Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
For better or worse, Vergara is in charge
by Ridge Mahoney, March 6th, 2013 4:29PM
Subscribe to Soccer America Confidential

TAGS:  chivas usa, mls


By Ridge Mahoney

I’m getting a real laugh out of all these fans and pundits wringing their hands about Chivas USA and imploring MLS commissioner Don Garber to do something.

MLS has been trying to “do something” for nearly a year. As was reported by Soccer America in December and subsequently confirmed by other media outlets and Garber himself, the league has provided personnel and resources to assist the team in its operations as well as selling tickets and sponsorships.

Periodic visits to Southern California by MLS president Mark Abbott and other executives last year were explained by the league as assistance in the buyout by owner Jorge Vergara of his partners, Antonio and Lorenzo Cue. I’m not sure I completely buy that, pun intended.

It seems a monumental waste of time to have such a powerful and important person as Abbott, the league’s point man on issues such as expansion and stadium projects, to help facilitate an in-house transaction. But, of course, as a single-entity league, MLS retains control of all of its teams with a 50.1 percent ownership stake , so these already complicated deals would need greater oversight at the league level.

Whether rumors of MLS inquiring about buying back the team from Vergara – a price of $25 million has been cited by a Southern California source with ties to the team -– have any grain of truth or not, his decision to again re-brand Chivas USA with a strong Mexican/CD Guadalajara identity is off to a terrible start on and off the field. A dismal crowd announced at 7,121 – which was probably closer to 5,000, if that – watched a 3-0 loss to Columbus Saturday night at Home Depot Center.

And what can the league do? Since it technically owns all of the teams, MLS has, theoretically, greater leverage in dictating the course of Chivas USA. That’s the theoretical. The practical is radically different.

Remember all the whining and crying from fans and journalists -- not to mention a few coaches and general managers – during the league’s early years about it excessively controlling, and thus suppressing, certain teams? League-run teams were a staple of the league until it “contracted” Tampa Bay, and found owners for Dallas and San Jose.

It wasn’t that long ago that just three ownership groups -- the Phil Anschutz empire and the Kraft and Hunt families -- were the only stakeholders in MLS. (The Hunt family took over the Dallas Burn in 2002; it started out as a league-run team.)

As it has expanded and widened its ownership to the current roster of 18 operator-investor groups, MLS has ceded greater autonomy to its teams. They can now develop their own players and sign them rather than relying exclusively on league-run mechanisms – player drafts, discoveries, weighted lotteries, etc. – and there’s little question the diversity of management philosophies has created teams of varied identities.

Los Angeles and New York are going to spend the most, Columbus, Dallas and San Jose are among the most frugal. Sporting Kansas City built a futuristic facility, the Quakes’ new stadium won’t be as lavish. There are stadiums that serve as centerpieces of a soccer complex (Colorado and Dallas), and a multisport facility (Home Depot Center).

But granting greater autonomy comes at a price, literally. When it approved Miami as an expansion team and accepted a fee of $20 million from Ken Horowitz, MLS took on a partner who ultimately couldn’t afford to keep the Fusion going. The price for an expansion team had dropped to $10 million by the time Vergara came aboard in 2004, though he also paid a fee of several million to set up shop in the AEG-controlled HDC.

The league has revamped its financial rules so that losses are not shared more or less equally, as was the case when operations started in 1996. If your bottom line is hurting, you’re on the hook for a lot more of it than is, say, Seattle. The league is in a real pickle with Chivas USA, since it operates at the behest of an all-powerful Galaxy, which collects lease payments whether or not its tenant wins a game or draws a fan.

MLS knew full well what Vergara had in mind at the time; to parlay the glorious history of CD Guadalajara into a Southern California branch office. Maybe he and the Cues believed the striped jerseys and a fearsome Chivas mascot would translate into regular attendance by at least a portion of the Southland audience, and for a few seasons, Chivas USA actually did draw decent crowds and reach the playoffs (2006-09).

But fortunes are not just trending downwards, they’ve apparently plummeted off a cliff. Three straight bad seasons have driven fans away. Former staff members who have talked to current members say there’s great uncertainty and anxiety inside the team’s offices, and if Vergara has a long-range plan in mind he’s not sharing it. Play elsewhere in L.A., move, sell?

There’s been outrage at the club’s jettisoning of non-Hispanic players, but claims of discrimination in this regard are unfounded. MLS teams can sign a lot of international players as well as green-card holders, and Jose Luis Sanchez Sola and Vergara are perfectly within league rules if they want to sign players of Mexican origin. The same could be done, say, in Montreal, if it wanted to stock those slots solely with Canadians or Italians or Frenchmen, or with any combination thereof.

Now, what the team cannot do is discriminate by language in its hiring of workers. It would be difficult to prove that a player was cut or traded, for example, because he didn’t speak Spanish, if such suspicions did arise. Competitive reasons could always be cited.

That Vergara has come full circle back to that original premise of a Guadalajara identity after several re-brands, and now MLS must somehow balance its adherence to greater autonomy with a financial sinkhole that is also a public-relations eyesore. But Vergara is the boss, and to a great extent he can do whatever he wants, whatever that may be.

In the modern era of MLS, it’s his mess to clean up. At least for now.

  1. Chris Sapien
    commented on: March 6, 2013 at 7:01 p.m.
    "Horizontal Stripes"?? Come on Ridge.....oh, you must be referring to how the stripes look when the defenders are laying on the ground after another goal allowed......
  1. Peter Skouras
    commented on: March 6, 2013 at 7:23 p.m.
    Over 1.000.000 "Mexicans" in LA and they can't have a Club that has a bit of quality?
  1. Peter Skouras
    commented on: March 6, 2013 at 7:26 p.m.
    ..."the modern era of the MLS?" FYI, the "League" let alone US Soccer is so far behind the rest of the world Ridge it's simple! What's trivial is the amount of talent there is in the US!
  1. Chris Sapien
    commented on: March 6, 2013 at 7:30 p.m.
    Sure, if they pool their collective money, buy a team, and decide to go down the same disastrous road of branding a team based on and for an ethnicity......not the brightest move ever.....just saying......quality is never guaranteed, nor is support as has been discovered....
  1. Ken Jamieson
    commented on: March 6, 2013 at 9:24 p.m.
    Comparing Chivas USA's use of Mexican players with FC Impact's use of Canadian players is totally off-base. While Canadian players on the other 16 MLS teams are treated as "foreign" players, that is not the case in Vancouver, Toronto or Montreal, although American players are not considered "foreign" players on these Canadian teams. The price of playing in a US-based, USSF-controlled league. Regardless of the orientation of a team, any Mexican citizen playing in MLS is a "foreign" player. MLS justifies its double-standard for Canadian citizens as an INS issue, yet in the old NASL (1968-74) there was one category "North American" players which included Canadians and Americans alike. If MLS had a Mexican-based team, then the comparison with Montreal, Toronto or Vancouver would be applicable, but under the current format, there is a big difference between Canadians and Mexicans when referring to the three Canadian-based MLS clubs.
  1. Luis Arreola
    commented on: March 7, 2013 at 10:29 a.m.
    Relax, the season just started. Vergara has at least this entire season to make his point. If he was bold enough to bring his ideology to USA he has to back it up. As for Fans, well, in USA we love to win and winners for that matter. If he starts winning, the fans will pour in, slowly but surely. Thats all that's going to take. Chivas fans in Mexico have been frustrated with Vergara for playing too many young unproven players. Chivas are producing great players but at a cost. Their fan base overall is weakening. Its not that they dont agree with the Mexicans only idea in Mexico, its more that they are a club of that stature is not winning. In USA as well, they are expected to win, most of all.
  1. Chris Sapien
    commented on: March 7, 2013 at 12:42 p.m.
    Luis, That was mostly well stated, but I am wondering, what "point" do you believe they are trying to make that you are alluding to?
  1. Luis Arreola
    commented on: March 7, 2013 at 1:26 p.m.
    He obviously champions Mexican American players over other nationalities as he has done in Mexico with Guadalajara team. His archrival their is AMerica who is well known for bringing in Foreign Top Players. He has shown great support for Mexican American players by including them in Guadalajara roster. My guess is he wants to prove he can be successful with same ideolagy here in USA.
  1. Andrew Jackson
    commented on: March 7, 2013 at 3:59 p.m.
    "But, of course, as a single-entity league, MLS retains control of all of its teams with a 50.1 percent ownership stake , so these already complicated deals would need greater oversight at the league level." This is a widely believed but false myth. The league does not own 51% of any team. The local investor/operators own 100% of their right to operate a team in the league. The league jointly through all of its investors control the entire league which includes all the teams. If the league wants to buy back the rights to operate Chivas USA they would have to pay Vergara 100% of what he thinks it is worth. MLS does not already own half of it.
  1. Frank Cardone
    commented on: March 10, 2013 at 6:13 p.m.
    It is 2013. There is no place in MLS for teams that are so ethic-oriented, regaedless of the ethnic group. Remember the Toronto Metros-Croatia in the mid-1970's? Do we need a team line Chivas USA in MLS? Are we going backwards? Take note: As I write this it is halftime at the Home Depot Center, Chivas vs. Dallas. Seems to be a beautiful Sunday afternoon. I would be stunned if there are more than 5,000 spectators present, regardless of whatever the announced attendance will be.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent Soccer America Confidential
Dempsey: Qualifying for the World Cup is bigger than breaking scoring records    
In his bid to "stay relevant" and in the plans of national team head coach Bruce ...
Bruce Arena makes the USA fun to watch    
Before Friday's game against Honduras, I wondered whether the U.S. national team would bring joy to ...
Michael Bradley: USA prepared 'to tilt the bar in our favor' early against Honduras    
As they train in San Jose for a crucial Hexagonal match against Honduras on Friday, the ...
Next move for Real Salt Lake is the most crucial in a decade    
The history of RSL is one of remarkable stability -- just three head coaches since starting ...
U.S. roster announcement: Bruce Arena's return marked by a singleness of purpose    
Multiply the left-back debate with a few more positions each with several candidates and you'll have ...
Quakes encouraged but not giddy after impressive opener    
Four seasons without playoffs has left the fervent fans in San Jose discouraged, but a ray ...
MLS 1-22: Ranking the teams on the eve of a new season    
Eight different teams have played in the last four MLS Cup finals and last year, 2015 ...
Random thoughts as the MLS season draws near    
The 2017 MLS season starts next Friday, March 3, more than a month earlier than the ...
Walker Zimmerman joins the U.S. centerback pool with solid performance    
Two FC Dallas centerbacks were summoned to the first U.S, camp of 2017 and after Matt ...
Rare USA golazo inspires some hope    
One swallow doesn't make a summer, but the USA delivered something impressive with its goal in ...
>> Soccer America Confidential Archives