Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
The Red Bulls Opt for Dirty Play. What say you, Commissioner Garber?
by Paul Gardner, September 19th, 2011 1:58AM
Subscribe to SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner

TAGS:  mls, new york red bulls, referees


By Paul Gardner

I regard the Red Bulls' Hans Backe as a jewel -- a coach who speaks his mind, who never minces his words, who doesn’t dodge questions, who has a sense of humor.

Such a combination -- it reflects an honesty about his work -- was bound to land Backe in trouble sooner or later. And now it has. Big time. Luckily for Backe, as far as I know he’s in trouble only with me. He should be in serious trouble with the bosses at MLS -- even at the Red Bulls -- but the betting here is that they will not even notice what he has been saying.

It is his remarks after Saturday’s game against Dallas that are so objectionable. The game -- to get that out of the way -- was worse than objectionable, it was utterly emetic. This is soccer?

And the reason for the dreadful game came out clearly -- things are always pretty clear when Backe describes them -- in his postgame comments.

For a start: “We didn’t have that much of an attacking game, maybe two or three good chances.” My translation: “We were not particularly interested in attacking, from the start we were there to defend and maybe steal a goal.”

My translation happens to be 100 percent correct -- for later Backe came up with this: “Over all it was a good game for us. Defend, defend, defend ...”

OK. The Red Bulls have injuries to cope with. Part of that, it needs to be said, is Backe’s fault for his addiction to signing elderly players. But the absence of key players is no excuse for giving us this appalling insult to the game. The rationale of course -- it’s always the same -- is that this was all they could do, this was the only hope.

Well, we don’t know that. We do know that it’s the easy way to handle things, no great expertise or tactics needed here. Because it takes the emphasis completely off actually trying to play soccer. The players can now concentrate on all those wonderfully admirable qualities like grit and guts and togetherness and so on and so on.

We’ve seen this time and time again from all sorts of teams. The players -- to their credit -- never seem entirely happy about it. They offer lame admissions that maybe it wasn’t a great game, but what the heck, we won didn’t we? Carlos Mendes: “That was a battle from start to finish. The guys played well, defended hard. It wasn’t pretty but it’s three points ...” And Chris Albright: “We’re not going to try to hide behind some veil of beautiful soccer - that certainly wasn’t the case ...”

Plus Luke Rodgers, who scrambled in the only goal of a blighted game -- a game that he described as “The best performance I’ve seen in a long, long time. The defending was just unbelievable. We played as a team tonight, we looked solid. The togetherness has been brilliant.”

If all that vapid boasting sounds familiar, no doubt it’s because it echoes faithfully what the Colorado Rapid players were mouthing after last year’s MLS Cup win (Dallas was again on the receiving end). A win for a poor, unattractive team that played virtually no soccer and reduced MLS’s gala game to a bore.

So where do we go from here? If this performance was so brilliant, then presumably the Red Bulls should keep playing this way, even when Thierry Henry and Rafa Marquez return to the lineup. (Though these macho wins always raise the question -- if things are so brilliant without the stars -- well, are they really needed?).

It is not an appetizing prospect -- quite puke-inducing in fact -- but Backe has now suggested that this is the way things are going to be, at least on the road. And he did so with words that should be totally unacceptable at MLS headquarters: “This is the way we probably need to do it on the road. We just need to get back to the basics, to the formation. Fill in for each other and play a bit dirty.”

Dirty? Right away, it needs saying that the Bulls were called for 11 fouls in this game -- which is not a huge total. But they did pick up three yellow cards. Statistically, then, it may not have been a foul-fest, but that doesn’t alter the impact of Backe’s intention “to play a bit dirty.”

OK, Commissioner Don Garber, here’s the coach of one of your teams saying, unequivocally, that he wants his team to play dirty. Are you going to let that go? Is it OK for teams to methodically play dirty in your league and to publicly boast of it? Is that what you want?

Of course, only the referees can actually stop the Bulls from roughing up opponents (and what else can Backe’s words mean?) -- but we need to hear from Garber on this matter.

Garber has fined coaches and general managers before -- for criticizing referees, for drawing attention to the league’s shortcomings, and we have had a stern, annoyingly high-minded statement from the league when fining a player alleged to have dived. But this is something different. It’s worth recalling that MLS started this season with a rash of appalling injuries.

Is it OK, Commissioner Garber, to advocate dirty play in MLS?

  1. Kent James
    commented on: September 19, 2011 at 7:50 a.m.
    Emetic? Paul, you're taking criticism to new heights!
  1. R2 Dad
    commented on: September 19, 2011 at 9:45 a.m.
    While I am philosophically opposed to such performances, they are not illegal. I would rather the league focus on enforcing appropriate punishment for excessive force tackles (whether caught by referees or not), which damage players and the reputation of MLS.
  1. Amos Annan
    commented on: September 19, 2011 at 9:52 a.m.
    "a bit dirty" are complaining about that? You expect the coach to be fined over that? Ridiculous! Foolishness! It's the same as saying we are playing more physical. It is part of soccer.
  1. Carl Walther
    commented on: September 19, 2011 at 11:23 a.m.
    No Amos, playing dirty is not a part of soccer. It's a part of your perception of soccer. It's supposed to be the "beautiful game." Something that you and other supporters of 'soccer thugs' know nothing about.
  1. Rudy Espindola
    commented on: September 19, 2011 at 2:29 p.m.
    Right on Mr. Carl
  1. Power Dive
    commented on: September 19, 2011 at 3 p.m.
    Playing dirty is part of soccer at nearly every level in every country. Brazil plays the beautiful game, but I will never forget Leonardo's elbow to Tab Ramos' skull in '94. Watch games today, people will purposely step on people when falling as to make it look like an accident. Elbows still fly as viciously today as they did back in '94. Recognizing that it's part of the game and supporting/condoning it are two completely different things. I'm 100% in support of post-game reviews of games to issue redcards/fines/further suspensions for anything that was missed by the refs during the game.
  1. Richard Romer
    commented on: September 19, 2011 at 8:46 p.m.
    Everyone should aspire to play the beautiful game. Barcelona does not revert to thuggery, even when their two center backs are out, and they tied in their last champion's league game. I just started playing over thirty travel soccer one year ago, and I am 53 years old. I marvel at the skill and the beauty f the game even at that level. We have fantastic, exciting games with minimal contact and no slide tackling and yet the people who watch are enthralled(Thrilled). I bought the premium package for the Red Bulls this season and I will not renew. The beautiful game is largely non-existent and when I hear that the coach wants his team to play a little dirty, it creates a desire to have anti-peristalsis(vomit). Those teams that can't keep up with the better teams practice harder, or get better players.
  1. Rudy Espindola
    commented on: September 19, 2011 at 10:39 p.m.
    how cool is that ? Mr. Romer reading that you are still playing at 53 years old put a smile on my face as I am ready to go to bed. for us the soccer lovers age is not an impediment to keep enjoying the Jogo Bonito but a booster. Congrats.
  1. I w Nowozeniuk
    commented on: September 22, 2011 at 12:42 p.m.
    Backe has figured out that the MLS ref are more 'rugby' oriented and let much more go than the rules of the game permit...Rodgers's comments were at the least delusional and the team performance was gut feeling is that Backe has lost touch with his squad since June and has failed to reinvent this team that started the season on a very promsing playoffs this year for Hans et al while the ghost of the Metrostars remains in the arena.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner
That Goal    
It was Pele who started the "soccer is beauty" theme. He titled his autobiography -- one ...
Tab Ramos paints a rosy American future in the changing U-20 World Cup -- but a U-18 World Cup would make more sense     
Tab Ramos has been talking in glowing terms of his team and its adventures at the ...
What's this? A goalkeeper penalized for rough play?     
Meet Sorin Stoica. Maybe you've seen him in action during MLS games. Not a highly paid ...
Scots wha hae! Thoughts on the sad and ominous decline of Scottish soccer    
I note, with considerable exasperation tempered by sadness, that Scottish soccer is experimenting with a marvelous ...
Celebrity coaches -- who needs them?     
I am still finding it difficult to come to terms with the extraordinary way in which ...
Wenger must stay -- even the stats agree     
Arsene Wenger should stay. That's what I think. And I think that way because I respect ...
Violent Goalkeeping (Part 2): FIFA must radically rethink the goalkeeper's role    
Last time, I asked: "What action has soccer taken to at least reduce the incidence of ...
Violent Goalkeeping (Part 1): Players at risk as soccer ignores its own rules    
Goalkeepers, we are told, need protection. No doubt we all agree. Up to a point.
The triumphant return of Bruce Arena    
Well, take that Jurgen Klinsmann. Never at any time during his five years in charge of ...
MLS games compare well with EPL but referees in both leagues reluctant to call PKs    
During this past weekend, I watched -- on television, of course -- 15 games. Well, not ...
>> SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner Archives