So Colin Clarke
has taken the fall for his team being upset not once, but twice, in the MLS conference semifinals by Colorado despite being the higher-seeded team.
Did he deserve
it? Well, the blame for a disappointing performance always falls in the same direction, and for losing twice in the playoffs with a chance to play in the championship game as host, general manager
can't be blamed for jettisoning Clarke.
"It's a strong roster with a lot of depth at all positions and we feel that we didn't realize our potential this year,"
said Hitchcock yesterday during a conference call announcing the news Clarke's contract would not be renewed.
But the rationale that Dallas underachieved despite superior talent isn't so
easy to justify. Yes, the regular-season record this season was impressive, but Hitchcock's assertion that FC Dallas is among the most, if not the most, talented team in the league bears
How many FC Dallas players will be, or should be, named to the MLS Best XI? Let's go by position: GOALKEEPER. Dario Sala
isn't the equal of Joe
, Matt Reis
, Troy Perkins
, Pat Onstad
and probably one or two others. Signing Shaka Hislop
is a move that made no sense when it was done and makes even less
sense now: to burn a senior international slot on a player whose peak performances for West Ham last season and T&T last summer will never be repeated, especially in a low-key league like MLS.
The revolving door of central partners for Greg Vanney
typifies the lack of quality at this position. And Vanney, despite his experience, at this point in his career
isn't as valuable as Michael Parkurst
, Eddie Robinson
, Bobby Boswell
, etc. Clarke bears the responsibility of not filling a vital position with a strong player, especially with
a SI slot available before Hislop was signed. Houston filled a need with Paul Dalglish
, for example. Chris Gbandi
had his best season at left back, and Bobby Rhine
on the other side, but again, neither is numero uno at his position. And it was Gbandi whose reckless red card opened the door for Colorado to rally in the second conference semifinal.
Watching the conference finals, and especially Houston and New England, illustrates how Dallas suffers in this area of the field as well. And a player who can be regarded as
among the league's elite is one of the club's biggest problems. Ronnie O'Brien
is among the best on the right flank, but as one observer said, "He's a me-guy," which his
recurring insistence to play inside and snippy comments about positioning seem to bear out. Ramon Nunez
, while talented, also let selfishness get in his way this season.
is no different than a front office or a business," said Hitchcock. "When you have so many different personalities, and strong personalities at that, and once again, I would argue with your point,
that I think we have so many talented players that it's a challenge to manage that."
By not properly handling O'Brien and Nunez, Clarke forced changes in other positions as well, i.e.
playing Kenny Cooper
at left mid in place of Nunez rather than up top. Cooper, a revelation and complete professional in his first MLS season, did everything he could.
satisfactorily resolved was the chemistry and cohesion of Richard Mulrooney
and Simo Valakari
in the middle. At times Mulrooney would drift wide to cover for O'Brien's moves inside,
and not until late in the season did he seem sufficiently recovered from his ACL injury to resemble the staunch warrior who won two titles in San Jose. Valakari's incessant fouling and lack of
range aren't secrets and comparing him to other central mids like Ricardo Clark
and Shalrie Joseph
is no contest. FORWARDS. Carlos Ruiz
is a strong, formidable
scorer and without the distractions of playing World Cup qualifying, was supposed to deliver consistently. He did cut down on his unexcused absences but forwards on other teams put up superior
numbers and sharper efforts. Maybe this is as good as he gets and the team has to decide if it's good enough. Abe Thompson
can play. For assembling a forward group of Ruiz, Cooper,
Thompson and Roberto Mina, Clarke has to be commended. And a team that scores four goals in the conference finals has done enough offensively to advance. INTANGIBLES.
doesn't ensure championships. A collective can certainly exceed the abilities of those individuals that comprise it, especially in league of parity. The personalities and abilities have to be
melded, and that duty is shared by all concerned. Also shared is a duty to toughen up in the playoffs, and teams that don't - no matter how talented - get punished. Remember San Jose and D.C.
United last year, or the Fusion in 2001, or the Fire in 2000, or the Galaxy (24-8) in 1998?
The fighting spirit that carried Colorado past Dallas, and New England past D.C. United, and
Houston past Colorado, just wasn't on display often enough at Pizza Hut Park. In the final weeks of the season Chivas USA and Real Salt Lake were tighter and tougher than FC Dallas.
"Obviously, at the end of the day, the coach is responsible for pulling the team together and getting them through those tough times," said Hitchcock. "Everyone accepts a piece of accountability
when it comes to any of those issues we've had."
Clarke pays the price for that accountability, of course, but the renovation of FC Dallas is far from done.