Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
Man. United youngsters stun MLS All-Stars
by Ridge Mahoney, July 28th, 2010 10:04PM
Subscribe to Soccer America Daily

TAGS:  mls


[MLS] A sellout crowd of more than 70,000 and seven goals provided MLS with the atmosphere and excitement it wanted for the All-Star Game, won by Manchester United, 5-2, Wednesday at Reliant Stadium in Houston. Here's what we liked and didn't like about the 2010 MLS All-Star Game ...

What we liked ...

-- After several seasons of filling up a few of its smaller, soccer-specific stadiums for All-Star Games, MLS went big-time in terms of facility and opponent. The aura of Manchester United, not seen in the USA for six years, prompted huge advance sales, and added attractions like Landon Donovan and Brian Ching and Mexican star Javier “Chicharito” Hernandez packed Reliant Stadium with 70,728 fans.

Man United will make further inroads into the Mexican market by playing the first match at Guadalajara’s new stadium Friday. Hernandez, sold by Guadalajara to United for a fee in the range of 7 million pounds ($10.7 million), is scheduled to play a half for each team. His goal showed he’s not being bought solely for marketing purposes, and the fans in Houston can brag forever that they witnessed his first goal in a United shirt.

-- Man United left many veterans at home for this tour, and in this match its young players came out in force. Many fans came out just to see Hernandez, and he scored United’s fifth goal with an elegant lob, yet a player four years younger -- Federico Macheda, just 18 -- hit the first two. Darren Gibson, also 22, nicked the third, and Tom Cleverley, 20, scored the fourth goal with a clever dink over defender Wilman Conde and cool first-time finish.

-- Goals light up any match, but watching teams share a dozen or more goals through languid defending takes away the rarity value of goals, and much of the excitement, inherent to a competitive match. Such as been the case with East vs. West and other All-Star Game matchups. The MLS All-Stars tried to stop Manchester United, but a line of defenders unaccustomed to playing together surrendered numerous chances in the highest-scoring All-Star Game played in the current format. United came at the All-Stars eager to wipe out the memory of a 2-1 loss to Kansas City on Sunday and the MLS players weren’t ready for the pressure.

-- Local hero Brian Ching headed in the All-Stars’ first goal on a free kick served by FC Dallas attacker David Ferreira, and former Dynamo Dwayne De Rosario scored the second with a sharp low finish inside the far post. Current Dynamo midfielder Brad Davis nearly scored twice, but both shots came back off the woodwork.

What we didn't like ...

-- The All-Stars took about 20 minutes to settle into the game, and by then they were two goals down. A terrible pass by Kevin Alston sent Macheda in alone on goal to score after just 20 seconds, and minutes later, a giveaway by Heath Pearce provided United with a counterattack chance it nearly converted. Macheda scored again in the 12th minute on a set play with a close-range header and no opponent near enough to challenge him.

A disjointed performance and set-play confusion is to be expected, since the All-Stars had only a brief training window, but several players struggled with simple traps and touches in the early going. United’s players were seldom guilty of such technical deficiencies, though they did concede Ching’s goal on a free kick.

-- Scheduling deprived the All-Stars of an optimum performance and the fans of seeing the MLS representatives at their best. De Rosario and Donovan played Tuesday night for their clubs in the Concacaf Champions’ League; neither got into the game until the second half, and Galaxy striker Edson Buddle never got off the bench. Sounders Steve Zakuani and Fredy Montero, who could have livened up the All-Star attack, were occupied during the All-Star Game with their own Concacaf match on Wednesday.

As evidenced by the crowds and excitement generated by Man United’s visits to Chicago (for training), Toronto, Philadelphia, Kansas City, and Houston, adhering to its scheduling necessities overrode the inconvenience of Concacaf conflicts. And All-Star Game distractions can’t be blamed by the Galaxy, drilled at home 4-1 by Puerto Rico Islanders on Tuesday with Buddle and Donovan on the field.

MLS All-Star Game
July 28 in Houston
MLS All-Stars 2 Man. United 5. Goals: Ching 64, De Rosario 90; Macheda 1, 12, Gibson 70, Cleverley 73, Hernandez 84.
MLS All-Stars -- Ricketts (Rimando, 46), Olave (Gonzalez, 46), Alston (De Rosario, 74), Marshall (Conde, 63), Pearce (Donovan, 74); Le Toux (Convey, 46), Morales (Moreno, 63), Joseph (Davis, 74), Barros-Schelotto (Ferreira, 46), Pappa (Larentowicz, 46); Angel (Ching, 46). Subs: Buddle. Goal:
Man. United --  van der Sar, Rafael, Brown, J. Evans, Fabio (Scholes, 72); O’Shea, Fletcher, Giggs (Gibson, 52); Nani (Hernandez, 62), Macheda (Welbeck, 62), Obertan (Cleverley, 23).
Referee: Jorge Gonzalez (USA)
Att.: 70,728.

  1. I w Nowozeniuk
    commented on: July 29, 2010 at 10 a.m.
    One can plainly see that the Man U players are quality futbolers demonstrated by their individual movements on and off the ball. Their giveaways are limited and they play with purpose. The little nuances are readily recognizable. True, the MLS All-Stars had little prep time if any; that's the fault of the league which seems to schedule games by the seat of their pants...LD and other players who played the night before should have never been allowed to take the pitch for their own well-being reasons...perhaps in the future, the commissioner and his kahunas will make sounder was a spectator friendly game which Man U took extra seriously.
  1. Philippe Fontanelli
    commented on: July 29, 2010 at 12:34 p.m.
    And again who was the coach of the All Stars? Bruce Arena! That was number one mistake. I always said that he has no concept of the game. Just look at the beating he took from Puerto Rico. That should tell you that he is no tactician. He was subpar at the helm of the National Team and he was a failure after that with the MLS teams. Yeah last year he did well with Beckham and Donovan although he was outsmarted by by an ex-prp player coach(this year with Donovan and Buddle??? maybe???). What I am trying to say he has never played pro ball to understand the pro game.
  1. Mj Lee
    commented on: July 29, 2010 at 2:10 p.m.
    When Bruce has to give playing time to all the All-Stars, it's pretty hard to compete against a cohesive team. Don Garber seems to be happy to diminish the MLS quality soccer reputation in exchange for ticket and TV rights sales. And once again, the broadcast just shows that US soccer fans care more about teams in other countries than the diminished product here at home. It's sad Garber's so eager to make a buck that he doesn't care about making the individual All-Stars look so bad.
  1. Scott Ellis
    commented on: July 29, 2010 at 3:26 p.m.
    The scheduling problem wasn't MLS' fault. They don't decide when CONCACAF schedules it's championship league matches. And when Manchester United decides it will honor our league with an appearance in our all-star game MLS cannot be picky about the date. They take the date they are given. Don't use the scheduling conflicts as a reason to find fault with the league. As for the quality of our league, Rome wasn't built in a day!!! You have to support it and it will get better. Everybody wants the best league in the world immediately. It doesn't work that way. Do want to get up at ungodly early morning hours to watch your favorite teams forever? Try supporting MLS and help build the foundation to the game being played at a high level stateside.
  1. Randall and barbara Smith
    commented on: July 29, 2010 at 6:28 p.m.
    Well said Scott and thank you.
  1. Bill Richter
    commented on: July 30, 2010 at 1:19 a.m.
    It's the All Star game, not an international match. Scott got it right: You take the date you can get when Man U is on the international road, and if you want a good league here, then support the one we have. Of course Garber is going after the money, MLS game attendance shows why. MLS is a business, not a charity, and if fans don't support it, he has to find funding where he can. The original Earthquakes proved that.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent Soccer America Daily
What They're Saying: Leonardo Jardim    
"Even you, if tomorrow another newspaper offers you a contract where you will earn 15 times ...
College women's soccer: Five storylines for 2017    
The 2017 college women's soccer season kicks off on Friday. The big news is that U.S. ...
What They're Saying: Greg Kuhel    
"We applied before, but we were not even selected for future consideration." -- Greg Kuhel, a ...
Newcomers break into U.S. U-17 boys squad    
There usually isn't a lot of turnover between the teams the USA uses in qualifying and ...
Stadium hangup hinders even hottest new soccer market    
Of the 12 MLS expansion candidates, none has come farther in a shorter period of time ...
Piatti comments cast cloud over surging Montreal Impact    
By hinting his tenure in Montreal might be nearing an end, Argentine attacker Ignacio Piatti injected ...
Video Pick: Giovanni Reyna shines for U-15s    
Giovanni Reyna scored from 22 yards and assisted on two goals, including Gianluca Busio's acrobatic side ...
Turner will make fans pay for most UCL games    
In case you've forgotten, this is the last season Fox Sports will carry the UEFA Champions ...
USMNT 40 tracker: Pulisic and Wood open Saturday    
Five players on our USMNT 40, tracking players under consideration for callups to the next camp, ...
American soccer weekend: Complete schedules    
The Chicago Fire will look to close the gap on Toronto FC when it hosts the ...
>> Soccer America Daily Archives