Join Now | 
HomeAboutContact UsPrivacy & SecurityAdvertise
Soccer America DailySoccer World DailySpecial EditionAround The NetSoccer Business InsiderCollege Soccer ReporterYouth Soccer ReporterSoccer on TVSoccer America Classifieds
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalkSoccer America ConfidentialYouth Soccer InsiderWorld Cup Watch
RSS FeedsArchivesManage SubscriptionsSubscribe
Order Current IssueSubscribeManage My SubscriptionRenew My SubscriptionGift Subscription
My AccountJoin Now
Tournament CalendarCamps & AcademiesSoccer GlossaryClassifieds
Ref lockout is a lose-lose situation for PRO and MLS
by Paul Gardner, March 7th, 2014 1:39PM

TAGS:  mls, referees


By Paul Gardner

It's not easy to see what MLS is gaining from its hard-line stance in the ongoing dispute with PSRA, the referees union.

As things stand, negotiations have ceased and the MLS season will start tomorrow with seven games that will feature what are termed “replacement” referees.

A lockout, says PSRA. PRO (the Professional Referees Organization), which employs the match officials, does not dispute that, but says it was forced into that position because PSRA rejected a short-term no strike/no lockout agreement that would have allowed negotiations to continue while this weekend’s games were played with PSRA officials.

PRO is an ostensibly independent body, but its offices are located within MLS headquarters, while MLS contributes heavily to its costs. There can be little doubt that the big decisions -- like this one on the referees -- are MLS decisions.

The dispute between the parties is essentially about money. According to PRO boss Peter Walton, “We have made a substantial proposal . . . and believe it is very fair and reasonable. Our proposal represents a significant increase above current compensation for referees and places them above the average for officials around the world. We are disappointed it has been rejected.”

The gap is $440,000. That is what PSRA wants, its “last and best” figure. According PSRA’s vice president Steve Taylor, PRO is insisting the gap is closer to $1 million, but he maintains that the $440,000 figure -- which is basically for game fees and salaries -- is the key one. If PRO accepts that, all the other stuff -- working conditions basically -- is to be negotiated.

As for Walton’s insistence that PRO’s offer would make MLS referees among the world’s best paid, Taylor replies that PSRA is comparing the pay to that of officials in other sports in the USA: “PRO’s comparisons are with soccer countries overseas. We don’t work there. We work in the USA and Canada.”

So the replacements (there are other terms that could be used to describe them) will take the field. Who are they? According to Walton, they are “a highly qualified pool of replacement officials all of whom have officiated at the professional level. The pool includes international FIFA officials who have moved here from overseas, former MLS officials and officials who have worked in other professional leagues in the U.S.”

Which raises a whole load of questions as to how qualified and how fit these guys can be. There is also a risk involved for any younger American referees involved, who may be jeopardizing their possible future membership of PSRA. Without that, they would be forfeiting a possible MLS career.

But the larger question mark is whether or not they will be up to the task in the eight games to be played this weekend.

Taylor puts the problem in dramatic terms: “To go this route is an awful decision by them (PRO). It could be a disaster this weekend. I hope the players don’t suffer for it, I hope there are no injuries as a result of unqualified people working these games.”

For PRO, there is a massive irony in this situation. PRO was formed to upgrade the standard of American refereeing that was supposedly poor -- a judgment that I never agreed with. We had, last year a full season of PRO-trained referees, which provided no discernible evidence of any improvement. PRO now finds itself, far from upgrading referees, in a situation where it is using “replacements” -- which must mean a lowering of standards. This is a lose-lose situation for PRO. Because if things go well this weekend, if PRO then hails the replacements ... then one might well ask why we need PRO when referees (described by Taylor as “unqualified”) can do the job as last-minute replacements.

But the lockout is no doubt a harbinger of things to come for MLS. Its days of operating on a limited budget, keeping expenses low, are coming to an end. Inevitably -- MLS, as Taylor points out -- is on the verge of a new TV contract, it is making money from new franchises ... but most prominently, its clubs, as the Clint Dempsey and Michael Bradley deals show, are now beginning to spend big money. It is unreasonable to expect that the referees would not notice all that evidence of growing wealth.

And not just referees. MLS will shortly enter into discussions with the players over a new collective bargaining agreement. The spat with PSRA -- which has not turned out well so far -- is looking like a rehearsal for troublesome dealings with the players.

Negotiations between PRO and PSRA will continue after this weekend. But the atmosphere has been soured. Does PSRA feel it is now facing a hostile adversary? “It looks like it,” says Taylor.

  1. James Madison
    commented on: March 7, 2014 at 6:14 p.m.
    Paul didn't use the "other word," but I will: the replacements are SCABs, and the fans should honor the PSRA by staying home.

  1. feliks fuksman
    commented on: March 7, 2014 at 8:57 p.m.
    Is this lockout worth the risk??

  1. Peter Skouras
    commented on: March 8, 2014 at 8:58 a.m.
    I bet the "Scabs" are just as knowledgeable if not at a higher level than "full-time" MLS referees because the the "latter" are dreadful! O dear.

  1. R2 Dad
    commented on: March 8, 2014 at 9:29 a.m.
    In the areas of Race and Labor, the USA continues to have a difficult time getting beyond our country's past. This is a new union, and MLS has a relatively clean sheet wrt relations with fans, players and referees. Yet as soon as there is a bump in the road it's immediately back to all the acidic posturing, vocabulary and tactics of Detroit. FAIL.

  1. I w Nowozeniuk
    commented on: March 9, 2014 at 1:13 p.m.
    James, u must either be a soccer ref or employed by MLS. Using the term SCABS is quite derogatory, make your criticism based on merit, not perception. FYI, there are a few MLS refs that could be classified as SCABS.

  1. Chris Sapien
    commented on: March 14, 2014 at 1:28 p.m.
    Shouldn't the term "scab" be considered part of what the left always claims is "hate speech" in this country?

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner
Why are England's clubs so barely English?    
With the inglorious exit of Everton -- bounced out of the Europa League by a 5-2 ...
Why are goalkeepers allowed to get away with this?    
The picture below is from Saturday's Dallas-Kansas City game. It shows Dallas goalkeeper Chris Seitz in ...
Kaka comes through; Villa not quite; Kelly not at all     
The great Orlando-New York clash managed to do what so often doesn't get done ... it ...
IFAB nearly gets one right, UEFA gets it all wrong    
Well, well -- how about this? Had to happen some time, I suppose, so here we ...
Europe embraces Latino flair, how about the USA?    
Ten minutes into Tuesday's Champions League game between Manchester City and Barcelona, TV commentator Martin Tyler ...
In search of youth soccer ... and do we really want it anyway? Part 3: Street soccer -- to be crushed or cherished?     
The purest form of youth soccer -- maybe it is really the only form -- is ...
In search of youth soccer ... and do we really want it anyway? Part 2: Correcting bad habits, or the intrusion of the adults    
Youth soccer is a manifestly imperfect sport. What else would one expect from kids, anyway? It ...
In search of youth soccer ... and do we really want it anyway? Part 1: The young naive mischief-makers ...    
Back in 1977 FIFA initiated an under-20 tournament and called it the FIFA World Youth Championship. ...
Argentina shines; Brazil not so much    
The way I look at it, Brazil owes us something. Us. Meaning the vast world soccer ...
Tab Ramos and the Soccer Speed Trap    
Comparing his very ordinary current under-20 team with the highly promising version he had two years ...
>> SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner Archives