Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
Stahl's red card and Olave's second penalty were justified
by Ridge Mahoney, April 5th, 2010 7:18PM
Subscribe to Soccer America Daily

MOST READ
TAGS:  houston dynamo, mls, philadelphia union, real salt lake, referees, seattle sounders

MOST COMMENTED

[MLS REF WATCH] Penalty kicks and ejections are usually the most contentious incidents of a competitive soccer match, and the first Ref Watch of 2010 takes a look at incidents from the first two weeks of play.

STAHL’S SENDING-OFF. Philadelphia head coach Peter Nowak traded barbs with Sounders midfielder Freddie Ljungberg after the Union lost its inaugural  match, 2-0, to Seattle in the MLS opener March 25. Nowak claimed that a dive by Ljungberg produced a fraudulent caution to rookie defender Tony Stahl, making his MLS debut, and set the table for his dismissal.

Ljungberg went down in a tangle with David Myrie and Stahl midway through the first half by letting the ball run rather than playing it. Myrie dove into a tackle with both feet but appeared to miss Ljungberg, who went down as Stahl banged into him from behind. Referee Ricardo Salazar cautioned Stahl; a few days later, Nowak complained that Salazar had been fooled. Yet a player cautioned, rightly or wrongly, should tone down his play, and Stahl did just the opposite. With a late and clumsy challenge near the end of the first half he kneed Freddy Montero in the lower back, and he did it in the center circle, where everybody in the stadium or watching on television couldn’t fail to see the foul.

Like Ljungberg, Montero has been criticized for his flops, but on this occasion he’d been drilled. Despite Union protests, Salazar brought out the red card. He’d already cautioned defender Danny Califf for a crunching midfield challenge in the first minute but that didn’t deter the Union from getting in its shots.

After the match, the Union released Myrie, who hadn't learned from his narrow escape, if indeed Salazar had erred. Badly scorched several times by Sounders winger Steve Zakuani, Myrie picked up a yellow card by felling him with a body block in the second half. While Nowak has a point in regards to Ljungberg and Montero hitting the ground too often and too easily, there’s nothing easy about officiating a game played on slick turf, in the rain, with a raucous Sounders crowd roaring at every touch. The Union took a hard, physical approach right from the kickoff, so it can hardly whine about being punished for foul play.

DYNAMO DOUBLE. Houston beat Real Salt Lake, 2-1, in its home opener at Robertson Stadium last Thursday with a pair of Brad Davis penalty kicks awarded for Jamison Olave fouls on Geoff Cameron and Luis Angel Landin, respectively, in the 52nd and 55th minutes. No one quibbled much about the first one, but RSL players swarmed around referee Jair Marrufo after he pointed to the spot a second time after Landin pulled the ball back as Olave dove in and hopped in the air before going down in a heap.

No doubt Olave and his teammates objected to the second penalty out of embarrassment as much as a sense of injustice; a team that prides itself on defense doesn’t expect to give away a pair of penalty kicks in the same game, never mind two inside of three minutes. Yet in attempting his tackle, Olave clearly stapled Landin on the ankle without the merest touch on the ball.

(There was a lot more contact in that incident than there was Saturday, when Rapids defender Marvell Wynne appeared to lightly clip the foot of Patrick Nyarko, whose tumble to the ground yielded the penalty kick by which Brian McBride hit the equalizer in a 2-2 tie.)

If the Mexican striker did jump away from the contact and fall to the ground to earn the call, he also did it out of self-preservation. A leg that remains planted under such a challenge is ripe for injury; ankle and knee injuries are far more common in such situations than when the fouled player can jump. Olave missed the ball and got the ankle, and whether Landin could have regained his balance doesn’t change the fact he’d been tripped.



0 comments
  1. Mj Lee
    commented on: April 7, 2010 at 5:34 a.m.
    This Ref Watch is not as critical as it should be. Jair Marrufo did a terrible job in the RSL-Dynamo game. He let too much go in the first half, and then over-compensated with the 2 quick PK calls. He is becoming an embarrassment to USSoccer, and if he gets a game in South Africa, he will be so bad that FIFA will make us wait 8 years before another US referee gets a WC assignment.
  1. Bill Richter
    commented on: April 8, 2010 at 2:13 a.m.
    I agree, he's been full of gaffes, remember the 2 cautions without a sendoff several years back? I cringe when I see him walk to the center circle before a match, wondering if he'll have a good game or tank. BTW, I'd not be surprised if we have worked a game or 2 together, as well as you being on the side for several I've coached in (If this is the MJ Lee I believe it to be, located somewhere in the vicinity of the left coast?) My knees are almost ready for a return.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now




AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent Soccer America Daily
USMNT: Arena meets Bundesliga quintet    
Less than two weeks after taking the job, new U.S. national team coach Bruce Arena has ...
MLS Moves: Hedges signs new deal with FC Dallas    
Keeping a successful team together can be a challenge in MLS, and rather let the contract ...
What They're Saying: Sigi Schmid    
"My son, Kurt, is still a Sounders employee [as an assistant coach and scout], so I ...
MLS Expansion: St. Pete and Carolina enter race    
One recent and a second likely refugee from the NASL threw their hats in the increasingly ...
MLS Expansion: Competition gets crazy    
If the push to get into pro soccer is driven by the desire to get a ...
NASL's fate hangs in the balance    
A decision on the 2017 sanctioning of the NASL and USL was put on hold by ...
MLS Awards: Villa adds MVP award to trophy case    
He won a World Cup and European Championship with Spain and a Champions League title with ...
What They're Saying: Russian MP Valery Rashkin    
"It is crucial to verify that 'FIFA 17 is compliant [with the law] for the game's ...
What They're Saying: Luke Mishu    
"I had to be realistic. I love soccer, but MLS isn't the NFL or NBA. I ...
Video Pick: Reus assists Auba for best Bundesliga golazo     
Borussia Dortmund's Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang scored the Bundesliga Goal of the Week, a golazo that was special ...
>> Soccer America Daily Archives