Join Now  | 
Home About Contact Us Privacy & Security Advertise
Soccer America Daily Soccer World Daily Special Edition Around The Net Soccer Business Insider College Soccer Reporter Youth Soccer Reporter Soccer on TV Soccer America Classifieds Game Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalk Soccer America Confidential Youth Soccer Insider World Cup Watch
RSS Feeds Archives Manage Subscriptions Subscribe
Order Current Issue Subscribe Manage My Subscription Renew My Subscription Gift Subscription
My Account Join Now
Tournament Calendar Camps & Academies Soccer Glossary Classifieds
Rogers still retired, so can we all relax?
by Ridge Mahoney, May 2nd, 2013 4PM
Subscribe to Soccer America Confidential

TAGS:  mls


By Ridge Mahoney

As regards Robbie Rogers and his future as a soccer player, or not, can we all just give it a rest?

He trained with the Galaxy Tuesday. So what? Less than three months after announcing his retirement and sexual preference in one fell swoop, he was on the field! Big deal.

For all we know, he still feels that playing a pro sport as an openly gay athlete is “impossible,” and for the American soccer press to beat the drums, indirectly or not, for him to resume is playing career now if not sooner is shameful.

And make no mistake, that’s what’s going on. In fact, the drums are beating so loud all manner of fans and pundits are decrying the MLS rules by which his rights are held by Chicago, even though as a Southern California native he’d love to play for the Galaxy, although Seattle coach Sigi Schmid has acknowledged he’s a good player, and Fire head coach Frank Klopas says the same thing and would certainly like him on his team, and the rules are so stupid that Herculez Gomez might have to jump through hoops if he came back to MLS because his rights are held by Sporting Kansas City, the last MLS team to employ him.

Whew! That’s a lot to digest, but let’s take on this task in stages. First, let’s set the record straight: all those references to NBA veteran Jason Collins being the first male athlete to come out during his pro career are correct, and nobody slighted Rogers by saying so.

Veteran Collins is a free agent and trying to find another team, so he’s as active now as he was Monday when a long story about his acknowledgement of being gay appeared in Sports Illustrated. Rogers went inactive when he retired, and officially he’s just as retired now as he was in February.

So Collins is the first, even though at 34 his chances of getting another pro gig are slim. Rogers, 25, can be the second if he resumes his career but he can never be the first, so all of you out there in Please-Be-Nice-to-Soccer Land, get over it.

The second issue to be discussed is Rogers actually resuming his career, which if you read all the adoring, breathless coverage since he jogged onto the field with the Galaxy is a fait accompli. Sure, the press and many fans would love to have Rogers back on the field in an MLS jersey. But what’s great for MLS and the politically correct crowd may not be great for Rogers, who twice left America to try the foreign market and failed both times.

He’s already become a poster child for the bashing of MLS player acquisition procedures. While he’s surely heartened by the outpouring of support he’s received since making his announcement, he shouldn’t feel pressured to resume his career so a lot of us can feel better about ourselves and the progress our society is making toward acceptance of homosexuals.

He’ll be the target of protests. The Supreme Court sessions over gay marriage have roiled emotions on many related topics, and he would see, and hear, vitriol from both sides. He’ll be a lightning rod for abuse as well as tolerance.

Maybe he left the game in the first place because he wanted to be himself instead of a symbol, a pioneer, a cause. He picked his identity over soccer. He could have kept his mouth shut and endured his internal conflicts to keep playing.

By coming out and retiring, he’s put himself squarely in the cross-hairs of his own persona. What to do next?

If he’s happier as a gay ex-player than he was as a closeted gay player, that’s the path he should take. Conversely, if he gauges that the time is right and he’s the right person to step into the dual spotlight as gay man and professional soccer player, that’s what he should do. But he should ignore all but those closest to him as he ponders his decision. He won’t be letting us down if he stays retired. He doesn't need to be the Jackie Robinson of gay pro athletes.

If he truly wants to resume playing, he will, and he might just get his preference in that regard as well. Or he might not. Two weeks before Rogers’ announcement, Chicago acquired his rights in a trade with the Crew. Coincidence or not, that’s the current status.

Didn’t another former Crew player, Brian McBride, get his way when he came back to MLS? Yes, there was a lot of posturing and stalling and huffing and puffing, but in the end, he finished his career with the Fire even though under MLS rules Toronto FC, which was atop the allocation order at the time, held his rights, and took its sweet time before trading him.

It’s not always the case that a pro player gets to play where he wants, even a megastar such as Landon Donovan. He may have gamed the system by negotiating a deal that took him away from San Jose and MLS to Bayer Leverkusen, only to return a few months later to the Los Angeles Galaxy, but when he first arrived in MLS, he went to San Jose, and in San Jose he stayed.

Quakes coach Frank Yallop adamantly refused to trade him, and while Donovan often zipped out of the locker room after home games and headed straight to Southern California for a quick visit, he played four seasons for the Quakes and helped them win a pair of titles. It’s hard to make a case that his fabulous career suffered because the team he started out with wasn’t his first choice.

Rogers isn’t a precocious 19-year-old frustrated by two years languishing in a German reserve team. Yet neither is he a stone-cold superstar; admiration for his bold stand clouds the fact during his stints in MLS and the national team his talented game often lacked tenacity or consistency. Once a teammate of Michael Bradley at Heerenveen, he lasted about nine months in Holland, and many U.S. players have carved out far more successful careers in England than he did.

In an interview with Anderson Cooper Rogers acknowledged a comeback is a possibility but for a while he’ll be enjoying time with friends and family, surfing, and thinking about life. Coming out was tough enough. Coming back can wait.

“Chill out,” is what he said. So should we all.

  1. Glenn Auve
    commented on: May 2, 2013 at 5:54 p.m.
    Well, sure, but maybe the fact that he was hiding his secret had a detrimental effect on his play and now that he is free of that he will be an even better player. And let's also remember that neither he nor Collins was the first. First American men, sure. But Anton Hysen came out in Sweden a couple of years ago and continues to play albeit in lower divisions.
  1. Eric Schmitt
    commented on: May 2, 2013 at 6:08 p.m.
    Wow, Ridge. Touchy today? Certainly, Rogers is entitled to decide his own moment to do, or not do, anything at all in regards to his return to soccer. But Rogers knew his decision would be analyzed to death when he made it, as did Collins. Media attention on this kind of thing is, unfortunately, inevitable. It doesn't mean we don't respect Rogers. It just means its a topic of conversation. I'll try not to overreact if you don't.
  1. Jacob Wang
    commented on: May 2, 2013 at 10:09 p.m.
    Rogers grew up in Orange County, CA. The Galaxy played its 1st game when he was 9 years old (he'll turn 26 on Mother's Day). Keep both of those facts in mind
  1. Oscar Albuquerque
    commented on: May 3, 2013 at 10:16 a.m.
    Ridge, we are all relax you should relax and stop writing titles like the one you just did. People are entitle to give their opinion whether you like it or not. Why is it that Mr Robbie Rogers and Jason Collins needed to call a press conference to tell us that their sex preference is men instead of women? The should have told that to their family which are the closest relatives to them and if they did good for them. Why the need to tell strangers their sexual preference? You don't see a 7/11 clerk calling a press conference to tell us all what his sexual preference is? Who cares if they are gay or not?
  1. Ronnie j Salvador
    commented on: May 3, 2013 at 6:45 p.m.
    Many thousands of families today shell out more than $31k for a year of high school. You don't have to be 'well heeled' nor does it have to be a 'very private high school'. It's fairly common, especially in the northeast.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now



Recent Soccer America Confidential
FC Dallas is adding to the tasks of Kellyn Acosta in Diaz's absence    
Several FCD players are stepping up their games in the absence of playmaker Mauro Diaz, who ...
Amercan soccer looks pretty good while looking back at past failures    
If you didn't see it, please check out the excellent story written by my friend and ...
World Cup is opportunity personified for game in Canada    
Just playing in the World Cup, which Canada hasn't done in more than 30 years, would ...
U.S. women strengthen their influence and power with new CBA deal    
Once the U.S. women's players had wrested control of their destinies away from a hired gun, ...
Three MLS teams in need of answers -- quickly    
The Union has yet to establish itself as a threat in the Eastern Conference, and after ...
Dempsey: Qualifying for the World Cup is bigger than breaking scoring records    
In his bid to "stay relevant" and in the plans of national team head coach Bruce ...
Bruce Arena makes the USA fun to watch    
Before Friday's game against Honduras, I wondered whether the U.S. national team would bring joy to ...
Michael Bradley: USA prepared 'to tilt the bar in our favor' early against Honduras    
As they train in San Jose for a crucial Hexagonal match against Honduras on Friday, the ...
Next move for Real Salt Lake is the most crucial in a decade    
The history of RSL is one of remarkable stability -- just three head coaches since starting ...
U.S. roster announcement: Bruce Arena's return marked by a singleness of purpose    
Multiply the left-back debate with a few more positions each with several candidates and you'll have ...
>> Soccer America Confidential Archives