Join Now | 
HomeAboutContact UsPrivacy & SecurityAdvertise
Soccer America DailySoccer World DailySpecial EditionAround The NetSoccer Business InsiderCollege Soccer ReporterYouth Soccer ReporterSoccer on TVSoccer America ClassifiedsGame Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalkSoccer America ConfidentialYouth Soccer InsiderWorld Cup Watch
RSS FeedsArchivesManage SubscriptionsSubscribe
Order Current IssueSubscribeManage My SubscriptionRenew My SubscriptionGift Subscription
My AccountJoin Now
Tournament CalendarCamps & AcademiesSoccer GlossaryClassifieds
The unofficial report on the State of the Commissioner
by Paul Gardner, December 6th, 2013 12:24AM

TAGS:  mls


By Paul Gardner

It is fair to say that there are two main events at the end of each MLS season: the MLS Cup final, and the address by Commissioner Don Garber on the State of the League.

It’s Garber’s message that interests me here, but before going into that, I wish to deliver my own end-of-season address on The State of Don Garber. Frankly, I’m concerned. Nothing to do with what he said in his own statement -- which was largely, and justifiably, positive and delivered with a firm confidence that never brimmed over into boasting. (Of course, there were a couple of things that didn’t sound right -- we’ll come to those in a moment).

My worries about the Commish have to do with the way he behaves when he runs into cold weather. Most recently, in Kansas City, during the KC-Houston playoff game, when the temperature was 21 degrees, with a wind chill factor of 10, when all the crowd shots showed fans swaddled in heavy clothing, and particularly with hats. In the midst of all that, here comes Garber without a hat, looking almost flimsily dressed. What is this -- a tough guy act?

I don’t think so -- we’ve seen it before -- I think it was during the MLS Cup in Toronto in 2010, another decidedly chilly event. It’s Commissioner Garber trying to convince people that it isn’t really cold out there, that MLS is not doing anything wrong by scheduling its most important games in hostile winter months.

But this looks like a dangerous obsession. Tomorrow, it’ll be Kansas City again, where the forecast is for 25 degrees. I fear the low temperature may goad Garber into an even more frantic display of defiance. Garber down on the field, presenting the post-game trophies in his underwear? That’s the sort of trouble that obsessions get you into. What Garber should be into tomorrow are things like woolly coats and scarves and hats. Bundle up, Don.

Garber has other, much milder obsessions. Call them ambitions. Like the one about 2022, the year MLS becomes one of the world’s great leagues. Nine years to go, so why not? In two words: single entity. That will have to go if MLS is serious about joining the wider world of soccer. The alternative would be for the rest of the world to switch to single entity. And, you know, Garber seemed to be hinting something like that when, in his State of the League address, he told us how “when we travel round the world” the MLS economic model is admired globally, “they want to know about it.”

Within the confines of the USA and Canada -- and the cocoon of single entity -- MLS has plenty to feel good about, despite the fact that it is, in Garber’s words, “an emerging league” and “still loses money as an enterprise.”

Garber feels good -- with reason -- about the growth of the sport, the multiplying number of soccer specific stadiums, the growing fan interest, and the prospects for expansion.

That is more than enough to give his address an authentic up-beat flavor. But when he talks about player development, he is on shakier ground. His views of college soccer need revising, they are bogged down by an unrealistically rosy vision of what college can do. He has to know that, without large and fundamental changes in its structure, college soccer will never be a satisfactory source of pro players.

Garber is not about to admit that -- but he did make a statement that I have never before heard any top soccer figure venture. He criticized the college game. A gentle criticism, to be sure, but it was a statement that could mark the beginning of a refusal on the part of the bulk of the soccer community in this country to continue meekly accepting whatever the college people decide upon, regardless of its value to the sport at large. Right after he had vowed to “continue to support the college system any way we can,” Garber speculated that the colleges could “perhaps start looking at adapting a bit, so that we can collectively develop the American game better ...” Yes it is a mild rebuke -- but it surely represents a welcome break with the hidebound thinking of the past.

The colleges are not, cannot be, part of player development. If anything, they represent player stagnation, even regression. The growth of the academy system is, to a large extent, a response to the growing awareness that something else, something -- like the impressive new MLS stadiums -- more soccer specific is needed.

Inevitably, Garber proudly flaunts the $20 million a year that he says MLS clubs spend on player development. But this can be utterly misleading, because it is quite clear that massive investment in providing the best facilities and the “best” coaching and so on is no guarantee at all that top level players will be produced.

For that to be more likely, intangible things like attitude and vision and style have to be correct. The U.S. game has a way to go in that aspect of youth development. American soccer, and that includes MLS, has not been -- and still is not -- particularly good at making the most of the abundant talent that this country offers.

  1. Randy Vogt
    commented on: December 6, 2013 at 7:39 a.m.
    After Major League Baseball switched the World Series in the 1970's from day to night games, didn't Commissioner Bowie Kuhn do the same thing and not wear as many layers as everybody else? What will Don Garber be wearing in Kansas City tomorrow night, or for that matter, NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell at the Super Bowl in New Jersey in February? Does the emperor have no clothes?

  1. Gerald Kettler
    commented on: December 8, 2013 at 8:53 p.m.
    who cares what the wearing !It looked liked the majority of the fans were having a raucous time in the stands during the mls cup !the german bundesliga plays many important ,championship games in cold environs. !I like the idea of the best team through the playoffs hosting the championship game and having home field advantage no matter what the temp !St.louis needs to be an mls franchise !

  1. Gerald Kettler
    commented on: December 8, 2013 at 8:57 p.m.
    also,the college system is not the only feeder system of players to mls !usl, nasl,pdl have all contributed good players to mls !

  1. Sonya Anderson
    commented on: January 10, 2014 at 12:58 p.m.
    What is "single entity?"

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner
Seattle's love affair with the Open Cup turns sour    
The controversy surrounding Clint Dempsey and his trashing of referee Daniel Radford's notebook is quite ridiculous. ...
Flying bat at Fenway Park should send warning to MLS    
The recent horrendous "accident" at baseball's Fenway Park, where a fan suffered what was, at the ...
Mourinho defends counterattacking soccer, calls other coaches stupid     
Jose Mourinho has raised, yet again, the old argument about the pluses and minuses of playing ...
Clampdown on tactical fouls way overdue    
My notes on the recent Seattle-Red Bulls game inform me that referee Jose Carlos Rivero called ...
Lincoln Phillips provides perspective on black soccer in 1970s USA    
As a goalkeeper, Lincoln Phillips should not feature among my most cherished soccer memories. I have ...
The remarkable Clive Toye -- who brought showmanship, excitement and color to American soccer    
The debt owed by American soccer to Clive Toye is a vast one. It is not ...
The small guys -- from Jimmy Greaves to Lionel Messi -- are the ones who matter most     
This week has brought home, in as dramatic a way as I ever recall, the joy ...
Concussion dangers still not fully accepted    
If ever proof were needed that the English style of refereeing is a bad model for ...
The Greatest. Remembering Richie Benaud, 1930-2015     
I'll need to switch sports for a moment here. But it's important. The greatest of television ...
Stars? Bah, says Mourinho. The team -- meaning the coach, that is ME, is the one who matters     
Coaches, of course, can be relied on to say something. Without doubt they are the most ...
>> SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner Archives