Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
MLS Playoffs Could Use Extra Officials
by Paul Gardner, October 27th, 2010 1:36AM
Subscribe to SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner

TAGS:  fc dallas, los angeles galaxy, mls, new york red bulls, seattle sounders


By Paul Gardner

The MLS playoffs are upon us, accompanied by various organizational hiccups that could be quite embarrassing. I’ll look at those in a moment, but first let me jump in immediately, with a suggestion to MLS that might help to reduce the red-face factor.

There is always an ominous cloud that hangs over the playoffs anyway. The cloud of caution. Low-scoring, tied games ... and the dreaded penalty kick shootouts as the tiebreaker. That’s the way that RSL won the title last year -- but, even though they were worthy winners, this is a rotten way to decide a championship.

I do have some thoughts about that. As it seems likely that we shall get a shootout or two during the playoffs, MLS should try to ensure that they are conducted fairly. What this means is that they should be closely monitored for goalkeeper movement.

Which leads me to suggest that MLS follow the lead of the UEFA Champions League and use a couple of extra officials -- the additional assistant referees, AARs, if not throughout the playoffs, then just for the final. The extra eyes of these “goal line” officials become particularly useful in the shootout.

That is my Helpful Suggestion to MLS (of course, you should know that I’m batting absolute zero on a whole string of previous suggestions).

Whatever, I am truly pleased to announce that the MLS playoff teams and matchups have now been decided, and that the situation is a tremendous mess that seems to satisfy no one. Except me, that is.

My main concern all along, ever since the announcement that the final would be played in Toronto, has been that absolutely nothing should be allowed to delay the games, and that maybe, somehow or other, they could even be advanced a week or two.

This was all based on my certain knowledge that Toronto on November 21 is wrong, both place-wise and time-wise, as a site for playing important finals. I shouldn’t be at all surprised if the game is visited with a snow blizzard, or at least sub-zero temperatures.

No doubt there will be hardy Torontonians to tell me that I’m out of my mind, that BMO field will be bathed in balmy temperatures, and caressed by gentle zephyrs. Maybe. But I’ve been in Toronto in November, thank you.

There having been no delays, all is now set for the coldest MLS Cup yet. I’m reminded of baseball in 1971. Then-commissioner Bowie Kuhn decided (for television reasons, of course) that there would be a night-time World Series game for the first time ever. But this was tame stuff compared with MLS -- this was only halfway through October, and it was in Pittsburgh, well south of Toronto.

It was a chilly evening. But Bowie made his point with record viewing figures. He also tried to make a personal point by sitting outside without wearing a top coat, making an ass of himself trying to convince the world that it wasn’t really cold at all.

I suppose Don Garber now has the chance to repeat Kuhn’s thermal-underwear excursion, but I’m banking on Garber having too much common sense to go for it.

We have 11 games coming up, featuring eight teams. I really don’t care that much that the Western Conference has proved much stronger than the Eastern. Nor can I get too outraged by the possibility that the Eastern Conference champion might turn out to be a team from the west.

Evidently the playoff system has not been thought through that well. Aside from the possibility of a geographical absurdity there is the more worrying concern that the predominance of western teams has introduced an element of unfairness to the whole procedure. To have Seattle playing against the MLS team with the best regular season record (the Galaxy, with 59 points), while the two western clubs that finished below Seattle (San Jose and Colorado), face ostensibly weaker opponents (New York 51 and Columbus 50), sure doesn’t look like a great idea. I’d say that Sigi Schmid and his Sounders deserve better than that.

The favorites? Don’t be ridiculous. In MLS there are no favorites. Last year the winner turned out to be Real Salt Lake, the team with the worst qualifying record. The year before that New York -- a team that had never in its entire existence even looked like winning everything -- made its way to the final.

Maybe this is the way it should be -- for a league whose single entity-structure and strict salary caps are designed to prevent clubs from outspending each other, thus throttling the emergence of elite clubs. A system that has begun to creak and which has needed the oil of the Designated Players to stop it from grinding to a halt.

Money begins to speak in MLS. We have, this year, two obvious candidates for elite team status among the playoff qualifiers -- the New York Red Bulls, who have been spending a lot of money, on a sparkling new stadium, and by acquiring three DPs, and the Los Angeles Galaxy that spent a fortune on David Beckham. Despite the spending, it’s difficult to see either team as demonstrably better than the rest.

Anyway, when I pick my favorites, I’m choosing the teams that I consider play the best soccer. That rules out the Galaxy, who have been borderline-boring in most of the games that I have seen. The Red Bulls can play nice stuff, but as the playoffs have approached, they have lost their touch, particularly when playing at home, where their last three games have produced but three goals and not much excitement -- certainly not enough to match the superb atmosphere created by the fans.

For style, I’ll take Real Salt Lake, Dallas, San Jose and Seattle, in that order. Which means that my preferred final won’t happen, as RSL meets Dallas in the first round. I did mention that the playoffs are a mess, didn’t I?

  1. Brian Something
    commented on: October 27, 2010 at 8:09 p.m.
    I know this won't happen because common sense is nowhere in the vicinity of MLS playoffs. But I'd like the playoffs to be changed in two ways. One is obviously to get rid of the idiotic way the wild card teams are assigned to play. That goes without saying. But I'd like to get rid of penalty shootouts and make the tiebreaker regular season points. So that would mean that the lower seeded team would have to outright WIN the round. This would encourage the lower teams to attack, rather than bunker and hope for a counter or penalties. This may not work within the context of a final (for TV reasons) but it should at least be done for the first two rounds.
  1. Hector Lizarraga
    commented on: October 28, 2010 at 2:02 a.m.
    Paul, I have never read a soccer journalist, ever, who I agree with time after time, more than you. You hit the nail on the head on issue after issue. Thanks for being the voice of reason and common sense, not to mention uncanny insight. Your column voices my frustations and makes me feel a little better about the future of soccer in the US. There has to be others out there like you, right?

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner
That Goal    
It was Pele who started the "soccer is beauty" theme. He titled his autobiography -- one ...
Tab Ramos paints a rosy American future in the changing U-20 World Cup -- but a U-18 World Cup would make more sense     
Tab Ramos has been talking in glowing terms of his team and its adventures at the ...
What's this? A goalkeeper penalized for rough play?     
Meet Sorin Stoica. Maybe you've seen him in action during MLS games. Not a highly paid ...
Scots wha hae! Thoughts on the sad and ominous decline of Scottish soccer    
I note, with considerable exasperation tempered by sadness, that Scottish soccer is experimenting with a marvelous ...
Celebrity coaches -- who needs them?     
I am still finding it difficult to come to terms with the extraordinary way in which ...
Wenger must stay -- even the stats agree     
Arsene Wenger should stay. That's what I think. And I think that way because I respect ...
Violent Goalkeeping (Part 2): FIFA must radically rethink the goalkeeper's role    
Last time, I asked: "What action has soccer taken to at least reduce the incidence of ...
Violent Goalkeeping (Part 1): Players at risk as soccer ignores its own rules    
Goalkeepers, we are told, need protection. No doubt we all agree. Up to a point.
The triumphant return of Bruce Arena    
Well, take that Jurgen Klinsmann. Never at any time during his five years in charge of ...
MLS games compare well with EPL but referees in both leagues reluctant to call PKs    
During this past weekend, I watched -- on television, of course -- 15 games. Well, not ...
>> SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner Archives