Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
MLS Goal Award: A Modest Suggestion (again)
by Paul Gardner, December 12th, 2016 12:52PM
Subscribe to SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner

MOST READ
TAGS:  mls

MOST COMMENTED

By Paul Gardner

I've been looking at the Goal of the Year winner. A wonderful free kick by Colorado’s Shkelzen Gashi. A hell of a goal.

A worthy winner, then? Well that depends. The MLS award is clearly intended as an individual award -- the goal comes with a player’s name attached, and that’s the guy who gets the award. By that criterion, yes, Gashi’s goal is a worthy winner.

Which is fine ... as far as it goes. But goals are frequently not solo efforts. The classic example of a team, as opposed to an individual, goal came from Argentina during the 2006 World Cup. One of its goals in a 6-0 win over Serbia & Montenegro came after a dazzling 24-pass sequence. The scorer of the goal, Esteban Cambiasso, was left really with a simple tap-in.

There is no way that Cambiasso could be given all the credit for that goal, that would be ridiculous. So the goal would not be considered for an award under the MLS system, which relies on crediting an individual. Yet it seems equally ridiculous to just ignore such a remarkable goal.

I’ve been into this topic before, in this column. In 2005 I suggested to MLS that it should add a couple of awards to its already formidable list: An Assist of the Year award, and a second Goal of the Year -- this one a team goal.

My very generous offer -- I told the MLS guys it was for free, no strings attached -- was, you’ll be amazed to hear, totally ignored. So, nothing daunted, I returned to the matter in 2006, repeating my unbelievably generous offer.

That was 10 years ago, and I have to report that it met the same fate as the original suggestion. It fell upon stony ground. It was greeted with all-embracing silence. Time to try again, don’t you think?

The idea of an assist award speaks for itself and I like the idea because it would honor playmakers. But maybe the concept of the team award needs some explanation. I outlined my thinking back in 2005, and used the same words in 2006. They seem to set things out satisfactorily to me, so here we go again, trying to capture the essence of a team goal:

“Such goals as these have a different quality from a sudden explosion of individual skill, they allow a few seconds of anticipation as the excitement builds to its zenith. That expectancy, that feeling of growing excitement is an important part of the game -- it would be nice to see it studied and to see it rewarded at the end of the season.”

You know, if it’s thought too difficult to assess such a goal -- it would, I think, call for an aesthetic as well as a soccer judgment, there might be another way of making the decision. A mathematical one: simply count the number of passes.

Can’t say that particularly appeals, but it does open up other possibilities. A number can be compared, infallibly, with other numbers. Thus, those 24 Argentine passes may be a world record, for all I know -- but it’s a total that’s there to be beaten. Not superseded by someone’s differing opinion, but by the mathematical certainty of a superior number.

All of this, of course, is predicated on the assumption that MLS teams are capable of scoring goals at all. If the recent MLS Cup final is any indication, they are having a lot of difficulty in that department. If a real drought sets in, that will solve all questions of competition, and The Goal of the Year will be just that. The One and Only Goal. I jest. I hope.

MLS can get this geared up for next season. Fan voting I suppose would come into it, though I continue to find online voting a too easily manipulable mechanism.

Or maybe the first thing that comes into mind when the MLS and suchlike people think of an award is that it would need a sponsor. My thoughts on sponsors are well enough known -- I mean my dislike of the way that their dismayingly commercial approach soon infiltrates everything they get anywhere near.

That prospect fills me with dread and gloom. So, while the sky is still bright, how about it you MLS guys? This, I feel quite certain, is my final offer. So don’t miss out on this unique opportunity ... or does that already sound like a sales campaign?



11 comments
  1. KC Soccer Dad
    commented on: December 12, 2016 at 1:26 p.m.
    Just make your own list Paul. Goal of the year - individual __________. Goal of the year - team __________.Assist of the year ___________. You obviously watch the MLS way more than I do. I'm looking forward to seeing your esteemed list.
  1. Scot Sutherland
    commented on: December 30, 2016 at 12:48 p.m.
    This. +10
  1. Mark Headley
    commented on: December 12, 2016 at 1:52 p.m.
    team goals are one thing. the last pass, the "assist," is often not the key, most impressive one, however. and a long succession of passes maintaining possession are unlikely to each add to cumulative penetration/breaking down the D.
  1. Allan Lindh
    commented on: December 12, 2016 at 2:01 p.m.
    Awards are just froth on the beer. Start hiring good refs and ordering them to punish violent play directed predominantly at skill players. That will start the evolution toward a league worthy of respect. (And I mean PUNISH, like in 3 game bans without pay. Second offense, 6 games without pay. Etc. Run the thugs out of the league.)
  1. Joe Linzner
    commented on: December 12, 2016 at 2:17 p.m.
    I agree that very often the actual scorer gets the credit but getting the ball to the scorer very often deserves the credit. EG, how many of JAs goals are tap ins and how many is he responsible for alone? Which is why the supposed golden boot award is so very misleading. Let's take success ratios. How many opportunities for tap ins were made and or missed by a scorer and additionally how many runs to put himself into a scoring position are made in lie of ball watching or throwing up hands because the ball did not fit into silver plate servings? There should be individual excellence and team excellence. Agree with Mr. Gardner on this one.
  1. Steven SIegel
    commented on: December 12, 2016 at 2:27 p.m.
    I am far more impressed with some element of teamwork combined with outstanding individual effort. certainly with GOTY, we can have a superlative goal that exemplifies both. Is that too much to ask that a league produces a single goal like that once a year?
  1. I w Nowozeniuk
    commented on: December 12, 2016 at 4:22 p.m.
    Who's the MLS referee of the year...they all should win the award.
  1. schultz rockne
    commented on: December 12, 2016 at 4:51 p.m.
    As we ponder this most tepid year in United States soccer...better: The MOSL (Major Outdoor Soccer League) Crudest Tackle of the Year; and to honor those all-important referees: MOSL Non-call of the Year (presented by former Bay Villager and former Liverpudlian Brad Friedel).
  1. frank schoon
    commented on: December 12, 2016 at 5:18 p.m.
    I like to see an award for the team that can string 3 passes together!!
  1. Miguel Dedo
    commented on: December 12, 2016 at 6:10 p.m.
    Amen on the idea that a goal is a team achievement. KCSocccer Dad has a good idea, Soccer America should select and post its own set of awards.
  1. Scot Sutherland
    commented on: December 30, 2016 at 12:50 p.m.
    Good call PG. I have always wanted an Assist of the Year and a Team Goal of the Year as well. I think Free Kick of the Year would be a good one as well. How about adding Pass of the Year to the list? We in American like to give out awards, let's just go all the way with it.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now




AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner
Clearance: an ugly play, a useless stat     
For some time now I have been wondering about the soccer term "clearance." A term, admittedly, ...
Roberto Cabanas & the Beautiful Game    
From the happiest of thoughts and memories about Roberto Cabanas to total bewilderment and sadness ...
Soccer & Concussion (Part 2): What needs to be done -- before the lawyers move in     
The suspect nature of the enforcement of protocols is by no means the only barrier to ...
Soccer & Concussion (Part 1): A Disgraceful Lack of Action -- Protocols are not enough     
There is, it seems to me, one thing above all others that soccer totally failed to ...
Toronto 0 Seattle 0 -- Another Forgettable Final     
Another decidedly non-memorable final. Maybe we get the finals we deserve. Scrappy, at times ill-tempered, incoherent ...
Will fear of goalscoring affect MLS Cup 2016?     
Back in the 1970s I recall watching a soccer panel on English TV. They were discussing ...
The Klinsmann Interlude (Part 3): Damage Repair -- Bruce Arena returns: Tab Ramos waits     
Bruce Arena never had any doubts about his own ability to move smoothly and successfully from ...
The Klinsmann Interlude (Part 2): Total Failure to Acknowledge Latino Presence    
For decades now, a very special and specific conundrum has been making its presence felt in ...
The Klinsmann Interlude (Part 1): A Sorry Experience for American Soccer     
Sunil Gulati has done the difficult thing, fired his buddy Jurgen Klinsmann -- someone he had ...
The Howard Years -- Remembering Keith Aqui (1945-2016)    
There comes a reminder -- a sad reminder, alas -- from the 1970s. The death of ...
>> SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner Archives