Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
College policies need overhaul
by Ridge Mahoney, December 16th, 2008 9AM
Subscribe to Soccer America Confidential



With the college season concluded and the MLS Combine and 2009 SuperDraft just a few weeks away, the time is ripe for the league to revise its policies regarding college players.

But it won't. A league that has coupled its SuperDraft with the NSCAA Convention to rake in a decent crowd for the proceedings has systemically and shamelessly hacked away at the college game.

A player who leaves college early can sign a Generation adidas contract, which comes with a nice bonus, and receive roster protection. A four-year player only gets a decent contract offer if he's picked in the first round; otherwise, he gets the minimum or a developmental deal.

Some pretty good college players opt for Europe not because they have grandiose dreams, but they see a way to earn a decent wage playing soccer rather than living with their parents or sleeping on somebody's couch.

Since the draft is held in January, during the European secondary transfer window, if an MLS team wants an elite player who might be thinking about Europe, it must take him in the first round to have any chance of a competitive contract offer. Many players will opt for Europe anyway, but not all of them will.

The smart thing to do is to wait and take him later, so as not to possibly waste a first-round pick on a player headed to Europe, but if a team does that, MLS policy usually dictates he'll get the minimum salary, if that. Case in point: Greg Dalby, drafted by Colorado in the second round, went overseas, didn't cut it, and haggled for months before accepting a deal from MLS for $33,000 rather than the $55,000 he asked for.

This also fits perfectly with the league's stance of punishing any drafted player who does find a spot in Europe and eventually decides to return. But it worked great in the case of Taylor Twellman, scorer of 23 goals as a $24,000 player in 2002, didn't it?

Former Crew head coach Sigi Schmid has a suggestion: grant every player taken in the first round roster protection, whether he's a GA player or not. "That's something that has been brought up, for sure, and something I've brought up as well, and been discussed," says Schmid, who in the past month has won the Coach of the Year Award, brought the Crew its first MLS Cup, and triggered a contentious move to Seattle that resulted in the expansion team surrendering allocation money and paying a fine to get him.

"We shouldn't necessarily punish a guy who's a 21-year-old senior and reward a 21-year-old junior who comes out early and is Generation adidas. So then teams look at the players and think, 'Do we take this 17-year-old because he's protected, or do we draft this 21-year-old who we think can help us?'

"You'll get a truer reflection of a player's value in the first round, and beyond the first round, Generation adidas guys are still protected and still have their premium."

MLS isn't in the business of sustaining college soccer, of course. It's making a pretty good go of succeeding as a business where so many leagues and projects have failed miserably. As the league expands, there are more first-round draft slots, but the field is tilted so heavily in favor of Generation adidas players that too many capable four-year players get caught in the squeeze.

In collective bargaining agreement negotiations to commence next year, the MLS Players' Union will have many issues to address, but one item that should be on the agenda is the stringent salary restrictions on college players taken after the first round. By whatever bizarre formula the league is putting "some" money saved by elimination of the reserve league "back into" the salary cap, that money can go to good college players who deserve more than a "take it or leave it" deal at the minimum salary.

The cessation of the reserve league and elimination of four developmental slots may, in the long run, actually accelerate the development of some players by taking them off the fringes of MLS rosters and force them overseas or to the USL. Ergo, they will either sink or swim, not float along aimlessly. And those that do get on a roster deserve a decent salary.

Schmid and others would also like to see a return of a summer showcase for college players, by which they train with MLS teams for two or three months and compete against each other in matches. Quakes general manager John Doyle believes both teams and players would benefit from training and observation as a de facto reserve team without any contractual obligations to MLS.

"We're right at Santa Clara," says Doyle of Buck Shaw Stadium and training facilities the Quakes utilize at the university. "They're off a little this year but traditionally they're a very good program. With USF, Stanford, Cal-Berkeley, San Jose State - I know I'll leave somebody out and get in trouble - and UC Davis has a good program this year, if we got to keep all those kids in a 100-mile radius that no one else could take, that would be a pretty good reserve team. And a lot of them come from Northern California, so they've gone through the youth clubs that we know."

The hangups, of course, would be NCAA restrictions. Yet college players in basketball and other sports are permitted to practice and play in similar environments. Hammering out the details would be difficult but not impossible.

And local players - from colleges, high schools, clubs, whatever -- have been training with MLS teams, unofficially of course, since the league started and no comets have crashed into the earth as a consequence.

At least, not yet.

  1. Sean Markus
    commented on: December 16, 2008 at 12:32 p.m.
    It is a complicated issue, with no easy answers. Generation Adidas was orginally created as an alternative to playing in college. At the time there was a prevailing philosophy that college soccer couldn't provide a high level of competition for talented players. Besides its beggining good intentions, Generation Adidas has turned into an alternate plan for athletes who flunk out of school. At the same time, Generation Adidas is not entirely to blame. The MLS shares of the blame for trying to have an NFL style draft, instead of coming up with a solution that works for all. The biggest problem with the MLS as whole, is it is a "Love Boat" league. Just like the crappy Aaron Spelling dram-edy of the early '80's, the MLS catches stars players either on their way or their way down. Very few of the countries best players are playing in the MLS.
  1. Paul Bryant
    commented on: December 16, 2008 at 10:32 p.m.
    I wonder how much playing time these Generation Adidas players get during the MLS season? Not to sound crass, but a $33,000 salary is not bad playing in a fledgling league like the MLS. Hey, you earned your college degree, you're playing soccer, what a life!

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent Soccer America Confidential
Michael Bradley: USA prepared 'to tilt the bar in our favor' early against Honduras    
As they train in San Jose for a crucial Hexagonal match against Honduras on Friday, the ...
Next move for Real Salt Lake is the most crucial in a decade    
The history of RSL is one of remarkable stability -- just three head coaches since starting ...
U.S. roster announcement: Bruce Arena's return marked by a singleness of purpose    
Multiply the left-back debate with a few more positions each with several candidates and you'll have ...
Quakes encouraged but not giddy after impressive opener    
Four seasons without playoffs has left the fervent fans in San Jose discouraged, but a ray ...
MLS 1-22: Ranking the teams on the eve of a new season    
Eight different teams have played in the last four MLS Cup finals and last year, 2015 ...
Random thoughts as the MLS season draws near    
The 2017 MLS season starts next Friday, March 3, more than a month earlier than the ...
Walker Zimmerman joins the U.S. centerback pool with solid performance    
Two FC Dallas centerbacks were summoned to the first U.S, camp of 2017 and after Matt ...
Rare USA golazo inspires some hope    
One swallow doesn't make a summer, but the USA delivered something impressive with its goal in ...
Greg Garza, soccer wanderer, finds place to start anew, again    
A long voyage to several continents has led U.S. international Greg Garza to the MLS startup ...
With first Arena game out of the way, U.S. players can re-focus on task at hand    
The message going forward for the U.S, team after it opened 2017 by tying Serbia 0-0 ...
>> Soccer America Confidential Archives