Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
Upon further review ...
by Paul Kennedy, November 14th, 2012 10:16PM
Subscribe to Soccer America Daily

MOST READ
TAGS:  mls

MOST COMMENTED

[MLS CUP PLAYOFFS: Houston-D.C. United]Upon watching replays of Houston Dynamo defender Andre Hainault's takedown of  D.C. United's Raphael Augusto late in the first half of the first leg of their Eastern Conference final series, PRO general manager Peter Walton said Ricardo Salazar should have red-carded Hainault. No call was made, and the Dynamo went on to rally from a 1-0 deficit and win, 3-1.

At halftime, Walton, who had not watched a replay on television, said a foul should have been called but Hainault should have only been yellow-carded.

"From the angle I saw in the stadium I thought it was a foul," he said. "Had there been a foul called, and of course it wasn't, I would've expected a yellow card. Looking at it in real time, I thought the tracking defender [Houston's Luiz Camargo] could have influenced the outcome of that particular play. That was my opinion from seeing it in real time."

Having watched the incident again, Walton said: "In review of that play, my opinion has changed in as much as the defender, which I thought in real time would have influenced the play, clearly was behind the action and therefore the disciplinary sanction should have been a red card for denial of a goal scoring opportunity."

Walton said the play "ticks all the boxes for a denial of as goal scoring opportunity and a send-off should have been the outcome."



6 comments
  1. Robert Buege
    commented on: November 15, 2012 at 8:47 a.m.
    It must be great to have multiple camera angles, stop action, and days to review and critique a decision made in a split second while running with only one angle of view and no second or fiftieth look!
  1. Steven McDonald
    commented on: November 15, 2012 at 9:44 a.m.
    I keep watching the replay and try to find what I must be missing but the only thing I'm missing is a DC biased opinion. I still see the defender had position, neither had control of the ball. DC player initiates contact knocking defender off his feet which in falling down , brings down Augusto. I still see a no call due to playing the advantage.
  1. Steven McDonald
    commented on: November 15, 2012 at 9:58 a.m.
    If Hainault had initiated the contact, everyone knows Augusto would have flopped so quick Olympic judges would be needed to score it.
  1. Barry Thomas
    commented on: November 15, 2012 at 10:38 a.m.
    As a neutral (and former referee)viewing the replays, I thought it was definitely a foul, doubted that Camargo could have caught up with Augusto, and was concerned with the way Hainault (deliberately, IMO) swung his leg into the legs of Augusto from behind. Red card? Maybe. Yellow card? Probably. Foul? Absolutely!
  1. John Yunker
    commented on: November 15, 2012 at 12:37 p.m.
    Hmmm... As also a former referee, I agree with Steven - taking into account only the replay angle from behind (the angle Salizar sees)- the DC player clearly initiates the contact from a shoulder charge (no foul) causing the Houston player to fall - their legs get tangled in the fall. Looking in slow motion from every angle, it appears that the Houston player made sure as he was falling to bring down the DC player. If the DC player had not shoulder charged the Houston player causing him to fall, the Houston player would have been in good position to defend. I'm thinking no foul - just hard play from the angle Salazar saw. (and being from Seattle am NO fan of Salazar)
  1. Joy Hottington
    commented on: November 17, 2012 at 10:52 a.m.
    Isn't that what Assistant Referees are for? Also Barry, a foul in that area of the field with no one else between Augusto and the goal would be a straight red. And Steven, glad to hear you know so much about Augusto given that he's played *never* in MLS before that game.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now




AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent Soccer America Daily
Video Pick: Wood strikes in Bundesliga debut    
It took 23-year-old American Bobby Wood, who scored 17 second division goals for Union Berlin last ...
U.S. Abroad: Johansson returns in crushing Bremen defeat    
Aron Johannsson returned to action in the Bundesliga for the first time in 11 months, starting ...
USA names roster for U-17 Women's World Cup    
Coach B.J. Snow has named the USA's 21-player roster for the 2016 U-17 Women's World Cup ...
MLS Countdown: Vanney gives TFC reminder    
Toronto FC waited through many seasons and head coaches before finally reaching the playoffs last year. ...
Bundesliga 2016-17: Half the teams have a U.S. player    
From age 17 to 28, from newly promoted RB Leipzig to four-time defending champion Bayern Munich, ...
WCQ Callups: USA battles injuries and suspensions    
The roster for the U.S. national team's World Cup 2018 qualifiers against St. Vincent & the ...
NWSL: Olympians back in fold, mostly    
Off for 26 days because of the Olympics -- except for one make-up game -- the ...
What They're Saying: Laura Harvey    
"It's about someone’s livelihood. It’s about their career. Irrelevant of what the decision is and who ...
What They're Saying: Alex Morgan    
"The players don't control any of the consequences that happen, that are enforced by U.S. Soccer. ...
TV Report: MLS and NFL to air joint lineup    
On Sept. 18, Fox Sports will air two live MLS matches -- Sporting Kansas City-LA Galaxy ...
>> Soccer America Daily Archives