Join Now | 
HomeAboutContact UsPrivacy & SecurityAdvertise
Soccer America DailySpecial EditionAround The NetSoccer Business InsiderCollege Soccer ReporterYouth Soccer ReporterSoccer on TVSoccer America Classifieds
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalkSoccer America ConfidentialYouth Soccer InsiderWorld Cup Watch
RSS FeedsArchivesManage SubscriptionsSubscribe
Order Current IssueSubscribeManage My SubscriptionRenew My SubscriptionGift Subscription
My AccountJoin Now
Tournament CalendarCamps & AcademiesSoccer GlossaryClassifieds
Commish Don Garber: Beckham has delivered for MLS -- beyond expectations
by Ridge Mahoney, November 11th, 2011 2:14AM

MOST READ

MOST COMMENTED

[MLS SPOTLIGHT] Expansion, playoffs, MLS Cup hosted by the highest surviving seed, Cosmos, referees, Beckham, player academies, a possible move of D.C. United ... there was all that and more during MLS commissioner Don Garber's annual “State of the League” teleconference call with reporters Thursday afternoon.

Thankfully, nobody brought up promotion and relegation during Commissioner Garber’s teleconference call with reporters Thursday. Perhaps that broken-down horse can finally be put out to pasture.

Just about everything else came up during a 30-minute question-and-answer session that followed about 20 minutes of opening remarks that, of course, bathed the league in a very favorable light. But unlike many past stagings of this annual event, Garber didn’t need to bend the truth until it screamed to create a positive spin.

In a dismal economy, with more established pro leagues suffering at the gate and one of them, the NBA, mired in a deep freeze of labor strife, MLS is stable and trending in the right direction. A stadium impasse for D.C. United, inevitable scheduling conflicts with outside competitions, a maligned playoff format, cloudy domestic and foreign financial forecasts, and a few struggling franchises are concerns yet hardly bellwethers of impending doom.

The league is riding momentum from a string of blockbuster expansion additions, a new television deal with a newly revamped TV network, and a spotty yet serious effort at player development.

An MLS Cup hosted by the highest remaining seed is likely to be formally approved by the Board of Governors, a significant statement, given that since day one it has held the title game at a pre-selected venue. As host, the Galaxy has already sold out MLS Cup to be played a week from Sunday, and is looking into ways to increase capacity at Home Depot Center.

The first question on the conference call, inevitably, concerned David Beckham, nearly done with a five-year contract and poised, perhaps, to help the Galaxy end its six-year championship drought. Selected to the Best XI on merit, not notoriety, and giving his team solid contributions in just about every appearance, he’s erased suspicions regarding his commitment to his club. But as to his future, well, nobody knows.

“I certainly hope to have him back,” said Garber of discussions among Beckham, his representatives, MLS, and AEG amid offers from foreign teams ranging from Xolos in Tijuana to Paris St. Germain in France. “David has delivered for us on all aspects beyond our expectations, on and off the field. David had a terrific year this year. It’s hard to argue that he wasn’t one of the more important players on our fields and really contributed to his team and the league.

“Lastly, I have to say MLS wouldn’t be what it is today if David didn’t decide in 2007 to come play in Major League Soccer. All of us appreciate everything that he’s done. It hasn’t been perfect, I don’t think any relationship is ever perfect. Certainly there are things we might have done a little differently, but all in all it’s been really a big success.”

The proposed unbalanced schedule – there will be a 34-game regular season in 2012, when Montreal becomes the 19th team – is a given, said Garber. Details are still being worked out and the league hopes to reveal details of the plan next week. It is aiming for the earliest release date – late December/early January – of its full schedule since the league started up in 1996. While defending the unbalanced schedule, aside from doing the math, Garber tends to get testy.

“It’s very simple,” he said.  “I’ve described it this way, and I’ve been criticized for it. To me, it’s simple math. Thirty-eight games [when MLS grows to 20 teams] would be almost impossible for us to execute with the other competitions that we are required to play, the weather issues that we have, the stadium availability challenges that exist in a handful of markets, the FIFA dates. All the things that we have to do differently in the United States from what leagues have to abide by in other parts of the world.

“Most important from a competitive perspective is the travel impact in this country. We did some statistics on this, and I think you guys would be shocked to know that the [Vancouver] Whitecaps traveled almost 60,000 miles this year. And the clubs on the lower end traveled around 30,000 miles.”

MLS deserves some credit for tweaking its structure to help its teams compete in the Concacaf Champions League, to cite one example, and working its schedule around the FIFA international dates, which this season forced it to compress the playoffs into a 12-day window. Instead of each team playing all opponents once at home and once away, MLS will double down on regional clashes.

“It’s premature to talk about how it lays out, but I’ll talk broadly,” he said. “We believe rivalries are important, and help drive passion that fans have for their teams - and their desire to watch those clubs, and ultimately hate, on national television.

“One of our objectives is to grow our national fan base, and grow our television ratings. In order to do that, we believe it has to be done from within. Rivalries, we believe, will help be the fuel to drive that energy, and it’s a big part of our strategy.”

Many sports rivalries transcend regional proximity; the Dallas Cowboys and Washington Redskins are bitter foes dating back nearly half a century, and Seattle fans are particularly disliked by their D.C United counterparts since the Sounders took the U.S. Open Cup at RFK in 2009. An unbalanced schedule would also deprive fans in certain markets from seeing certain teams – such as the defending champion -- in their stadiums but Garber believes other priorities are more important.

“There are a lot of factors that go into the decision to be unbalanced,” he said. “We have things that we are going to have to sacrifice.

“But we believe that at the end of the day, the benefits to what we are trying to achieve broadly and strategically, to achieve a vision of being one of the top leagues in the world, will be delivered with the schedule format that we’re going to come out with in a week.”

When asked about D.C. United’s stadium morass during last year’s address, Garber launched into a stinging tirade of frustration. This year’s response was terse yet calmer -- and thus, more ominous -- regarding the key issue of a possible move.

“We are, as I mentioned earlier, paying more to play at RFK than we are at any other stadium than we've ever played at in the history of the league, including stadiums like the Meadowlands,” said Garber. “And [we] have raccoons that are running around in the locker room.

“We need a solution, and I’ve been pushing [president] Kevin [Payne] and [operator-investor] Will Chang to try to find that solution. If that means that if they can’t get a new, improved lease in D.C., they have to move to another facility in the region, I will be supportive of that, and in fact will help them do that.

“And if it means they can’t find a solution in Baltimore, then we’ll have to go through a process – as we did with San Jose – to have to think about potentially moving the team.”
On other topics ..

Garber said despite ownership upheaval, the Cosmos continue to be among the possible groups to operate a second New York team, and other options include Detroit, Las Vegas, and Florida.

The playoff format, which this year was revamped to add two teams and institute play-in games for wild-card teams, is being evaluated.

He praised the TV partnership with Fox Soccer Channel that is about to end and hailed a new deal with NBC Sports Group that takes effect in 2012.



10 comments
  1. Efrahim Fernandez
    commented on: November 11, 2011 at 11:58 a.m.
    Perhaps the product will improve in the future with changes being made in the youth programs. The reality is the competition level is at times not even equal to some higher ranked Div 1 college programs.. The more teams makes an even more diluted talent starved league. I am a soccer fanatic but would rather watch American Football them MLS. Sorry

  1. Amos Annan
    commented on: November 11, 2011 at 12:05 p.m.
    I think the MLS is doing a great job overall and the fan base is finally taking off. I don't thing relegation will work very will in the US, adding doubt to investors, and is not necessary. The current system of MLS and other lower leagues works well.

  1. Phil Love
    commented on: November 11, 2011 at 12:20 p.m.
    Sure promotion/relegation adds excitement, but it's not financially realistic for investors. More likely is that European leagues will drop relegation in favor of an American-style leagues. The travel issues shouldn't be as big a deal for MLS as other leagues since they only play once a week, but notice that MLB, NHL, and NBA play most of their games in regional divisions, with fewer games out of region. MLS at the same level as D-I college? You are high. As an FC Dallas fan, I've seen my share of lousy MLS games, but MLS is still many levels better than college soccer.

  1. Glenn Maddock
    commented on: November 11, 2011 at 12:26 p.m.
    Ok, fans keep beating this dead horse of Prom/Releg. Never going to happen here, so give it up. We already have it here, its called Playoffs. If you're good you get promoted to the playoffs, if not you are relegated to your couch at home. American fans love it that way, and American owners will only do it that way. Travel issue is money not distance. We dont have the budget of baseball or football team. You are not a soccer fan if you dont want to support your local league, its pretty simple, MLS is on par with the average clubs in Mexico and 2nd division leagues in Europe like Holland, France, etc. Thats fine after only 15 years, and in 10 more years we'll be up there.

  1. Ernest Irelan
    commented on: November 11, 2011 at 1:36 p.m.
    travel is a real problem in the USA compared to other countries..in most other countries, a bus is the common mode of travel , that being short trip...I believe the regional playing of teams is better suited to all, also, improved stadiums is a goal to look at..we have weather problems that some countries just do not have..here in USA, it can be a real deterent to spectators an a problem for players, even travel is hindered in the present way MLS teams are expected to do..our high end teams of MLS are on par with many div one leagues in other countries..developement of youth soccer still needs to be looked at more closely..cost of developement puts many potential elite players out of the picture...

  1. Ted Westervelt
    commented on: November 11, 2011 at 1:52 p.m.
    Maybe reporters are realizing that promotion, relegation and unlimited clubs is a federation decision. Perhaps they realize Don Garber's opinion on it is about as relevant as Ronald McDonald's. Sadly, I suspect that reporters have just been warned not to ask.

  1. Ted Westervelt
    commented on: November 11, 2011 at 1:56 p.m.
    Phil, et al. No duh that MLS investors prefer monopoly and anti-competitive practices. That the weakest argument against promotion and relegation of them all. You ignore the fact that a path to promotion enables lower division owners to raise significantly more capital, and interest. Alex Ferguson said end of relegation in the Prem would be suicide for lower division clubs. It's time to admit the lackthereof hurts ours.

  1. I w Nowozeniuk
    commented on: November 11, 2011 at 7:44 p.m.
    Superman, your travel analysis belongs in the bin.

  1. Stephen Johnson
    commented on: November 12, 2011 at 4:42 p.m.
    We all need to get off this promotion/relegation perch. Enough is enough; this is America, not the rest of the world. It just never will work here. So, just let this horse die and put it behind us where it belongs. The league needs to build to an ultimate 24 clubs, which works prefect with the 34 game (play twice within conference, once outside conference) schedule which is the max number of games for the North American market. Again this is America, get use to it and move on.

  1. Daniel Clifton
    commented on: November 12, 2011 at 6:21 p.m.
    I have to agree with Stephen Johnson. This talk of promotion/relegation is just alot of hot air in the US. It is not going to happen. I have enjoyed watching the relegation battles from afar in the EPL. The way MLS is set up it can't happen here. I think the quality of the league is clearly improving. I would like to see better youth development. That is the pipeline for future players. MLS needs to become more soptisticated in player development. I like seeing the teams in MLS that have alot of US players. It is a North American league. My hat is off to the people who have nurtured MLS. It is growing steadily. I watch games played in Seattle and it sounds like an EPL game. Soccer is attracting alot of young fans and is growing in the US.


Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now




AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent Soccer America Daily
Top 20 U.S. soccer crowds    
[CROWD COUNT] Wednesday's match between the LA Galaxy and Manchester United drew 84,632 fans at the ...
Galaxy II signs academy product Jaime Villarreal    
[USL PRO] Jaime Villarreal, younger brother of Jose Villarreal, signed with LA Galaxy II, becoming the ...
Falcao is back! Playing baseball    
[VIDEO PICK: Off the Post] Colombian Radamel Falcao, recovering from an ACL injury, was perhaps most ...
Freddy Adu's latest stop: Serbia    
[AMERICANS ABROAD] A decade after making his pro debut at the age of 14 with D.C. ...
What They're Saying: Robbie Keane     
"Of course, it's embarrassing ... It's embarrassing because we're the LA Galaxy, and the scoreline doesn't ...
What They're Saying: Bruce Arena    
"I think [it's] a real lesson for a lot of players. You talk a lot [during ...
Man United humbles Galaxy 7-0 before 86,432 fans    
[INTERNATIONAL FRIENDLIES] Manchester United showed it had no problem adapting to the system of new Dutch ...
Plans for Kansas City soccer village unveiled    
[U.S. SOCCER] Kansas City, Kan., is home to a state-of-the-art soccer stadium in Sporting Park. Now, ...
Earthquakes break out of slump in big way    
[MLS: Week 20] The San Jose Earthquakes snapped their five-game winless streak with a 5-1 win ...
NBA All-Star interrupts Real Madrid practice    
[VIDEO PICK: Off the Post] Summer soccer in the USA means big clubs from around the ...
>> Soccer America Daily Archives