Join Now | 
HomeAboutContact UsPrivacy & SecurityAdvertise
Soccer America DailySoccer World DailySpecial EditionAround The NetSoccer Business InsiderCollege Soccer ReporterYouth Soccer ReporterSoccer on TVSoccer America ClassifiedsGame Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalkSoccer America ConfidentialYouth Soccer InsiderWorld Cup Watch
RSS FeedsArchivesManage SubscriptionsSubscribe
Order Current IssueSubscribeManage My SubscriptionRenew My SubscriptionGift Subscription
My AccountJoin Now
Tournament CalendarCamps & AcademiesSoccer GlossaryClassifieds
Don't bother with Fair Play -- just pay the fines
by Paul Gardner, August 4th, 2010 1:15AM

TAGS:  fifa, netherlands, spain, world cup


By Paul Gardner

Images of the recent World Cup final linger on in my mind. Andres Iniesta's goal, of course, now made more lustrous by knowledge we could not have at the time, that this was the winning goal.

But beyond that ... what else is there that remains from that game, that climactic game, that should have been one of soccer’s great festive occasions.

Little that was worthy, I fear. My memories come unbidden, I am not looking for anything in particular ... but the memories are of violent play, of rough tackling, of reckless challenges, and, of course, of an embattled referee, Howard Webb, doing his best to cope with the havoc.

This was supposed to be a showcase game. Surely, we should be able to rely on the World Cup final displaying our sport at its best? Or if not that, then even more certainly, we have the right to expect that this very special occasion will not turn into an exhibition of the sport at its worst.

Sadly, we got the worst. Thanks to the Dutch, who chose to besmirch this gala occasion with ... well, it’s not necessary for me to describe the way they played, I’ll let you listen to the greatest of Dutch soccer players, Johan Cruyff: "Sadly, they played very dirty ... This ugly, vulgar, hard, hermetic, hardly eye-catching, hardly football style ...”

There is a wonderful, almost choking, incoherence to that exasperated cri de coeur as Cruyff barely controls his disgust at what he had seen.

That was spoken in the heat of the immediate post-game period. Maybe Cruyff would be less hard on his compatriots now, but I hope not. His first reaction was surely the right one. The way the Dutch played was a disgrace.

What the Dutch got away with was, in soccer terms, pretty close to murder. The murder of the sport. There can be no excuses. Their approach comes over as entirely premeditated. The fouling started in the first minute of the game, it cannot be mitigated as a response to anything that the Spanish were doing.

But the Spanish were inevitably drawn into the fray, and we got what must surely go down as the nastiest World Cup final ever. Just three days earlier FIFA President Sepp Blatter had commented on what he saw as commendable fair play at the tournament: “There have been fewer yellow and red cards, the players have been respectful to their opponents.”

Then, having sat through a final that was the very negation of fair play, Blatter dodged the issue and simply refused to face the facts: “I will not make any comment but we always say football is school of life because it is based on discipline and respect. It’s a combat game but in the spirit of fair play. You have to learn to win and you have to learn to lose, and should not forget the basis which is discipline and respect.”

That is sheer persiflage, it tells us nothing, but that is hardly surprising, for Blatter, when asked directly about the violence, refused to comment, and gave his reasoning: “Even though I have seen all the irregularities as a spectator, I cannot answer this question as president of FIFA. I could answer it as a fan of football but I am here as president.”

An extraordinary statement, one that confirms that Blatter now sees his role as that of a superior being, no longer able to take a realistic look at the sport, no longer able to see it as the fans see it. This is a huge mistake. On occasions such as this, when the sport has been led woefully astray, who else but the FIFA president should speak out, loudly and clearly, against the transgression? What kind of a president is it who watches for two hours as his sport is dragged through the mire and then says that it is precisely his position as president that prevents him from condemning it?

A diplomatic one, for sure, and that is further evidence that Blatter has promoted himself to the role of a World Leader who cannot soil his hands with mundane difficulties.

This blindness is bad enough, but things get worse, because FIFA has now announced that it has punished the two finalists by imposing fines.

The Dutch have been fined 15,000 Euros ($14,400), the Spanish 10,000 Euros ($9,600). And the Dutch actually get off lighter than Spain -- they’ve been fined $1,600 per card, while the Spanish are coughing up $1,900. Not that anyone will even notice, because these fines are, of course, pathetic, obscenely pathetic. To set them in perspective, all you need to know is that the Spanish soccer federation has promised bonuses, reported to be $734,000 to each player.

This attempt to put a moral matter right by monetary means is distasteful in the extreme, the final squalid touch to a thoroughly sordid episode. The Dutch deserve a much more severe punishment than a mere $14,400 slap on the wrist. They have tarnished the sport, made a mockery of what ought to be one of its most noble occasions.

But the president of FIFA cannot comment on it, cannot take any action ... because he is the president. Some president.

  1. Gene Jay
    commented on: August 4, 2010 at 8:37 a.m.
    Yeah, the finals sucked. Everyone knows it. Didn't read this entire article because I moved on weeks ago. On to Henry in the MLS, and getting psyched for EPL, La Liga, Serie A and Bundesliga, et al. I think you will find, Mr. Gardner, everyone else has moved on too. Your story seems to be about the fines and a few digs at the president of FIFA. We still don't care, and have moved on already! Given your propensity to re-live it, I am sort of under the impression you actually loved the finals--because it gives you something nasty to write about.
  1. Kerry Ogden
    commented on: August 4, 2010 at 9:28 a.m.
    I think the real issue here is why haven't the ref's been fined for all the bad calls. Blatter is the real culprit here, protecting the ref's from relegation due to the bad calls which still will continue unless something is done by FIFA!
  1. Gus Keri
    commented on: August 4, 2010 at 10:43 a.m.
    Congratulation, Paul, on being awarded the 2010 Colin Jose Media Award by the National Soccer Hall of Fame. You deserve it.
  1. Carl Walther
    commented on: August 4, 2010 at 11:25 a.m.
    Slather Blather (as he is referred to here)is the major problem with dirty play and bad refereeing in world soccer. His egomaniac driven personality prevents him from seeing anything approaching reality in the sport. A man who has said that, "FIFA is more important than the U.N." is not emotionally fit enough to lead FIFA.
  1. Brian Something
    commented on: August 5, 2010 at 9:29 a.m.
    "now made more lustrous by knowledge we could not have at the time, that this was the winning goal." But we did. By that point in the match, the Dutch were never in any danger of causing Iker Casillas to break a sweat. The fine structure is even more ridiculous when you consider that of Spain's four cards, one of them was for time wasting and one was for taking a jersey off after scoring... neither of which was anything like the assaults committed by de Jong and van Bommell.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner
Arena and the Lawnmower: Why, Bruce, why ...?    
Bruce Arena's signing of Nigel de Jong is a shameful episode. The most experienced American coach ...
Losing Miazga, Gonzalez, Villafana -- How is that good for MLS?     
Let's see now. Matt Miazga -- we can define him, at age 20, as one of ...
Coming soon: a slimmer, snappier -- and maybe better -- rulebook     
Right now, I'm thinking that IFAB -- you know, the soccer rule-making guys -- have really ...
The MLS PseudoDraft and other obstacles that Latino Americans face in American soccer     
Time for another MLS SuperDraft. It would be better called the MLS PseudoDraft. It might also ...
A new type of coach -- appointed by the sponsors     
Keeping up with the changes and additions to the English language -- I'm talking now about ...
Good luck and bad luck for the Foxes     
You hear it often enough: a team should rest assured that, over the course of a ...
Pawson's Pause gives the game away     
I continue not to understand the negativity that pervades -- though possibly less than it used ...
Will Computer SAM kill off the soccer pundits?     
Mark Lawrenson was once a top defender. He played for the Republic of Ireland, even though ...
The English get a timely reminder from Jurgen Klopp     
I have a problem with Jurgen Klopp: I find it difficult to take anything he says ...
Don Garber is right -- MLS deserves more respect. But it doesn't help its own cause.     
Commissioner Don Garber sounded off recently on the subject of respect, and how he feels that ...
>> SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner Archives