Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
Time to say good-bye to Bradenton
by Paul Kennedy, March 1st, 2011 1:06AM
Subscribe to Soccer America Daily

TAGS:  mls, u-17 world cup, youth boys


[MY VIEW]The USA continued its streak of being the only nation to have qualified for all 14 Under-17 World Cups with five wins in five games at the 2011 Concacaf Under-17 Championship in Montego Bay, Jamaica. Despite Sunday's 3-0 overtime triumph by Wilmer Cabrera's boys over Canada, it's clear the under-17 residency program launched by U.S. Soccer in 1999 and based in Bradenton, Fla., has run its course.

There are any number of yardsticks by which to judge the U-17 residency program:

-- Success on the field.The six first U-17 residency classes produced one fourth-place finish at the Under-17 World Cup, but that's it. The 2-0 win by John Ellinger's U-17s over Mexico in New Zealand at the 1999 tournament remains the only U.S. win in the knockout phase of 13 tournaments, a remarkably poor record.

-- Developing future stars.Ellinger's 1999 team included Landon Donovan, DaMarcus Beasley and Oguchi Onyewu, among others. But few current U.S. stars began their careers in Bradenton or at the U-17 level for that matter. Of the starters against Ghana in the second round of the 2010 World Cup, only goalie Tim Howard, Jozy Altidore and Donovan represented the USA at the U-17 World Cup. Many of the attacking stars on the very promising U.S. under-20 national team either left the residency program before the end of its cycle (Joseph Gyau and Sebastian Lletget) or moved abroad at a young age (Bobby Wood, Josh GattandOmar Salgado).

-- Jumpstarting the careers of young players.Players like Michael Bradley, too young to make the 2005 squad, and Altidore, a reserve on the 2005 U-17 team, benefited from being placed in a full-time soccer environment and made the leap to pro soccer at young ages. The same could be said for Neven Subotic, another 2005 reserve who now stars for Borussia Dortmund and Serbia.

-- Developing a style of play. The work at Bradenton would be beneficial if it instilled in U.S. teams a distinct style of play in the manner of such great programs at those at Barcelona or Ajax, but the teams that have come out of Bradenton have been largely unremarkable. Despite their success in winning the 2011 Concacaf tournament -- Mexico, the 2011 U-17 World Cup host, it should be noted was absent -- the Americans showed little pizazz. Indeed, in the quarterfinals against El Salvador and final against Canada, the USA looked like the second best team on the field for much of regulation.

Much of what was unique about Bradenton has been made moot by the launch of U.S. Soccer's Development Academy and the MLS homegrown program that has seen clubs sign players as young as 16.

In particular, MLS is offering the fast-track player development -- the opportunity for young players to train and play alongside older pros -- that was always lacking in American soccer.

More generally, Development Academy programs are beginning to replicate the daily academy training experience. A few are even adding a residency component. Real Salt Lake has launched a residency program in Phoenix. FC Dallas has its own residency program for Dallas players. The Schulz Academy, a former DA program in South Florida, has launched a new residency program.

Most of Cabrera's U-17s are DA products. Only two U.S.-based starters against El Salvador in the decisive quarterfinals -- Andrew Oliver (Westside United of Indiana) and Alejandro Guido (Aztecs Premier of California) -- were not affiliated with DA programs.

That doesn't mean that DA programs are the be all and the end all of American youth soccer -- after all, Oliver was the U-17s' leading scorer and Guido was their playmaker -- but they will catch much of the talent coming through the ranks.

With or without the residency program -- or a local academy club program for that matter -- Donovan and Subotic (discovered playing in a park in Bradenton) -- would have probably become stars.

And the demise of Bradenton as a residency program doesn't mean U.S. Soccer should drop the U-17 national team program or should abandon its extensive calendar of international trips or domestic camps that should have a special emphasis on providing opportunities for players outside the DA or MLS systems.

The U-17 national team program should continue -- and keep its record streak going for many years to come -- but there is no realistic need for a full-time program that takes a player away from home or out of his local soccer environment.

If U.S. Soccer and Nike were throwing out the idea of launching a full-time national residency program today, they'd probably pass.

So it's time to say goodbye to Bradenton.

  1. Bob Escobar
    commented on: March 1, 2011 at 8:07 a.m.
    With all the money invested (in the millions) for the amount of years this program's been in place, we have not produced one single world class player or anyone close enough to say that American boy came out of our Bradenton program. Landon Donovan, our best American player learned the game elsewhere and the same could be said for a few others....I totally agree with Paul Kennedy, time to say goodbye to Bradenton.
  1. Walt Pericciuoli
    commented on: March 1, 2011 at 8:25 a.m.
    I agree, but how about taking some of that money and allocating it to youth clubs to be used soley for scholarships to qualified players that are unable to afford the local "academy" or what ever you want to call the latest hot shot gimmick.I still think it is important to have a wide net to search for talent and we shouldn't allow talented players to go unnoticed because they can't afford the fees associated with the higher profile clubs.
  1. james knowles
    commented on: March 1, 2011 at 8:48 a.m.
    not so fast everyone. first of all, the mls youth teams are not always the first choice for players in those regions that actually have one. mcbean was the only player to come from chivas or LA even though there were six players from SoCal on team in jamaica. also, a lot of top players are not signed to their mls club's first team immediately out of high school. bradenton is still one of extremely few full-time residency programs in this country and while it takes most of the best in the US and brings them together, i think being hasty about its possible dissolution is very, very dangerous. and to judge it on this year is to not look at all that cabrera has done. the team that went to the 2009 edition was very good and if not for a few unlucky plays, they could have gone far in nigeria (not that winning at this level even really matters).
  1. Marc Silverstein
    commented on: March 1, 2011 at 8:57 a.m.
    FYI. It was 1999 not 1991 that was Ellinger's first Bradenton class. Editing. Take it seriously.
  1. tim francis
    commented on: March 1, 2011 at 10:30 a.m.
    Great athletes are musts, to begin FUN but efficient training in the fine individual skills at the youngest age possible. So how do we lure these athletes away from the higher paying more popular sports? AGREED on providing the money for encouraging less entitled, more athletic players out! Also, we must make the sport more addictively fun to play-- encouraging creativity, laughter, hooting, etc. Have you seen the mood and skill of elite soccer at u9-13? -- Rare creative effective individual skill encouragement, marine-like set-up-the-drill and stop coaching-coaching, serious,bored and frustrated parents and players: smiles and positive shouts only after goals. No wonder so many quit around 13 or 14--they realize that soccer is a lot more frustration and hard work than joy in play. Addictive joy in the dance of the game maybe the thing that gets the best athletes away from basketball, football, and baseball, and gets us the pizzaz needed to win games at the highest levels.
  1. Thomas Easterling
    commented on: March 1, 2011 at 10:40 a.m.
    Here's a potential advantage offered by residential programs: they could allow players from "soccer poor" regions of the country to develop skills they would otherwise not get. If you're looking for the most athletically gifted young people in America, you'd do well to look at the Southeast--that strategy has worked for SEC football coaches, anyhow. But soccer is fourth or fifth fiddle here, behind football, baseball, basketball, and maybe even track. I'd like to see residential programs that poach talented athletes from these sports and give them an opportunity to focus on soccer instead. However, taking soccer players from areas where soccer is already strong isn't necessarily going to give the best benchmark for what residential programs can do. Whatever advantages in technique that can be offered to already strong players, if you can give the same lessons to better athletes, then the latter will win bigger over time.
  1. Albert Harris
    commented on: March 1, 2011 at 10:42 a.m.
    I'd be interested in Cabrera's take on the Bradenton program before making any irrevocable decisions. I've liked the way he seems to be looking at players outside the traditional suburban base of the Bradenton program. We need to develop a consistent coaching style and flow thru the the various age divisions and I do believe he's the man to do it. What happens after they get to Bob Bradley is still a concern, but that's for another thread.
  1. Julio Zarate
    commented on: March 1, 2011 at 7:12 p.m.
    Please, Just get serious!. We are far ahead of becoming a soccer power. We may be good runners, strong players, but skills??? uhh. A good measurement is when we face teams like Argentina, Brasil, etc. They make us dance the tango and samba in every department. We know many excellent players do not have the opportunity of the rich ones. DA, ODP, Showcases, you name it are only designed for those that have money and accesibility. We know many players with good talent that do not have anyway to get to the fields because they are far away or because they parents needs to have two jobs to survive. If they have transportation to the field, then they do not have money to travel out of state, If they can travel out of the state, then they do not have money to pay the 1,500 for ODP or the 3,000 for the DA, plus other tournament expenses. Soccer in America will continue being a failure until everybody has the same opportunities to compete. Then you will see the richie moved out and leave the real skillful players to take control
  1. tim francis
    commented on: March 1, 2011 at 8:13 p.m.
    The lsck of money and skill factors are a lot of the tragic reality, Julio, and there's more: The low relative value of soccer compared to the 'major' sports: basketball, football, baseball, video games and TV. These keep many of our best potential players, rich or poor, going to other sports or electronic ones. That's why we need to make our kids experience in practice and games better than these sports and electronics-- both challenging AND fun-- to make kids intrinsically want to build the skill to build the fun. Then if we can get the 'greed' factor out so that all kids can play, we'll be on our way.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent Soccer America Daily
MLS Countdown: Kaka recalled by Brazil for Centenario    
The announcement came a day too late to benefit the Philadelphia Union, but Orlando City midfielder ...
U.S. Abroad: Gonzalez's Pachuca has edge in Liga MX final    
Omar Gonzalez, who was passed over for a spot on the U.S. Copa Centenario team, started ...
BeIN Sports adds special Copa Centenario coverage    
One vital aspect of soccer's increased television exposure is how events are treated by non-rights holders ...
USA-Bolivia: Spotlight on Pulisic's bid for starting job    
Christian Pulisic has already impressed his coach, Jurgen Klinsmann, enough that he's in contention to start ...
What They're Saying: Jozy Altidore    
"When Haiti qualified, I just thought it'd be a cool thing, because they haven't qualified for ...
TV Report: Fox network twinbill draws 1,613,000 viewers    
Last Saturday's FA Cup-MLS doubleheader on Fox reached a combined 1,613,000 viewers. Manchester United's 2-1 overtime ...
Concacaf turns to NBA for new CEO    
In another step to rehabilitate itself after five years of scandal, Concacaf hired Philippe Moggio out ...
Women's players' strike motions go to judge for decision    
Judge Sharon Johnson Coleman took under advisement competing motions for summary judgment made by attorneys for ...
USL: Lou City's Goodwin off to Harvard Medical School    
Goalkeeper Scott Goodwin announced that he's leaving USL club Louisville City FC to attend Harvard Medical ...
Video Pick: Neymar, his wax figure, and 31 Barca goals    
Brazil star Neymar met his Madame Tussauds wax figure -- poked it, checked under the shirt, ...
>> Soccer America Daily Archives