November 15th, 2009 11:38PM



By Paul Gardner

I had to feel sympathy for MLS Commissioner Don Garber when the lights went out at the Home Depot. Not once, but twice -- and we got television shots of him in his luxury suite, talking into his cell phone, trying to show some mastery of a situation over which he had no control at all.

Embarrassing it must have been for him. To me it was merely irritating -- my concerns were rather different from Garber's. What worried me was not what was going on when the lights were out, but what was happening when they were on. When the Dynamo and the Galaxy, under full floodlights, were supposed to be giving us an exhibition of MLS soccer at its best.

Well, I think that statement is justified -- this was the conference final, after all. But the soccer was not fit for the occasion. Dismal stuff, inchoate and incoherent for the most, a game of grinding teeth and unremitting effort. Not worth watching.

In such a game you can guarantee that Dema Kovalenko will set the tone, It took only 13 minutes before he launched himself, studs up, into Stuart Holden's legs. In midfield, no danger threatening -- merely a nasty challenge because Kovalenko couldn't control the ball, and Holden stole it. A yellow-card offense if ever I saw one -- but here we go again -- referee Terry Vaughn didn't even call a foul, never mind give the card. A significant omission, as Kovalenko, inevitably, did get a yellow in the 77th minute.

The game, if that's what it was, was liberally sprinkled with 41 assorted fouls. Five of those came from Beckham -- a total that ought to have earned him a yellow for persistent infringement. Referee Vaughn spared the star.

Totally fitting that the winning goal should come from a Galaxy defender, with Gregg Berhalter prodding the ball into the net for what would be a top candidate for Worst Goal of the Year, should MLS have such an award. The insurance goal arrived in the form of a penalty kick -- (an occurrence that had seemed likely all game long) -- and gave Landon Donovan, whose skills had been lost in the suffocating banality of the evening, a momentary chance to get some attention.

Beckham, the other highly paid star, looks increasingly like the 34-year-old that he is, trying to pretend that he's still a 24-year-old, which he assuredly is not. It's still all about those long right-foot passes and crosses, but the accuracy is beginning to look suspect. As that wonderful skill declines, we get the battling, fouling, David instead, and a guy who finds it necessary to complain to the referee all the time.

Maybe Bruce Arena has some magic that can turn this assembly of geriatrics and adolescents into a worthy team in time for MLS Cup. But it seems unlikely.

Which leaves me thinking that the appeal and the marketability, to say nothing of the honor, of MLS will be in the hands, or at the feet, of Real Salt Lake come November 22nd.

RSL and Chicago gave us a game - a goalless game, as it happens - that was full of good soccer and without the unpleasant atmosphere that marred the Galaxy vs. Dynamo meeting. There were fouls -- 31 in total, 23 of them by RSL (six from Chris Wingert, who did get a yellow, though not for persistent fouling).

RSL is hardly a team full of innocents -- not with Kyle Beckerman leading the league with 10 regular-season yellows, and Jamison Olave sharing top spot with three reds. But the soccer was lively, attack-oriented and it flowed nicely. It was open enough for one to sense, from both teams, a suggestion that there were players out there who were actually liking what they were doing. The days of expecting pro soccer with a smile have, alas, been put behind us. Things have gotten too serious for that, and probably the most we can hope for is soccer that is enjoyable both for players and spectators alike, rather than a drudge for both.

The only thing that marred RSL's win was, of course, that it wasn't really a victory at all because it came via a shootout. That's the best soccer's rulemakers can do, so no blame attaches to RSL. MLS has been relatively lucky so far -- despite five of its 13 finals going to overtime, only one has sunk to the shootout level.

We may be heading for another one. RSL did not show any great facility for finishing, despite plenty of exciting approach play. As for the Galaxy -- well, we have been in no doubt for some time now that, defense is the important thing, and the "grinding out" of 1-0 wins apparently represents the acme of their costive approach.

Off we go to Seattle for a final that does not, which ever way you look at it, promise to be a sparkling one. It has been born from two overtime conference finals, four hours of soccer that failed to produce even one halfway decent goal.

This is a final that desperately needs a referee who will, right from the start, be harsh in his punishment of gratuitous physical play and of tactical fouling. I wish I could think of one to nominate, but the recent permissive performances of top MLS referees have left me without a viable candidate. In any case, is that what MLS wants? A tough referee who may well send someone off -- how can that be good for the final? In fact, players do not get red-carded in MLS Cup finals. So far that fate has descended on only one player -- surprise, surprise, who else but the fearsome Kovalenko? The promos and highlights shown on TV strongly suggest that mayhem, broken bones and blood are what the TV companies are looking for.

But ... nil desperandum. RSL, under the admirable Jason Kreis, has shown itself to be an enterprising bunch, not given to the cautious approach. And I do have some hope of the Galaxy turning on the style, a hope that rests entirely on one man -- Landon Donovan. Where there's Donovan, there's hope.

  1. Ric Fonseca
    commented on: November 16, 2009 at 1:58 p.m.
    Hola Paul! While watching the Friday evening "spectacle" everyone I know asked: why in sam's heck did the MLS schedule the game on a Friday night with an 8:00PM kickoff? Perhaps Mr. Garber is not too fully aware of the horrendous Los Angeles freeway traffick especially on a Friday night. I opted to relax and watch it on the "tee-vee" at a sports bar Anyway, I sort of thought the barkeep had mixed a more than usual strong liquid libation when I saw the field go dark, and lo and behold I thought: hey are they playing the men's NCAA finals already? After all the NCAA finals have a "time out" halfway through each half? Then a thought struck me: hey, the HDC is on state university property and it is surroundeud by residential areas on three sides. Did someone from the Galaxy or the HDC management check the fine print, i.e. that the lights are to go off at a certain time when evening games are played given the residential neighborhoods and other regulations? Think about this: Most if not all night games kick off at 7 or 7:30... get where I am going? So the HDC "excuse" or "explanation," does NOT wash for me, I know only too well what local governments, schools, parks, and even state universities demand about lights being on after a certain time... me thinks that there is a timer that someone did not check before kickoff. Think about it. As for the foul, so there were 41 fouls, how many did Houston get? The RSL/Chicago game recorded 31, 23 for RSL and only 8!?!!?? for Chicago? Come on Paul give us the numbers. Kovalenko? He's got trouble written right next to his name, and everyone knowledgeable remembers his "enforcer nature." Maybe Arenas needs such a player. I hope the final doesn't come down to that. And as for the referee, well, bring in someone from Europe, the dude who did the '06 WC Finals, or even "Dracula" from the Mexican Federation. Certainly none of the MLS refs... then again, it is the MLS... Think about it.

  1. commented on: November 16, 2009 at 4:02 p.m.
    "Beckham, the other highly paid star, looks increasingly like the 34-year-old that he is, trying to pretend that he's still a 24-year-old, which he assuredly is not. It's still all about those long right-foot passes and crosses, but the accuracy is beginning to look suspect. As that wonderful skill declines, we get the battling, fouling, David instead, and a guy who finds it necessary to complain to the referee all the time." Couldn't agree more, and to watch most of our own media (not to mention the British press: "BECKHAM SAVES GALAXY") slavishly credit everything to Beckham, when in fact it was he who was the downfall of the team for several years, is annoying. If I were another member of the team, I'd still be furious. (There are other members of the team, right, ESPN?) I think the group conference chapionship pix say it all--Beckham is nowhere to be seen--he's elsewhere on the field, displaying his kids to the TV cameras.)

  1. Austin Gomez
    commented on: November 16, 2009 at 10:02 p.m.
    Thank you very much, Paul, for the "NIL DESPERANDUM." You are such a classical language linguist (like myself), I love your knowledgeable Latin epithet for Mr. Jason Kreis' RSL! With his Latin legions of 22 RSL Gladiators,,,,,,,,,They Will Win!.... or as the Romans will shout................V I N C E N T ! ! ! (NIL --- irregular Adverb, followed by a wonderfully-sounding GERUNDIVE)! "NOT TO DESPAIR"......................Mr Kreis is on his way! ----- !priceless!

  1. Paul Cox
    commented on: November 17, 2009 at 3:15 a.m.
    The rumor on Prost Amerika is that Kevin Stott, an ex-FIFA ref, will be doing the final.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner
Tab Ramos and the Soccer Speed Trap    
Comparing his very ordinary current under-20 team with the highly promising version he had two years ...
'A flag on the play' -- something soccer could learn from football     
From Saturday's FA Cup game in England: Leicester's Andrej Kramaric gets clean through the Tottenham defense, ...
A Look Back at 2014 and a Resolution for 2015    
I see we're being told that 2014 was a great year for soccer etc, etc, etc. ...
The EPL begins to embrace Latino talent     
All 20 English Premier League teams were in action on Boxing Day (Dec. 27). Between them, ...
Burley rants against diving -- and gets it badly wrong    
Craig Burley, I must say, comes over rather well on TV. Down to earth, with an ...
MLS: a Soccer League without a Soccer Voice    
A few names to consider: Dick Walsh, Ken Macker, Bob Cousy, David Prouty, Howard Samuels, Doug ...
College Cup serves up more bland brew    
After several years of boringly vapid finals it can be safely said that the College Cup ...
Yet again English refs land themselves in trouble with silly simulation calls    
This past Saturday gave us a sharply well-defined view of just how big a mess the ...
Donovan departs in triumph. Pity about the soccer.     
The winner of MLS Cup 2014, the only winner, really, was Landon Donovan. He ended his ...
Klinsmann and Walton cast shadow over MLS Cup    
As MLS bows gracefully (well, that's my hope) off the soccer scene for a short while, ...
>> SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner Archives