Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
Frings surgery raises same old questions
by Ridge Mahoney, September 12th, 2012 12:15AM
Subscribe to Soccer America Confidential


MOST READ
TAGS:  mls


Torsten Frings, one of those older former internationals who seem to be flocking to MLS these days, is out for the season.

Toronto FC, which signed Frings last year, announced last week that he will undergo arthroscopic surgery on his hip and sit out the balance of 2012. Thus Frings, 35, failed to play as many games as his age before incurring a serious injury -- he managed 33 league matches for TFC, scoring two goals and registering three assists -- and while his toughness, experience and leadership surely can't be questioned, he didn't do much to lift TFC out of its seemingly perpetual doldrums.

He was also bothered by shoulder and hamstring problems earlier this season, and how much his age contributed to those issues is fodder for speculation, and perhaps, criticism as to how TFC and other MLS teams pay to play these players in the first place. TFC fans and people who cover the team were already wondering a) if he'll be back next year; and b) should he be back next year?

Yet coaches and general managers will always be tempted to make such moves with a liberal policy of international player slots per team. In a way, this can be deemed a reasonable approach, since the risk of signing a player who may not fit in and/or be hit by injuries is lessened by having alternatives available.

But it can also be frustrating to younger players, many of them American, who might otherwise be given a chance. And in many games Frings stood out even if he didn't dominate the play as many expect all Designated Players to do. But, they are also expected to increase their team's potential to succeed.

The thorny question of which players are too old can't be quantified by a number. Marco Di Vaio, 36, has done pretty well for Montreal. He's not too old as long he's producing and staying reasonably healthy, which are really the same parameters as for most players, aside from the biggest stars and young players scaling the development curve.

But since the older foreign players often command a high salary, naturally, the benchmarks are higher, too. In the last weeks of the regular season, and in some cases the playoffs, they will be under scrutiny.

Seattle, which signed German Christian Tiffert last month, is auditioning former Icelandic interational Eidur Gudjohnsen. The Galaxy's trial of Swedish midfielder midfielder Christian Wilhelmsson resulted in him signing a contract.

No team would be more well-set than the Quakes, yet they have brought in English left back Jordan Stewart for a 10-day trial, looking forward perhaps to next year rather than the Sept. 15 roster freeze date after which no changes can be made.

Most of these players are free agents and as such can sign with an MLS team outside of the North American transfer window, which closed last month. Teams looking to upgrade for the playoffs and/or getting a jump on next year are kicking the tires and taking a test drive. If the players are available and willing to go on trial, why not?

Well, if it's that easy, maybe it's too easy.

The policy of eight slots per team has been in force long enough to be re-examined by MLS and U.S. Soccer, which approves such procedures. Both entities are under pressure to enhance their player development programs and if such a large number of foreign slots -- plus green-card holders -- is to continue, it might also be time to look at some youth mandate that would necessitate more young players getting on the field. They, too, need to show they can produce.



1 comment
  1. Ric Fonseca
    commented on: September 12, 2012 at 4:26 p.m.
    It would behoove some young physiology doctoral candidate or some established pro-sports medicine specialist to conduct or come out with some granite-solid conclusion as to what age is "too old." As we all know being a certain "xxxx" age for our sport could be the late 20s (barring career threatening injury) and most likely into the mid thirties; some "veteran" - or as some would be wont to say, "over the hill professionals," can still play into their late 30's still though, Ridge does have a valid point by stating that bringing in these guys is indeed "frustrating to younger players.... many Americans...." who are told the probervial Catch 24 excuse that "gee sorry you don't have much experience, get more playing time and then we'll see," i.e. a danged if you do and danged if you don't. My point? Stop bringing in so many mid-thirty-something guys and give younger players an opportunity to enter an OJT (on the job training) program with an MLS team. And lastly, yes Ridge I agree with you especially the last paragraph! Golly, gee willikers, it might just even work!!!


Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now


AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent Soccer America Confidential
U.S. Report Card: Altidore's goal rewards resilient defensive effort    
A patient and confident U.S. performance was rewarded when Jozy Altidore scored in his fourth consecutive ...
Dempsey subtler but no less important     
The "heat map" is an interesting beast. Media outlets and Web sites use them to represent ...
MLS Power Rankings: Timbers Reach the Summit    
Its shortened schedule to accommodate the FIFA international playing dates turned out to be a case ...
A year out from the World Cup, then and now    
The 2014 World Cup is about a year away. How does the U.S. team compare to ...
Panama game showcased U.S. growth    
Just as far too much angst and worry were expressed in the wake of a 2-1 ...
Uncertainty remains for lots of U.S. players    
As the USA moves closer to returning to the World Cup finals -- the path will ...
U.S. Report Card: Dominant performances abound as USA throttles Panama    
In its 2-0 win over Panama on Tuesday, its most convincing effort in the Hexagonal so ...
Jurgen Klinsmann's best MLS friend    
Jurgen Klinsmann and Sigi Schmid share a lot in common. Both are from the Stuttgart area ...
Jamaica form confounds Hexagonal expectations    
It seems as if many of the pundits, including this one, were wrong about the Hexagonal.
Salt Lake and Sounders Rise as Galaxy Slides    
A light week of five games nevertheless produced some movement in the weekly Power Rankings, with ...
>> Soccer America Confidential Archives