Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
Copa America final ref had his hands full
July 26th, 2011 12:36AM
Subscribe to Soccer America Daily

MOST READ
TAGS:  copa america, referees

MOST COMMENTED

[REF WATCH] The latest edition of Copa America, the South American championship that is the world's oldest continental national team competition, came to conclusion last weekend when Uruguay beat Paraguay, 3-0. Randy Vogt looks at how final referee Salvio Fagundes and his crew reacted to several tough calls ...

"Refereeing the Copa America final was bound to be one of the most challenging games in Brazilian ref Salvio Fagundes’ career,” says Vogt*.

Vogt's take:

DELIBERATE HANDBALL? “In the third minute, with me watching live on Univision, it looked like Paraguay’s Nestor Ortigoza deliberately handled the ball one yard from the goal line on an Uruguayan shot by Sebastian Coates.

“The replay confirmed the ball hit his hand, which was by his face. If my comprehension of Spanish is correct, one of the Univision announcers said it was unintentional but I disagree as his hand was not in a natural position as it was by his face. If Fagundes gave the penalty kick, he also needed to send off Ortigoza as he had denied an obvious goalscoring opportunity. The ref was relatively well-positioned at the 18 and decided against taking action.”

YELLOW OR RED? “Fagundes could have sent off Uruguay’s Diego Perez in the 24th minute but opted to give him a caution for unsporting behavior. He had committed a studs-up tackle at midfield a second after Paraguay’s Cristian Riveros had passed the ball. For me, it was a red card.”

OUT OF CONTROL. “From that point on, the officials struggled to control the game and the players probably believed that no penalty kicks or red cards would be given. They were right. Six cautions were given, 24 fouls were whistled and seemingly every decision was greeted by outward dissent.

“In the 69th minute, Paraguay’s Pablo Zeballos was pushed inside the penalty area and in the 80th minute, the jersey of Uruguay’s Edinson Cavani was grabbed but no PKs were given.

“In the 85th minute, the ball struck Uruguay defender Sebastian Coates’ hand, which was by his face, 10 yards outside the penalty area and the foul was called, the direct kick was given and he was cautioned. The handling was very similar to what had occurred in the third minute on his shot, inside the penalty area, which was not called on Paraguay.”

GOOD CALLS. “An important decision that Fagundes clearly got correct was when Uruguay’s Alvaro Pereira tripped Paraguay’s Dario Veron that the ref whistled before it became a Uruguay breakaway in the 61st minute.

“Assistant referee Marcio Santiago of Brazil got the very tight call correct as Diego Forlan was just onside before he scored the third Uruguay goal in the 89th minute.

* (Randy Vogthas officiated more than 8,000 games during the past three decades, from professional matches to U-6 gamesHe is the author of “Preventive Officiating.”)



0 comments
  1. John Munnell
    commented on: July 26, 2011 at 10:44 a.m.
    Agree or disagree, I've really been enjoying this feature over the past few weeks. Thanks!
  1. Kenneth Barr
    commented on: July 26, 2011 at 5:41 p.m.
    I agree the third minute incident was a penalty for hand ball but a sending off would have been harsh. Putting the hands up in front of the face is an instinctive protective move so therefore I would not have shown the defender red. I agree with the caution given in the 24th minute, again a sending off would have been a rather harsh decision. It was comparable to the caution given to a Paraguyan defender for a two footed scissors tackle a few minutes later. Could have been red but he chose yellow. I don't to see refs become Hallmark salesmen, a card for every occasion.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now




AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent Soccer America Daily
Canada: MLS clubs begin quest for CCL berth    
Toronto FC and the Montreal Impact are already playing for the third time this season. And ...
MLS Countdown: Timbers seek second helping of revenge    
The defending champion Portland Timbers have yet to regain the form and momentum that swept them ...
Video Pick: A knee-slapper own goal by Alaba    
Bayern Munich's 23-year-old David Alaba has won Austria's Player of the Year honors five times in ...
What They're Saying: U.S. Department of State travel alert    
"Euro Cup stadiums, fan zones, and unaffiliated entertainment venues broadcasting the tournaments in France and across ...
What They're Saying: John Stiles    
"It can't be a coincidence -- it seems almost to be of epidemic proportion." -- John ...
U.S. Open Cup: NASL-USL battle resumes    
Nine NASL-USL meetings, including the first meeting between Oklahoma City rivals Rayo OKC and Energy FC, ...
Video Pick: Yet another Dimitri Payet free-kick golazo    
Euro 2016 host France beat Cameroon, 3-2, in a friendly thanks to a last-minute goal by ...
Video Pick: DaMarcus Beasley scores a beauty    
DaMarcus Beasley, the only U.S. veteran of the 2002, 2006, 2010 and 2014 World Cups playing ...
What They're Saying: Jurgen Klinsmann    
"This is a little bit like two years ago. We talked about that with the Ghana ...
USL Rewind: Louisville City short-circuits Battery    
Charleston's home unbeaten streak dating back 29 games over more than two years ended Saturday when ...
>> Soccer America Daily Archives