Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
MLS Disciplinary Committee working overtime
by Ridge Mahoney, August 20th, 2012 1:30AM
Subscribe to Soccer America Confidential

MOST READ
TAGS:  mls, referees

MOST COMMENTED

At first glance, a decision made by the MLS Disciplinary Committee to suspend Vancouver midfielder Barry Robson for harassing an assistant referee during a stoppage-time melee seems unfair.

The committee reviewed the incident from the 'Caps match played on Wednesday night and announced the suspension Saturday morning, just a few hours before Vancouver took on Northwest rival Seattle at CenturyLink Field in a 1 p.m. match. Though the league notified the 'Caps late Friday of a possible suspension, that still left Coach Martin Rennie and his staff little time to prepare for Robson's absence in a very important game, which it lost, 2-0.

In expanding the Disciplinary Committee's power to review and perhaps punish incidents in which the referee took no action, for whatever reason, the league has piled on more work with less time to do it. Expansion of the schedule to 34 games has necessitated more teams playing midweek games -- the Crew are in the midst of a three-week stretch in which it plays each Wednesday -- and thus speedier review of incidents, which are not always recorded by broadcast and film crews.

In the case of Robson, the referee's report would have been a powerful piece of evidence, since his altercation was with a match official. But still the committee needed some time to gather information and statements from the relevant individuals. This is a different situation than a caution or dismissal that would require a suspension, which the rules of the game stipulate must be imposed starting with the team's next game.

Perhaps a more reasonable approach would have been to announce the suspension Monday, and let it take effect in the 'Caps next game --- another Cascadia Cup battle at Portland on Saturday -- instead of the Seattle match. Yet this could bring complications if Robson were to be involved in another altercation, with opponents or officials or members of the crowd, leaving the committee with yet another incident to untangle.

As it turns out, the committee is in for some long hours even without a backlog. Last weekend was rife with controversy, with dismissals and penalty kicks at the forefront.

Three players were sent off in the Montreal-San Jose match, with Steven Lenhart's seemingly inadvertent smack to the face of Montreal's Hassoun Camara starting a melee that resulted in both being dismissed as well as a penalty kick.

D.C. United coach Ben Olsen was fuming after a 1-1 tie with Philadelphia that also finished 10-against-nine and featured a penalty kick re-taken and missed by Dwayne DeRosario for encroachment, with Branko Boskovic being sent off after a scuffle prompted by Mark Geiger's decision.

The Revs thought a penalty kick awarded for an A.J. Soares' slide tackle on Chris Rolfe looked more like a dive than a foul.

A belief that the committee is taking on too much has its backers around the league, and not until an extensive review is undertaken at the end of the season can its efficiency, fairness, and consistency be evaluated. Yet in cases like that of Robson, there's going to be consequences, for messing with match officials is one of those transgressions the league will not tolerate.
And as far as it being a rush job, there just isn't enough time to do it any other way.



1 comment
  1. Allan Lindh
    commented on: August 20, 2012 at 3:03 p.m.
    This is nit-picking. Many matches are too violent, played in a bad spirit, players striking out at one another, bad tackles aplenty, and players running at and harassing refs when they try to return a spirit of fair play and respect for one another to the match. The refs and the league are doing their best, but it is up to those players who are out for blood, playing with much to much anger to remember they are playing the Beautiful Game. And if they cannot, up to coaches to put them on the bench, rather than just using them like mad dogs to attack the other teams skill players. IMHO.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now




AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent Soccer America Confidential
One man's Midseason MLS Best XI    
The list of All-Stars was released by MLS on Tuesday and amid the controversy of who ...
Arena goes with experience -- and a few question marks in Gold Cup knockout phase.    
The six players called by Bruce Arena for the Gold Cup quarterfinals and beyond were not ...
USA beats a minnow: the woeful, good and hopeful     
What was the most pathetic moment for the USA in its Gold Cup game on Wednesday? ...
SA Midseason Awards: Nikolic, Paunovic head list of Chicago candidates    
An amazing turnaround in Chicago has the Fire challenging for the Eastern Conference title and Supporters' ...
Bruce Arena went too defensive against Panama    
It's true that the USA has a Panama problem. Los Canaleros are the only team that ...
Midseason kudos to Atlanta, questions for PRO    
A revived Eastern Conference heads the list of midseason trends for the 2017 MLS campaign.
USA proves it has depth -- and cohesion     
One would have been excused for not expecting much from the USA in its friendly against ...
Quakes' Kinnear swept out by new wave as much as poor results    
In explaining his decision to fire Dominic Kinnear, Quakes general manager Jesse Fioranelli said, "I think ...
Thank you, Tony DiCicco    
I've often been told that I am very fortunate to have the job of soccer journalist, ...
VAR problems should not dissuade MLS    
MLS is an ideal testing ground to supply additional data for use of the Video Assistant ...
>> Soccer America Confidential Archives