Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
Tevez trashed amid xenophobic torrent
September 30th, 2011 3PM
Subscribe to SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner

TAGS:  argentina, england, uefa champions league


By Paul Gardner

LONDON -- Carlos Tevez, it would appear, has committed the worst act that any soccer player has ever been guilty of. What he did, it seems, is to refuse to go on to the field as a substitute during the second half of Manchester City’s Champions League game against Bayern Munich.

That is his offense. Or rather his alleged offense -- because Tevez says the whole thing was a misunderstanding, and that he did not refuse to play. Manchester City, evidently taking Coach Roberto Mancini’s version as the truth, has suspended Tevez for two weeks while it investigates.

While that proceeds, the English media and virtually all the gurus and experts have adjudged Tevez guilty and have been greatly enjoying themselves ripping Tevez to shreds, condemning his character and demanding that he be severely punished.

If we thought that English xenophobia might have been disappearing as the Premier League featured more and more foreign players, it looks as though we were wrong -- it was merely waiting for a suitable moment to burst forth in all its prejudiced ugliness.

And what a target it has here -- Carlos Tevez, an Argentine if you please, a nationality that has always figured high in the English hate list.

As it’s not getting much attention while the sport of abusing the Argie reaches a climax, it’s worth taking a brief look at Tevez’s record in England: he arrived in 2006, went to West Ham, where he had two coaches -- Alan Pardew and Alan Curbishley, both of whom treated him as most English coaches would treat Argies, by leaving him on the bench. Tevez -- three-time South American Player of the Year in 2003, 2004 and 2005 -- was not considered good enough to play in the EPL. Tevez eventually forced his way on to the team at the end of the season, and saved West Ham from relegation with the crucial goal in a 1-0 win against Manchester United on the final day of the season.

He moved to Man U in 2007 -- and in two seasons there scored 34 goals in 99 games. In 2009, he moved across town to Man City -- and has played 84 games for them, scoring 52 goals. As team captain, he raised the FA Cup in 2011 -- the first trophy won by Man City in over 40 years.

The record is impressive but it is being totally ignored in the xenophobic torrent that now swirls around Tevez. He is suddenly a despicable character, not worth a moment’s thought or a touch of consideration or sympathy. The British media in its element, and at its worst. Headlines like “Carlos the Jackass,” “Let Him Rot," “A Toxic Asset,” plus comments like “a disgrace to football,” and “a dressing room cancer” are everywhere. Oh yes, and there’s a feeble editorial in The Times asking “What if we all refused to do our jobs as Carlos Tevez did?”

Tevez, then, is simply being trashed as a worthless human being. Compare that to the treatment accorded to Joey Barton, very English player. A “hard-nosed” midfielder with two criminal law convictions for violence, also guilty of a frightening physical assault that sent one of his own teammates to hospital, not to mention stubbing a cigarette into the eye of another, plus numerous onfield episodes of foul play ... this delightful young man has recently been signed by EPL club Queen’s Park Rangers and promptly given the captain’s arm band.

Talking of “combative” (a convenient euphemism for players like Barton) players, three of them have been heard from on the subject of Tevez -- three players with formidable records of thuggery. Man City player Nigel De Jong for a start. This is the guy who karate-kicked Xavi Alonso during last year’s World Cup final, and the guy responsible for breaking the legs of the USA’s Stuart Holden and Newcastle United’s Hatem Ben Arfa, but these are not crimes that call for much criticism in England, no one has ever demanded that De Jong “rot” for crippling fellow pros. So de Jong (he’s now a “straight-talking character” according to the Mirror) is giving advice to the Man City management on how to deal with the situation.

Robbie Savage, another thug who once earned the title of the dirtiest player in the EPL, has also been heard from, unashamedly trashing Tevez in a column fully backing the Man City coach, who is referred to as “my mate Roberto Mancini.” And it was that utterly callous hardman, Graeme Souness, who called Tevez “a disgrace to football.”

Tevez is no longer viewed as a talented soccer player -- certainly not to be compared with the likes of the trusty Brits Barton, Savage or Souness -- merely a nobody to be kicked around by people who possess a record that usually makes moralizing difficult for them. They have, of course, jumped all over Tevez.

Tevez, no doubt, will not play again for Man City. Financial considerations -- as Man City try to recover some of their considerable investment in the player (he cost them $75 million) will probably lead to a softening of the club’s position and Tevez will join another club, though not one in the EPL. And somehow or other, the sport of soccer will survive then apparent enormity of Tevez’s alleged crime.

That won’t take too long -- and it will then be time to ponder Mancini’s role in all this. To take a hard look at that game against Bayern Munich, in which Mancini was manifestly outcoached, in which his team was outplayed, and in which he mismanaged his substitutions late in the game, getting into a spat with striker Edin Dzeko as he came off the field, followed by the Tevez incident. And finishing with a 2-0 win, a rather easy one, for Bayern Munich.

  1. Ruben Ibarra
    commented on: September 30, 2011 at 3:32 p.m.
    It is time to bring a talent like Tevez to the MLS. Those of us that are fans of American soccer see this as an opportunity that MLS needs to take advantage of.
  1. Mick Whitewood
    commented on: September 30, 2011 at 4:27 p.m.
    Paul Gardner, you are an imbecile! How can you make the statement "Carlos Tevez, it would appear, has committed the worst act that any soccer player has ever been guilty of". Even someone with less knowledge about football than you (which I think is impossible by the way) would know that the worst act that any soccer player could ever be guilty of has already occurred, and by the way, is it a coincidence that the person that committed this act is also Argentinean? Hmm, I think not! How quickly you forget about Diego Maradona (The Cheat)in the World Cup. Maybe you haven’t forgotten about the worst act not only in soccer but sports history, maybe you just don’t know about it yet!!!
  1. lorenzo murillo
    commented on: September 30, 2011 at 8:17 p.m.
    Paul, you are absolutely wrong... may I remind you that Tevez has also been benched in his national team. Tevez has an attitude or inferiority complex, he thinks he is better than what he is. In Argentina he has a problem accepting Messi is better than him. City is better off..
  1. R2 Dad
    commented on: September 30, 2011 at 11:05 p.m.
    City should have known better to keep Tevez. Mancini has the reputation as a top-down manager and Tevez needs a manager that can soothe his aching ego. In any event, Paul Scholes admitted he did much the same thing 10 years ago and he survived because he apologized: I think the lack of contrition on the part of Tevez is really the problem--all professionals make mistakes but you have to just suck it up and he can't.
  1. Andres Yturralde
    commented on: September 30, 2011 at 11:24 p.m.
    Good take, Paul. Still posing questions with a hammer, I like it. Good eye, good angle. And better yet, good ear. What a delight for one who has ears--even behind his ears.
  1. Carl Grover
    commented on: October 1, 2011 at 2:19 p.m.
    Some of you people who post here are really full of SH*? What do you say about guys like De Jong and Barton - who are ruining the game by their tactics - injuring players. You need to change your sport to American football.
  1. Carl Walther
    commented on: October 1, 2011 at 5:10 p.m.
    "Super Man" - Have you ever had anything positive to say about anything? How about 'Super Negative' for your new name?
  1. I w Nowozeniuk
    commented on: October 1, 2011 at 10:23 p.m.
    Perhaps, Tevez has an overblown ego as many top futbollers do, but having too many aces will make the bench feel like exile...hoarding leads to discontent.
  1. Rudy Espindola
    commented on: October 1, 2011 at 11 p.m.
    Hey tevez: not only you have offended the English Crown but America too, how dare you ??
  1. Rudy Espindola
    commented on: October 1, 2011 at 11:02 p.m.
    Mr. Gardner, please never stop writing
  1. Cleartheball
    commented on: October 2, 2011 at 9:50 a.m.
    I'm all for getting the real story before sentencing, but there is enough doubt about Tevez' personality that I'm not ready to defend him, yet. There is not doubt that he can play, however.
  1. Rudy Espindola
    commented on: October 2, 2011 at 4:48 p.m.
    He's been already sentenced and executed. Let's patiently wait for the next offender. Q
  1. Paul Bryant
    commented on: October 2, 2011 at 6:33 p.m.
    I think the reason Tevez may not have wanted to go into the game was because he did not want to be cup-tied. Being cup-tied would reduce his chances of being trade to a "big" team.
  1. D M
    commented on: October 2, 2011 at 10:41 p.m.
    Tevez is the best player in M. City and it should not be bench. Between Tevez and Manchini I take Tevez. Fired Manchini and keep Tevez. Manchini is not the manager that M City needs at this point. This was evident the last game.
  1. Ramon Creager
    commented on: October 4, 2011 at 10:50 a.m.
    Think what you may about Tevez, Mr. Gardner's observations re. Barton, De Jong et al are spot on. There clearly seems to be a double standard going in the EPL, where criminals like De Jong can always find a comfortable home but skilled foreigners in particular get a chilly reception. BTW, I find it not coincidental that the referee who disgraced himself by allowing De Jong to remain in the game after karate kicking Xavi Alonso, Howard Webb, is an EPL ref.
  1. Paolo Jacobs
    commented on: October 6, 2011 at 8:32 a.m.
    Paul Bryant might be on to something,, bein Cup-tied could be a big reason....Man Citizens is crap anyways, Carlos wanted to be near his family and homeland anyways, so anyone could see this commin

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner
The triumphant return of Bruce Arena    
Well, take that Jurgen Klinsmann. Never at any time during his five years in charge of ...
MLS games compare well with EPL but referees in both leagues reluctant to call PKs    
During this past weekend, I watched -- on television, of course -- 15 games. Well, not ...
Of tattoos and voodoo and science ... and soccer    
My calendar says March 1. But, quite possibly, global warming has advanced things. The weather is ...
Suddenly, the sport itself rebels against low-scoring Scrooge soccer    
We haven't seen anything like this for quite a while. In fact it was beginning to ...
Pep snubs Kun -- modern soccer at its worst    
Back in 2005 the word from Argentina was that maybe -- of course maybe -- a ...
Where soccer fails, the NFL gets it right    
An impertinent book, this. The title and subtitle tell you succinctly what you are getting: "The ...
More urgent than Van Basten's rule changes: soccer needs a total reversal of referees' negative mindset    
The problem is this. To praise Marco van Basten for speaking out on a topic that ...
Clearance: an ugly play, a useless stat     
For some time now I have been wondering about the soccer term "clearance." A term, admittedly, ...
Roberto Cabanas & the Beautiful Game    
From the happiest of thoughts and memories about Roberto Cabanas to total bewilderment and sadness ...
Soccer & Concussion (Part 2): What needs to be done -- before the lawyers move in     
The suspect nature of the enforcement of protocols is by no means the only barrier to ...
>> SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner Archives