The 2005 NAIA MenÆs All-American First Team is unique in that it contains no Americans. The 11 players selected hail for seven countries: Kenya (4), Iceland (2), England (1), Haiti (1), Northern Ireland (1), Ukraine (1) and Uruguay (1):
PLAYER, SCHOOL, YEAR (COUNTRY)
G Jorundur Kristinsson, Auburn-Montgomery, Soph. (Iceland)
D Hugh Davey, Embry-Riddle, Soph. (Northern Ireland)
D Bonivenger Misiko, Lindsey Wilson, Soph. (Kenya)
D Robert Oguda, Southern Nazarene University, Sr. (Kenya)
D Ben Callon, Rio Grande, Sr. (England)
M Simon Mulama, Park, Sr. (Kenya)
M Brian Ombiji, Lindsey Wilson, Sr. (Kenya)
M Andriy Budnyy, Azusa Pacific, Sr. (Ukraine)
F Hjortur Hjartarson, Auburn-Montgomery, Jr. (Iceland)
F Igancio Novas, Lindenwood, Jr. (Uruguay)
F Ricardo Pierre-Louis, Lee, Fr. (Haiti)