Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
Players will suffer until rough play taken seriously
by Paul Gardner, October 10th, 2011 12:26AM
Subscribe to SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner

TAGS:  mls, referees


By Paul Gardner

After two weeks without watching any MLS games, I returned to the fray to watch Vancouver-Real Salt Lake. I fell asleep. Let’s put that down to jet lag ... though I do believe that, had there been any great excitement in the game, I would have stayed awake.

Certainly, it was good to see Javier Morales back in action. Not at his best as yet, but full of good ideas and good passes -- but what on earth has happened to RSL in his absence?

An occasional shot of Jason Kreis apparently imprisoned in an isolation booth, made me believe he was suspended. Apparently not -- food poisoning, it seems. I doubt that his presence on the bench would have changed anything -- this was a thoroughly disappointing display, almost to the point of ineptitude, by RSL.

Maybe it got better while I dozed -- but as Vancouver scored twice in that time, I doubt it. Vancouver, not exactly impressive, but a better team than RSL on this night surely deserved their win. Camilo is a real find -- the sort of player that MLS urgently needs, a goal-scorer, a trickster, a crowd-pleaser.  And, sad to say -- thinking of Morales, David Ferreira, Steve Zakuani and Mauro Rosales -- a candidate to get himself seriously injured.

That problem -- of the crudity of much of the tackling in MLS -- has not been solved. Indeed, since Commissioner Don Garber’s praiseworthy start-of-the-season appeal to the referees to give such players better protection, nothing has been heard from MLS on the subject.

That is deplorable. The fact has to be faced that, without players of the type I’m describing -- the creative, artistic playmakers -- the style, to say nothing of the caliber, of the soccer in MLS slumps badly.

As I was reminded on Saturday by a vapid performance by the normally lively Seattle Sounders during their 0-2 loss to Philadelphia. A big part of the Sounders’ loss of form can be put down to injuries. The Sounders have been the biggest victims of MLS thuggery -- losing Zakuani early in the season to a criminally awful “tackle” from Colorado’s Brian Mullan and then, just three weeks ago, being deprived of the services of the hugely impressive Rosales for several weeks by an utterly unnecessary midfield tackle, inept and negligent, from D.C.United’s Daniel Woolard. (It needs to be said that D.C. has itself suffered from the violence, losing two players: Branko Boskovic at the beginning of the season and -- just a week before the Woolard incident -- its star player, Chris Pontius, suffered a broken leg after a collision with Chivas USA’s David Junior Lopes).

Mullan, of course, has served his far-too-lenient 10-game suspension and has been playing regularly again since mid-July. Since then he has picked up three yellow cards, including one for a “reckless tackle.”

This carnage is not to be simply shrugged off, or dismissed as “part of the game." Coaches need to be much harder on their own players who indulge in thuggery. Looking back to that dreadful foul of Mullan’s, it is almost incredible to recall that the Colorado coach Gary Smith was quick to defend it, and to hide behind that tired old defense that the critics of Mullan “don’t understand the game.”

And of course the referees need to be quicker with the cards. In the same game that Mullan received his yellow for a reckless tackle, referee Jorge Gonzalez red-carded Philadelphia’s Sheanon Williams. For violent play?  For a leg-breaking tackle? No -- Williams got a yellow for bitching to Gonzalez, and then, when he kept going, got a prompt second yellow and was ejected.

Firmness on the part of Gonzalez, for sure -- no doubt Williams used naughty words. But the priorities here are quite wrong. To be that harsh, that quickly, in punishing a verbal tirade makes sense only if violent play meets with the same -- indeed, more severe -- punishment.

But it does not. MLS referees, faced with the reluctance, or downright refusal, of MLS coaches to discipline their own players (it’s only a few weeks ago that Hans Backe was calling on his Red Bulls to play “a little dirty”), have simply not reacted forcefully enough.

After the injury to Rosales, Seattle coach Sigi Schmid had this to say: “We have a talented player in this league, a player who’s a good player, who fans want to come and watch play, then we let thugs hit him and we don’t protect him enough.”

That was said, heatedly no doubt, right after the game. But it is essentially true. I might argue with a detail: having seen very little of Woolard in action, I have no idea whether he is a thug, or not. His tackle came at midfield, in a non-threatening situation, with Seattle leading 3-0 in the 89th minute ... why make the tackle?  Woolard got nowhere near the ball (it was difficult to see why he imagined he had any chance of getting to it), but made solid contact with the knee of Rosales’s standing leg. It looked like the effort of an inexperienced player -- yet Woolard, at age 27, has considerable experience, though most of it is not at the highest level.

All of that is bad enough -- but it gets worse, because this episode reveals just how deep the determination to excuse violent play goes.

There was the performance of referee Kevin Stott -- probably the league’s most experienced official. Rosales had been fouled before in this game, perhaps not enough times to indicate that the fouling was systematic, but enough to raise the suspicion. Yet when Woolard made his crude tackle, Stott called the foul but did not go to his pocket. No card.

Then there’s the attitude of the commentators -- in this case Tony Limarzi and Thomas Rongen. When the foul occurred the two were busily engaged in one of those irrelevant, giggly duets that are so lamentably frequent in soccer telecasts. Rongen was droning on about MLS expansion. On screen, we could see the foul, then we could see Rosales writhing in evident pain -- and then we even had time to watch a very good replay of the incident. And still Rongen droned on. It took 25 seconds -- which is a long time -- for Rongen to notice that Rosales had been fouled. At which point, Rongen switched from drivel about MLS expansion, to drivel excusing the foul ... nothing to get excited about, of course, just “awkward, non-intended.” Ho Hum.

When people like Stott and Rongen -- both highly experienced in different areas of the sport -- are clearly seen to be not taking rough play seriously, they are making it more likely that the serious injuries will continue.

So the players will suffer. And so will MLS. Which makes it inexplicable to me that Garber has not spoken out. And an awkward question needs to be asked -- one which will no doubt rile Garber and his MLS colleagues -- but I shall ask it anyway. What sort of reaction can we expect if the next player to go down seriously injured by violent play happens to be David Beckham?  Or Thierry Henry?

  1. Alvaro Bettucchi
    commented on: October 10, 2011 at 1:17 a.m.
    I have gone to see numerous San Jose Earthquake Games, and I no longer see "THe Beautifuol Game". The fouls that are committed on the feild, resemble a practice session for Amrican Football. Forwards are continuously at risk, and the referees do not enforce the rules. It's time that MLS officials begin take a look at what is happening, before you begin to lose what makes soccer the beautiful game.
  1. Saverio Colantonio
    commented on: October 10, 2011 at 12:29 p.m.
    You have a lethal combination of coaches selecting bigger, stronger and less skilled players with absolutely atrocious refereeing in the MLS. I can't keep track of the number of times non fouls are called and real fouls go under punished or unpunished. I've watched where the referees have ruined the games irregardless of which team (my team or the other team) won the game.The MLS has to get serious about referee situation. Until that happens, I doubt that coaches will get serious about keeping their thugs off the pitch.
  1. Rudy Espindola
    commented on: October 10, 2011 at 4:08 p.m.
    Mr. Gardner a LAZY JOURNALIST ? no comments.
  1. I w Nowozeniuk
    commented on: October 10, 2011 at 8:54 p.m.
    MLS referees do too many about-faces...too harsh or swallow the whistle on many bookable offenses...there is no consistency, ARs don't call anything so not to offend the man-in-the-middle...even with the spray cans they don't get it right, encroachments never punished...sometimes it appears as if these refs emigrated from the rugby league.
  1. Amos Annan
    commented on: October 11, 2011 at 3:58 p.m.
    Ridiculous article about rough play. Let's don't turn soccer into a non-contact sport. There are already way too many red and yellow cards. And "players writhing on the ground" is common after every touch. Too casual observers, it is becoming like professional wrestling... fake injuries and all.
  1. I w Nowozeniuk
    commented on: October 14, 2011 at 11:40 a.m.
    Amos, i guess u sucked it up when an opponent crunched u from the rear or got elbowed u in the head and the ref swallowed his whistle...MLS stats prove that its average total fouls per game are usually twice that of the EPL where tough play lacks MLS's a matter of fair play and enforcing the law of the game...obviously, the ref controls the game and if the player(s) make mockery of it, they should face the consequences.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner
That Goal    
It was Pele who started the "soccer is beauty" theme. He titled his autobiography -- one ...
Tab Ramos paints a rosy American future in the changing U-20 World Cup -- but a U-18 World Cup would make more sense     
Tab Ramos has been talking in glowing terms of his team and its adventures at the ...
What's this? A goalkeeper penalized for rough play?     
Meet Sorin Stoica. Maybe you've seen him in action during MLS games. Not a highly paid ...
Scots wha hae! Thoughts on the sad and ominous decline of Scottish soccer    
I note, with considerable exasperation tempered by sadness, that Scottish soccer is experimenting with a marvelous ...
Celebrity coaches -- who needs them?     
I am still finding it difficult to come to terms with the extraordinary way in which ...
Wenger must stay -- even the stats agree     
Arsene Wenger should stay. That's what I think. And I think that way because I respect ...
Violent Goalkeeping (Part 2): FIFA must radically rethink the goalkeeper's role    
Last time, I asked: "What action has soccer taken to at least reduce the incidence of ...
Violent Goalkeeping (Part 1): Players at risk as soccer ignores its own rules    
Goalkeepers, we are told, need protection. No doubt we all agree. Up to a point.
The triumphant return of Bruce Arena    
Well, take that Jurgen Klinsmann. Never at any time during his five years in charge of ...
MLS games compare well with EPL but referees in both leagues reluctant to call PKs    
During this past weekend, I watched -- on television, of course -- 15 games. Well, not ...
>> SoccerTalk with Paul Gardner Archives