Join Now | 
HomeAboutContact UsPrivacy & SecurityAdvertise
Soccer America DailySoccer World DailySpecial EditionAround The NetSoccer Business InsiderCollege Soccer ReporterYouth Soccer ReporterSoccer on TVSoccer America ClassifiedsGame Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalkSoccer America ConfidentialYouth Soccer InsiderWorld Cup Watch
RSS FeedsArchivesManage SubscriptionsSubscribe
Order Current IssueSubscribeManage My SubscriptionRenew My SubscriptionGift Subscription
My AccountJoin Now
Tournament CalendarCamps & AcademiesSoccer GlossaryClassifieds
Camilo departure stinks, but it's business
by Ridge Mahoney, January 16th, 2014 10:15PM

MOST READ
TAGS:  mls, vancouver whitecaps

MOST COMMENTED

By Ridge Mahoney

It took a statement from MLS commissioner Don Garber to confirm what had been painfully obvious from the get-go in the Camilo-to-Queretaro mess: claims of confusion over an option clause in Camilo’s contract that caused him and his agent to believe he was a free agent were a smokescreen, plain and simple.

He and his agent -- clandestinely it must be said but that’s how things function sometimes in the global player market –- found a club, Queretaro in the Mexican league, that wanted him badly enough to pay him big money to play and a hefty sum to acquire. The transfer fee will likely be in the range of $2 million and a salary of more than $1 million has been reported.

It will cost Queretaro more. The club knows FIFA could impose a fine for negotiating a deal with a player already under contract to another club, and the worldwide governing body could also fine the league and Mexican soccer association if MLS and U.S. Soccer file a complaint and other paperwork. But “confusion?” Give me a break.

Had confusion been the issue, Camilo and his agent would have apologized immediately and arranged to get his Brazilian butt back to Vancouver or somewhere else where the situation could be discussed. The only confusion here was in their misleading the press, which should have known better than to peddle the story spun an agent willing to pull this scam in the first place. As the days passed and Camilo stayed in Mexico, references to the option “confusion” kept re-appearing even as the Whitecaps’ brass steadfastly maintained the club had retained his rights.

Yes, a team can own a players’ rights, but his heart and soul and mindset are his own, and once a team loses those, it’s game over. He posed in a Queretaro jersey long before anybody on the Whitecaps knew what was going on. Do MLS and the Whitecaps have any recourse that can get him back? Not really.

Technically, he’s breached his contract, but practically, he’s gone.

The situation triggered speculation from pundits and journalists that FIFA would investigate the propriety of option clauses, since FIFA doesn’t specifically authorize them in its statutes regarding contracts and player movement. To read a few reports, you’d think the entire MLS contractual system could come crashing down regarding its use of option clauses.

Uh, no. Use of contract options have been part of American sports leagues for decades and FIFA’s policy is not to meddle in contractual matters that have been upheld in U.S. courts and/or negotiated between respective parties. MLS contracts qualify on both counts and by engaging in collective bargaining with the league office through its union, the players accede to the conditions in those contracts.

FIFA’s aversion to legal battles in foreign courts is well-founded. It simply maintains that if laws are not being violated, it has no standing. And for the most start it stays out of domestic matters.

As an example, trades during the MLS season often occur outside the transfer window and technically should be covered by FIFA statutes, as would domestic loans that are common in many countries. And FIFA does regard loans as they were transfers, and as such, an international loan would have to jibe with the international transfer windows.

But domestic loans, like trades, are not so restricted and thus, neither are trades. MLS can set its own schedule for discoveries, trades, etc., without regard to FIFA mandates other than the primary and secondary transfer windows set by the national FAs.

Now, the Camilo case stinks, big-time. But this has happened before. A Brazilian midfielder, Francisco Lima, played out the 2008 MLS season and was under contract for 2009, but simply walked away and told the Quakes he wanted to play for an Italian lower-division team. Weeks turned into months, and finally San Jose just gave up and released his international transfer certificate. The Quakes could have filed a complaint and sought a suspension to prevent him from playing but that could take months to resolve.

The league office and Garber will be answering a lot of questions in the next few months regarding its heavy investment in the Clint Dempsey and Michael Bradley transfers, among other issues. But in the cases of Camilo and its use of contract options, those ships have sailed.


4 comments
  1. Mike Gaire
    commented on: January 17, 2014 at 12:18 p.m.
    I agree, it totally stinks and I hope the Whitecaps will not just take it lying down but will do something about it! If I was there CEO I sure as hell would!
  1. StrikerBob Norman
    commented on: January 17, 2014 at 12:41 p.m.
    Agreed! But it is the MLS and US Soccer that needs to stand up to Mexican money. As the MLS continues to improve and acquire talent, it will be the precedent set by their reaction to being raided that will determine how much protection their contracts can offer to league owners in the future. File the paperwork with FIFA. Today! Sorry, Vancouver. But if only it was Valeri and Portland involved...!
  1. Damon James
    commented on: January 17, 2014 at 3:59 p.m.
    This is just one of many areas where US soccer (and MLS in particular) departs from FIFA norms. There is an economic incentive for FIFA to avoid stunting the growth of the potentially lucrative US soccer market by making MLS comply with the rules that apply to every other league. Perhaps a bigger issue is that the domestic antitrust liability USSF would face trying to make MLS comply doesnt pose a threat for the league. In other words, USSF doesnt have enough legal power over MLS whip them into shape without FIFA's backing.
  1. James Froehlich
    commented on: January 18, 2014 at 9:43 a.m.
    A question: has anyone determined whether money was the SOLE motivation??

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now




AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent Soccer America Confidential
For once, USA starts off a year just as it's supposed to    
Defensive miscues. Sloppy touches. Blown assignments. Confusion. These negative facets of play have been part and ...
Jozy shows he's still the man up front    
U.S. soccer fans have a love-hate relationship with most of their big stars. For every fan ...
Lee Nguyen on how he parlayed longer offseason into national team success    
Revs attacker Lee Nguyen got his first U.S. start against Iceland last Sunday and turned in ...
Revs' Heaps relishes competition and preaches consistency    
Aside from the apparent departure of Jermaine Jones, not a lot has changed on the New ...
USA-Canada match underscores Olympic issues for Klinsmann    
A games against Canada Friday may be the last opportunity for USA coaches Jurgen Klinsmann and ...
Christian Pulisic, 'the American Jewel,' must be protected    
I can think of 10 reasons we should be excited about Christian Pulisic. Those are each ...
Paths of Miazga and Cropper cross with both at crucial points    
An FA Cup match this weekend between MK Dons and Chelsea is a tussle between a ...
Return of Movsisyan reconnects Real Salt Lake with its rise to success    
After five years in Europe, striker Yura Movsisyan has come back to Real Salt Lake on ...
Coaches-in-training ready to whip LA Galaxy locker room into shape    
With three MLS titles in five seasons with the LA Galaxy and a scoring rate that ...
For once, some healthy signs are coming out of Toronto    
A flurry of offseason moves has strengthened Toronto FC after it conceded as many goals as ...
>> Soccer America Confidential Archives