Join Now | 
HomeAboutContact UsPrivacy & SecurityAdvertise
Soccer America DailySoccer World DailySpecial EditionAround The NetSoccer Business InsiderCollege Soccer ReporterYouth Soccer ReporterSoccer on TVSoccer America ClassifiedsGame Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalkSoccer America ConfidentialYouth Soccer InsiderWorld Cup Watch
RSS FeedsArchivesManage SubscriptionsSubscribe
Order Current IssueSubscribeManage My SubscriptionRenew My SubscriptionGift Subscription
My AccountJoin Now
Tournament CalendarCamps & AcademiesSoccer GlossaryClassifieds
The Martino experiment, Take 1
by Ridge Mahoney, March 12th, 2012 10:43PM

MOST READ
TAGS:  mls, television

MOST COMMENTED

[TELEVISION WATCH] Much of the buildup to the debut of MLS on NBC had focused on a decision to utilize former Fox Soccer analyst Kyle Martino between the team benches rather than in the broadcast booth, yet as he and partner Arlo White demonstrated, people matter more than positioning.

The rapport between the two seemed to flow naturally for most of the telecast during a two and a half window that also featured host Russ Thaler and former Jamaican international Robbie Earle working from a desk near the field. NBCSN brought a crisp, professional sheen to the telecast, utilizing replays smartly and not cluttering up the telecast with bizarre camera placements or in-game fluff interviews.

Only once did the distance between the main commentators generate a glitch, and that came during an awkward moment for any broadcast: as Martino analyzed a replay White had to jump in as the director cut back to live action to show Red Bulls’ keeper Ryan Meara diving to make a save. That happens occasionally in normal circumstances; perhaps sitting side-by-side White could have been able to signal Martino a few seconds earlier but in this case clearly there was no harm done.

White had no such issues regarding the transition from a club gig to national platform. He provided plenty of information – maybe at times a tad too much but that’s a subjective matter of personal taste -- ready to deliver on both teams, including good tidbits and anecdotes from the teams’ most recent meeting in the 2011 playoffs, a 2-0 Red Bulls win at the same locale (then known as Pizza Hut Park).  Rarely did his ample, genuine enthusiasm boil over into outright gushing.

Prior to the game, in an exclusive interview with Soccer America, Martino gave a sharp insight on the perspective from which he sees the game at field level. “Standing on the sideline, the game can be two-dimensional,” he said. “It can be difficult to see the things that are so critical to analyzing the game: the passing lanes, the spacing, the angle of the runs, the positioning of the back line or the distance between the midfield and the forwards.”

Martino agreed that White, who worked Sounders’ telecasts the past two seasons as a lone ranger in the booth, possesses enough background and knowledge to provide observations on formations and tactics along with identifying players and describing play. Thus provided with an outline of analysis, Martino can interpret plays and incidents in context and also critique individual performances and head-to-head matchups.

In a conference call with reporters last week, executive producer Sam Flood and producer/director Pierre Moosa clarified Martino’s role when a questioner referred to it as that of “a reporter.” They stressed he’s an analyst, not a sideline reporter. Still Martino and White nailed the news when Ricardo Villar came up hobbling; White first asked if Martino could see who was warming up; after a brief silence, White noted Bobby Warshaw was getting ready, and Martino explained Villar’s ankle took a blow when Thierry Henry had tumbled into him. Thus the audience was up to speed when Villar, after scoring a spectacular clinching goal on a steal and feed by Blas Perez, left the game in the 74th minute.

The synchronization worked nearly as well earlier in the game when Fabian Castillo, who’d been flaying the Red Bulls from the right flank, took a bad knock and had to be replaced by Carlos Rodriguez, a left-sided player who took over that side and thus pushed Brek Shea to the right. White asked Martino for his assessment of the move, and Marino opined that one advantage would be Shea’s proclivity to cut inside and shoot with his stronger left foot. This is an obvious element, of course, yet one of timeliness and relevance that Marino rightly emphasized on a platform presenting MLS for the first time.

NBCSN pioneered the use of an analyst stationed between the benches in its coverage of the NHL amidst a more turbulent environment of line changes and power-play/shorthanded situations. The proximity of a soccer analyst to the comments of coaches and players – along with field referees and the fourth official -- can offer a cleaner flow of information than presented by two commentators rather than a trio of play-by-play person, analyst, and sideline reporter .

No doubt there will be changes and tweaks as NBCSN and MLS get to know each other better. Considering Martino and White had worked only two preseason games prior to Sunday’s kickoff, their symbiosis going forward shouldn't be a major concern for Moossa and Flood, nor the audience.



6 comments
  1. I w Nowozeniuk
    commented on: March 13, 2012 at 9:56 a.m.
    The game speaks for itself, all these commentators do is blow winded smoke with too much yada-yada which is irrelevant. Same goes for the video cameras that destroy the game with ping-pong zoom-ins and outs. Neither lets the game breathe.

  1. Gus Keri
    commented on: March 13, 2012 at 11:34 a.m.
    First of all, the replays were not always optimal. On two occassions, the director had to cut the replay short to go back to live action. It showed lack of experience on the best timing for the replays. Secondly, the advantage of the new experiment is the fact that the color commentator was reporting from the sidelines which makes the likelihood of blabbering much less and gives the play-by-play commentator more time to focus on what matters the most, which is to describe the action.

  1. Ray Shines
    commented on: March 13, 2012 at 12:21 p.m.
    Gus, given the director is a football director, you have to give him a bit of slack for that. And, yes, Arlo White had much, much more time to focus on what matters the most: who scored in a friendly a year ago, how the Estonian National Team did recently, that Dane Richards and Usain Bolt share a country of origin, and where every player on the field was from. You were talking about that, right? Because Lone Ranger didn't shut up once and let the game breathe. He seemed intent on impressing us with how much he'd studied.

  1. Mj Lee
    commented on: March 14, 2012 at 3:32 a.m.
    Using Kyle Martino as a color guy, when he is so mashed potato bland, is laughable. Arlo should be left to do the game by himself, he is such a pleasure.

  1. Mark Buckley
    commented on: March 14, 2012 at 7:28 a.m.
    Why isn't Robbie Earle in the booth?

  1. Gus Keri
    commented on: March 14, 2012 at 9:42 a.m.
    Ray, there is nothing wrong about adding this information to the telecast. There are a lot of breaks in the game to allow for such additions. But the most important thing is to keep following the game when it's occuring.


Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now




AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent Soccer America Daily
What They're Saying: Sigi Schmid    
"We've got to make sure we right that and get them back for that. I don't ...
August brings no change to Sounders' fortunes    
The way things are going, the Seattle Sounders' season may remembered as before and after Tukwila. ...
Farfan hero, Alvarado goat in Mexico    
Gabriel Farfan came off the bench and scored the winning goal five minutes later to lead ...
Ontario's K-W United FC takes PDL crown    
Top-seeded Kitchener-Waterloo United FC became the third Canadian team to win the PDL championship in the ...
MLS: Seeing isn't believing after 39-goal Saturday    
On a day when Frank Lampard, Shaun Wright-Phillips and Tranquillo Barnetta, among others, made their league ...
What Thay're Saying: Chris Rolfe    
"That was the craziest game I've ever been a part of, in pro soccer." -- D.C. ...
Video Pick: Mourinho tosses medal to young Arsenal fan    
Jose Mourinho brought a smile to the face of a young Arsenal fan when the Chelsea ...
What They're Saying: Economics professor Bruce Corrie    
"There are a number of positive benefits it could have to engage youth, build values, provide ...
Crowd Count: Chattanooga FC draws record 9,236 fans    
For the second year in a row, Chattanooga FC set a National Premier Soccer League attendance ...
Charlotte snaps Rhinos' USL unbeaten streak at 19 games    
The Charlotte Independence got goals from brothers Alex Martinez and Enzo Martinez as well as Pole ...
>> Soccer America Daily Archives