Join Now | 
HomeAboutContact UsPrivacy & SecurityAdvertise
Soccer America DailySpecial EditionAround The NetSoccer Business InsiderCollege Soccer ReporterYouth Soccer ReporterSoccer on TVSoccer America Classifieds
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalkSoccer America ConfidentialYouth Soccer InsiderWorld Cup Watch
RSS FeedsArchivesManage SubscriptionsSubscribe
Order Current IssueSubscribeManage My SubscriptionRenew My SubscriptionGift Subscription
My AccountJoin Now
Tournament CalendarCamps & AcademiesSoccer GlossaryClassifieds
John Terry captaincy debate defines the times
by Paul Gardner, February 5th, 2010 10:22AM

MOST READ

MOST COMMENTED

By Paul Gardner

The further that soccer moves into the celebrity area, the more distasteful things get. And already I'm in trouble. That word "distasteful" that seemed to me, moments ago, to be exactly the word I wanted, now suddenly looks old-fashioned and rather naive.

Of course, what else, I'm thinking of the behavior of the England captain, John Terry. Having it off with the girlfriend of Wayne Bridge, one of his England teammates. And then trying to get a court order banning the revelation. Very nice.

But "distasteful" probably isn't the right word because it implies some sort of ethical (though not moral) judgment, and we don't make those judgments too often these days. Not in the celebrity world, anyway.

For once, I think it is worth looking back and pondering how things used to be. There certainly was a time, not all that long ago, when Terry's behavior would have meant his instant dismissal -- not only from the England captaincy, but from the England team.

That was, oh, maybe 40 years ago, when the word "honor" was always attached to representing one's country. Terry would have been judged to have sullied that honor, and I doubt anyone would have argued the point.

Consider: in 1950 a Stoke City player, Neil Franklin -- England's center back, in my opinion probably the best center back England has ever produced -- chose to accept the offer of the maverick pro league that was then starting up in Colombia. The money was exceptionally good -- much more than Franklin could earn in England. He went to Colombia, but the league, which did not have FIFA's approval, soon collapsed. Within a month the 28-year-old Franklin returned to England. To be shunned. He never played for England again, indeed never played First Division soccer again.

His behavior was widely considered to be "dishonorable" -- which in one way it was, for he had walked out on Stoke City, and the England selectors never forgave him for what they saw as his betrayal.

There were those -- I was one of them -- who thought the decision, to virtually finish the career of one of England's best players, was harsh, but at that time it no doubt represented majority opinion.

Returning to today, reading what is being written about Terry, about the great debate that has arisen about whether he is fit to wear the captain's armband, brings you into a different world. Whether it's better or worse, I know not. 

But I do feel quite sure that Terry's behavior, though it might escape in today's terms being either distasteful or dishonorable, surely ought to be unacceptable.

The USA went through a similar situation 12 years ago, with John Harkes philandering with teammate Eric Wynalda's wife. Coach Steve Sampson threw Harkes off the team, and then did the honorable thing by keeping his mouth shut about the background.

But that was then. For Terry, his luck ought by now to have run out. He has been in plenty of trouble before, all of it well, I'll try the word "unsavory" this time. You add all the incidents up and you wonder what sort of character you're looking at.

That's important, because being captain is surely about character. Either that, or it's about nothing. Terry's character is evidently badly flawed -- so what's to discuss?

The England coach, who happens to be Italian, is Fabio Capello, from a country where the family -- and the values of the family -- are held in exalted esteem. But Capello is taking his time about this, as though much consideration must be given. To what, one wonders?

Well, to this: soccer is more important than any of that ethical b.s. about honor. What matters here is that England win the World Cup -- to satisfy all those superbly passionate fans, and to make all the marketing people happy by seeing, at last, a return on all the millions of dollars they have pumped into the England team over the past decade.

That's all. Terry? Is he a coarse drunk who's been involved in public brawls, who's been engaged in dubious financial deals, who cheats on his wife with another player's girlfriend? Irrelevant, all of it. Maybe he has to stay as captain because there's no other suitable candidate. But whatever happens, this team, this collection of celebrity millionaires, must not be upset.

If Terry remains the England captain, then we know that the position -- which used to be the highest honor the game could offer -- has now been dragged through the mire, and requires no particularly admirable personal qualities at all. Just the ability to play soccer well -- which, overlooking a cynical elbow here and a crude body block there, Terry can certainly do.



0 comments
  1. Collin Willardson
    commented on: February 5, 2010 at 12:34 p.m.
    I agree with the comments that Paul has made. Once upon a time, being a captain of a national team mean that you had honor, respect, and were an upstanding citizen. John Terry shows none of these. He simply does not respect life. He is a good footballer, no doubt, but he still isnt a good person. I like that Fabio is not making him captain, but i do feel that John terry should be punished for his actions and moral behavior. But i am glad that Fabio stands for something right still in this world of slipping morals and corruption.

  1. Steve Rafferty
    commented on: February 5, 2010 at 12:39 p.m.
    I agree and as an American Chelsea fan it hurts to say it... He is not a real person...His public personnae and private ones are too different. Seems like Gerrard might be a better choice...or Rooney.

  1. Collin Willardson
    commented on: February 5, 2010 at 12:48 p.m.
    Yeah Gerrard would be a good choice. i dont see Rooney as much of a captain though in all honesty. I especially don't see Beckham being captain anytime soon either. My personal vote, and bear with me here, is Peter Crouch. I think he is a good person, a good footballer, and a good leader.

  1. Joe Hosack
    commented on: February 5, 2010 at 1:11 p.m.
    This is what happens when you value a person's Skill MORE than the total PERSON. Hopefully at some point in his life Mr Terry wants to be considered more than a footballer. The world does him a mis- servive to over look that which diminishes his growth as a complete person. This scenario worked out well for the USA in 1998 - I hope he stays Captain. J H Pennsylvania USA

  1. Gonzalo Munevar
    commented on: February 5, 2010 at 1:47 p.m.
    The pirate Colombian league did not collapse until 1953 (or was it 1954?) when Di Stefano left Millonarios for Real Madrid and the Colombians finally said "uncle" to FIFA. As late as 1953 Millonarios was allowed to play internationally, winning the forerunner of today's World's Cllub Championship and going on a successful tour in Europe.


Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now




AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner
FIFA's Scandalous Snub of Costa Rica     
Should there be any lingering doubts about the total domination that Europe now has over the ...
A Tale of Two Clasicos: From Madrid to Seattle    
It seemed like a good idea -- to compare and contrast Sunday's big games. Two clasicos ...
How I referee Garber vs. Klinsmann    
That MLS Commissioner Don Garber should be upset by Jurgen Klinsmann's thoughtless and really rather peevish ...
To Landon Donovan: Ave atque Vale!     
So Landon Donovan has had his special day ... and I cannot think of anyone involved ...
The Need for a Holistic Approach to Soccer    
One of the stranger things about soccer is that it is rarely, if ever, considered as ...
England -- belatedly and hesitantly -- begins to accept Latin talent     
LONDON -- Change -- important, fundamental change -- seems to be arriving at last in English ...
Tactical fouls and studs-up tackles dangerously overshadowed by diving hysteria    
LONDON -- This fatuous business of turning simulation, or diving, into the worst crime that a ...
Magath's cheese poultice -- maybe not so whacky as it sounds    
LONDON -- There's not much to be said -- well, nothing good -- about the short ...
Coaches, Doctors or Refs: Who to trust with players' health?    
LONDON -- You may have noticed that Jose Mourinho has plenty to say. You may also ...
Mad Dog and Fighting Pig find home in MLS -- in a good way, of course    
Hard on the heels (and that phrase may soon acquire literal meaning) of the arrival of ...
>> SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner Archives