Join Now | 
HomeAboutContact UsPrivacy & SecurityAdvertise
Soccer America DailySoccer World DailySpecial EditionAround The NetSoccer Business InsiderCollege Soccer ReporterYouth Soccer ReporterSoccer on TVSoccer America ClassifiedsGame Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalkSoccer America ConfidentialYouth Soccer InsiderWorld Cup Watch
RSS FeedsArchivesManage SubscriptionsSubscribe
Order Current IssueSubscribeManage My SubscriptionRenew My SubscriptionGift Subscription
My AccountJoin Now
Tournament CalendarCamps & AcademiesSoccer GlossaryClassifieds
Klinsmann plays the formation game
by Ridge Mahoney, June 10th, 2014 6:32PM

TAGS:  mls


By Ridge Mahoney

Out with the diamond, in with the Christmas tree.

Or did the USA play with more of a pentagon in midfield while beating Nigeria, 2-1, on Saturday in its final World Cup warm-up match? An ESPN pre-game graphic showed a 4-2-3-1 alignment, which with two holding mids and a line of three midfielders in front of them probably best resembles a trapezoid. 

A formation is a starting point, a framework, for how players align themselves on the field. It necessarily shifts and changes as situations develop and more important than how it looks from the stands or on television is how it functions, and there’s geometry within that geometry, too. 

One of the keys for high-passing, high-movement teams such as Barcelona is the players’ ability to shrink and expand triangles of different shapes and sizes all over the field. One of the keys for the USA against Nigeria was using Jermaine Jones and Kyle Beckerman as double pivots; they stayed connected most of the time and moved together to protect the back line and funnel balls forward. Michael Bradley used this foundation to cover great expanses of the field, and the ostensibly wide midfielders -- Alejandro Bedoya and Clint Dempsey -- were able to tuck inside and open up space for the outside backs.

The diamond midfield used primarily against Azerbaijan and Turkey wasn’t designed as a blueprint for the World Cup, though at times in Brazil the American alignment could resemble it. Head coach Jurgen Klinsmann has constantly put his players, both collectively and individually, into uncomfortable situations to force them into decisions. He’s changed formations and tactics and personnel at halftimes of games to broaden their range of experiences as well as alter the game’s dynamics. He doesn’t say so publicly, but he’s been willing to sacrifice a result for a worthy experiment. While winning all three warmup games, the USA encountered several obstacles.

Against a bunkered Azerbaijan, the USA struggled in cold, windy conditions. Turkey’s attack exposed one of the diamond’s great vulnerabilities, that of a lone holding mid –- in this case Jones –- trying to cover the vast space in front of the back four. But the defensive breakdowns were not solely the fault of Jones; the Americans didn’t cover for each other quickly enough. 

Teams that consistently play the diamond, such as Real Salt Lake in MLS, work constantly on the positioning and cohesion necessary to imbue defensive stability and how to break out when possession is won. The diamond shrinks and flattens out when RSL is defending, and expands in the attack. 

Bradley is an ideal player for the attacking tip of a diamond, but who can play the defensive point at the other end? Beckerman does an incredible job for RSL yet at the World Cup level there aren’t many men who can do that job alone. If the outside mids pull back and tuck in, the attack suffers greatly. RSL has refined its system so well that players step in where they are needed, which is the essence of any successful system in the modern game.

Klinsmann is trying to take the USA into a new era, that of a national team pool sufficiently stocked with talented, intelligent players who can flourish in different formations and systems. At times, he’s resorted to the familiar and comfortable 4-4-2, yet that alignment can be played so many different ways -- which is one of its strengths -- it’s not as standard as it once was and some observers have declared it obsolete. While most teams play with four in the back, there’s almost infinite variance in what the other six are supposed to do.

But the coach knows well that the chalkboard is not the field. He’s stressed the technical and psychological aspects along with the tactical. Since taking the job nearly three years ago, he’s compiled an amazing amount of data on dozens of players. He’s put them in demanding situations and watched their reactions. Ideally, a formation maximizes the strengths of the players selected. Yet during a World Cup match every player will confront moments of crisis. If opponents focus on stopping Bradley and Dempsey, how does the USA adapt?

One of the major talking points of every World Cup is which teams got their formations and systems right, and which did not. For the Americans, this brutal set of matches will be a measure of where they are as players, whether or not Klinsmann devises the perfect game plans. 


  1. Gus Keri
    commented on: June 10, 2014 at 7:30 p.m.
    I think Klinsmann will use a diamond against Ghana, but not in the midfield. The diamond is going to be in the attack, in front of the defensive midfield duo of Jones and Beckerman. The attacking diamond will consist of Bradley in the back, Altidore in the front, and Dempsey and Bedoya on the sides.
  1. cisco martinez
    commented on: June 10, 2014 at 7:44 p.m.
    There you go Mahoney, a 4-3-2-1 Christmas tree! If Ghana comes at the USA with a lot of midfield runs, the 4-3-2-1 will ussually do a good job at blocking the runs; my only other concern is our defense turning the ball over in our own third, as what happened in Turkey and Nigeria game. Ghana's forwards make some inside out runs which destroyed S. Korea.
  1. I w Nowozeniuk
    commented on: June 11, 2014 at 9:52 a.m.
    I could care less; team chemistry, effort, and execution is the key. Hopefully that can be done over more than 20 minutes.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent Soccer America Confidential
Year of parity marks 20th MLS season    
There are certainly some poor teams in MLS this season for which parity seems a long ...
MLS: Best of September    
More brilliance from the Atomic Ant, another top forwar.d robbed by the league's all-time shutout king, ...
Sporting KC isn't about to rest on its impressive laurels    
There is a lot to like about Sporting Kansas City. Its ownership group has built one ...
Does the Open Cup final need a home, too?    
Since closing of the U.S. Soccer Hall of Fame building in Oneonta, N.Y,. five years ago, ...
MLS home teams are winning at a near-record pace    
Has the rapid pace of MLS expansion and corresponding increase in soccer-specific stadiums translated into better ...
MLS stars align at just the right time    
September was a crazy month in MLS. Not once but in two consecutive weeks the top ...
Western Conference race merits attention from all MLS fans, regardless of loyalties    
By expanding its playoff field from five teams per conference to six, MLS has broadened interest ...
The case for and against a summer off    
We should know soon enough whether the Copa Centenario goes ahead as planned -- the final ...
My 23 for Mexico    
Just about every U.S. fan is anxious to see who will be picked to face Mexico ...
Fire plagued with questions in aftermath of latest shakeup    
Who in their right minds would be encouraged by yet another shakeup at the Chicago Fire?
>> Soccer America Confidential Archives