Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
Bayern beats Chelsea in youth matters
by Mike Woitalla, May 16th, 2012 2:59PM
Subscribe to Youth Soccer Insider

MOST READ
TAGS:  england, germany, uefa champions league, youth boys

MOST COMMENTED

By Mike Woitalla

On Saturday, two clubs that have often boasted about their youth programs, meet in the decider of Europe’s most prestigious club competition, the UEFA Champions League. A look at the players who helped Chelsea and Bayern Munich reach the final reveals just how successful they are in developing players.

Chelsea can point to just one player who rose from its youth ranks and contributed to its 2011-12 Champions League run: The 31-year-old John Terry, who is suspended for the final, joined Chelsea in 1995 at age 14.

Since Roman Abramovich bought Chelsea in 2003, he has reportedly invested up to $150 million in its academy program and in 2005 he put Dane Frank Arnesen in charge of producing homegrown talent. Since 2008, Chelsea started partnering with U.S. youth clubs “to assist the growth and development of U.S. soccer at the grass roots.” Yet under Abramovich, Chelsea's youth movement has yet to bear fruit and the club remains dependent on the Russian billionaire’s purchase of established stars. (Arnesen resigned last season.)

Bayern, Germany’s richest club, also buys stars, such as Mario Gomez, Franck Riberyand Arjen Robben, but Bayern’s youth program has been streaming talent to its first team and the German national team.

Six key contributors to Bayern’s campaign came out of its youth program. They include five who after Saturday’s game will join Germany’s Euro 2012 squad:

Outside back Philipp Lahm, the 28-year-old Bayern and Germany captain, joined Bayern at age 11. Forward Thomas Mueller, 22, the Golden Shoe winner at the 2010 World Cup, also arrived at Bayern at age 11.

Midfield linchpin Bastian Schweinsteiger, 27, joined the Bayern ranks at age 14 and Toni Kroos, 22, moved into the Saebener Street dorms at age 16. Central defender Holger Badstuber, 23, arrived from VfB Stuttgart at age 13.

Bayern brings few foreign players into its youth program, but 19-year-old Austrian David Alaba moved 220 miles east from Vienna to Munich at age 16.

With Alaba and Badstuber out of the final with yellow-card suspensions, 22-year-old Munich-born Diego Contento, who’s been at Bayern since age 5, is expected to get his first Champions League action of the season.

Bayern spends about 5 million euros ($6.5 million) a year on its youth program, including its U-23 team that plays in the fourth division.

“It is not a question of budget,” says club president Uli Hoeness. “If we need 5 million, that’s OK. If we need 7 million, we will do it. Because you cannot give a limit. You spend what is necessary. One year 4 million, next year 6 or 7 million.”

Hoeness insists the youth program’s focus is on boosting the first team, not earning money on transfers. But last year it sold 21-year-old Munich-born Mehmet Ekici, who joined the club at age 8, to Werder Bremen for 5 million euros -- enough to fund its academy, which includes dorms for 13 players, for a year.

Bayern’s 185 youth players are aided by 29 full- and part-time coaches, three goalkeeper coaches, two fitness coaches, seven physiotherapists, one doctor and six academic tutors. The club employs one scout for each age group.

“Every time Bayern has been very successful it’s had a lot of players from its youth program,” says Director of Sport Christian Nerlinger, who himself joined FC Bayern as a 14-year-old and won league titles and the UEFA Cup with Bayern in the 1990s. “They have a special identification with the club.”


(Mike Woitalla, the executive editor of Soccer America, coaches youth soccer for Bay Oaks/East Bay United SC in Oakland, Calif. He is the co-author, with Tim Mulqueen, of The Complete Soccer Goalkeeper, and More Than Goalswith Claudio Reyna. Woitalla's youth soccer articles are archived at YouthSoccerFun.com.)



2 comments
  1. Jamie Nicewander
    commented on: May 17, 2012 at 1:26 p.m.
    There is an enormous difference in the spending between these two clubs and yet Bayern, spending a fraction of what Chelsea spends , is taking the lions share of the spoils. Very interesting. Has anyone shared this information with Roman Abramovich? I truly believe that many times these owners with deep pockets are taken advantage of when it comes to player contracts, academy teams etc. It is easy for these people surrounding the professional teams to say, "it takes money to be successful", as an excuse for throwing more money at a problem, and thereby lining their own pockets. The limited time I have been in education and the soccer community I have learned that money does not 'fix' anything by itself and a proper dose of 'rigor' and 'pride' can fix most situations. Results must be the focus. Lets not confuse development with results and believe them to be on opposite sides of the spectrum, rather they dovetail each other actually and each phase of development should be producing the appropriate results.
  1. Carlos Thys
    commented on: May 17, 2012 at 2:13 p.m.
    Jamie Nicewander, I have to agree in full. This is very telling. Chelsea hasn't but John Terry, and he's deservedly NOT going to be on the pitch for once more showing very immature behavior in the previous encounter with FC Barcelona. (Very sad that UEFA will let Terry lift the trophy if Chelsea win on Saturday.) So many fans worldwide can "get behind" a FC Barca because, despire their massive salaries and the club's overall massive debt, so many of the players started at age 13 or 14 and made it to the pros. Some, like Xavi, Iniesta, Puyol, and Messi started even younger. Here's where FC Bayern beats every other big side in Europe: They operate debt free. Annually. And for a very long time. Their financial house is very much in order. In fact, they frequently help bail out traditional but financially troubled clubs in Germany. (To boot, a ticket at the Allianz Arena puts the ticket prices of the Premiership clubs to shame.) And FC Bayern produces youth players who do make it to the very top of the game. Some are now also at HSV, Nurnberg, and in Stuttgart. The only thing that I would disagree on is that Chelsea's boss Roman Abromovich is not fooled by anyone. He knows exactly where his (much of it corruptly earned) money is going. And he has no problem buying his way -- scrupulously -- to the very pinnacle. He cares little if anything springs out of Chelsea's youth program. And it is essentially the same at Manchester United and definitely now so at Manchester City. How fans can really get behind a group of very expensively thrown together mercenaries is beyond me.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now




AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent Youth Soccer Insider
Tips for attending a college ID camp    
With summer being a popular time for young players to attend College ID camps, we've asked ...
Gottschee and FC Dallas take No. 1 seeds into Development Academy playoffs    
FC Dallas and BW Gottschee of Queens, New York, are the No. 1 seeds in the ...
Teen stars sign with MLS clubs    
In the wake of Atlanta United, set to begin MLS play in 2017, signing 15-year-old Andrew ...
How refs deal with trash-talking    
"Look at the scoreboard" and "You got nothing" are two common things that trash-talking players say.
Does American soccer really only work for white kids?    
Les Carpenter's article for the London-based Guardian on American youth soccer is headlined: "'It's only working ...
Changing the Canvas: Finding Inspiration Outside of our Beautiful Game    
My wife is a developmental psychologist. For two decades she has been studying children and the ...
'Toughest World Cup yet' awaits U.S. U-17 girls    
The USA will face Paraguay, Ghana and defending champion Japan in the first round of 2016 ...
John Hackworth: India experience provides valuable lessons for U.S. U-17 boys    
In its third international tournament of the year, the U.S. U-17 boys national team finished runner-up ...
Adding to the alphabet soup of American youth soccer    
If your children play soccer in the USA, they may be playing under the umbrella of ...
Insights on European scouting of U.S. youngsters by 'Arsenal Yankee' Danny Karbassiyoon    
Daniel Karbassiyoon jokes that Arsenal kept him from going to college twice. The first time, at ...
>> Youth Soccer Insider Archives