The U.S. Depth Chart: Marked with many questions

[USA CONFIDENTIAL] Five games into the reign of U.S. coach Jurgen Klinsmann, a few of the names have changed, and a different persona may be emerging even if the results haven’t been stellar. Though much of the focus on the early days of Klinsmann's tenure as U.S. national team coach has centered on a feeble attack, other numbers merit closer attention. He's used 30 players, a different starting lineup in each of his five games, and several formations since taking over in late July. Games in November against France and an opponent to be determined will allow for further experimentation and more data to be mined heading into a busy 2012 that starts with a January training camp. Here's what the USA's depth chart currently looks like ...

An emphasis on skill and combination play has produced impressive stretches of ball control and creative movement spoiled by lackluster finishing (two goals in five games). The back line has looked capable at times and confused at others, the midfield displays have ranged from crisp to creaky. The only consistently solid position has been in goal.

Based on his selections and their performances so far, here’s a look at the U.S. depth chart at each position, with a few players not yet picked for a game-day roster by Klinsmann (*marked by an asterisk) also included.

FORWARDS. The struggle to score goals – only two have been netted in five games since Klinsmann took over – naturally puts Jozy Altidore, Juan Agudelo, et al., under the spotlight, along with the question of whether Clint Dempsey can remain in the “hole” behind the forward(s).

Altidore has yet to translate his goalscoring prowess in Holland with AZ Alkmaar to the national team, and his current state is probably somewhere between a fluid, confident performance against Honduras and a more labored showing that rarely troubled Ecuador. There’s no question he can carve out space, knock down balls, and occupy centerbacks. He’s also surprisingly adept at getting out wide, as he did to center a ball Brek Shea contrived to poke wide from point-blank range in the Honduras game. (He did the same last year at the World Cup in stoppage time against Algeria, too.)

Barring a dramatic resurgence by Edson Buddle, Herculez Gomez, Freddy Adu, or somebody else, Altidore is going to get a lot of playing time. Agudelo’s youth and inexperience are not suited to a starting role just yet, especially if he’s paired with a fairly young (22) Altidore.

As to other candidates who can play up top with Altidore, the only viable option could be Landon Donovan in case Klinsmann opts for more speed. Shea has occasionally played up top for club and country and if a 4-3-3 formation is really on the USA horizon he’s a top candidate at the left wing.

Chris Wondolowski’s late surge into Golden Boot contention with San Jose will probably earn him a recall to the January training camp but his misfires in the pre-Klinsmann Gold Cup weren’t encouraging. Aside from Teal Bunbury -- and he’s still very raw -- nobody other than Agudelo looks viable in the short term among the younger contingent.

Starters: Altidore, Dempsey. Backups: Agudelo, Buddle, Gomez*, Bunbury*, Adu*.

MIDFIELD. Dempsey has certainly emerged as a more dangerous attacker while deployed as a second forward, but that switch plus a few injuries have left the midfield rather barren.

Shea’s ability to play on either flank has masked a failure to generate effective, consistent wide play. In just two national team games, Danny Williams has shown the acumen and ruggedness to handle himself, but whether he can handle the position of right mid is yet to be determined. His attacking instincts are solid, as he showed by getting off three shots against Honduras and working combinations up the flank with rigth back Steve Cherundolo, but often he looks like a central player chafing in the wrong position.

Leading the list of injured are Stuart Holden and Jose Francisco Torres, who won’t be seen until the New Year. If he ever gets healthy, with his instincts and engine Holden can fill the bill on the flank or in the middle. Torres offers touch and vision and a surgical left foot; he’s better suited to a central grafting role rather than out wide flying up the flank and flinging in balls, a la Shea, or as a schemer. Unless he can consistently trick his way through tackles, he’ll be prone to costly turnovers, as physically he’s just not there yet.

Robbie Rogers’ good/bad games under Klinsmann seem to confirm the opinion of predecessor Bob Bradley: not a bad player, but not all that good, either. DaMarcus Beasley showed enough in the last two games to edge his way into the picture but will need to improve significantly to dislodge Shea. He still has his pace and a potent left foot, valuable weapons in all situations.

None of the central combinations used by Klinsmann among Maurice Edu, Michael Bradley, Jermaine Jones, Kyle Beckerman, Jeff Larentowicz and Torres have taken root. During the testing-out process, lack of cohesion and confusion are to be expected, yet the current cast of characters consists of either two-way players or those suited mainly to a holding role. A Holden or Benny Feilhaber or Sacha Kljestan could change this dynamic and lend a true attacking flair, with preference perhaps for Holden or Donovan, both of whom are imbued with enough workrate and range to lessen the burden on a more defensive counterpart.

One option is a mix of two-way central players and reliance on attacking impetus from four outright attackers and occasionally the outside backs, no matter who they may be or how they are deployed. Critics cry out for an incisive, insightful, all-conquering No. 10, but no such finished product exists in the current pool, and many national teams – such as Mexico – do just fine without one.

Starters: Shea, Bradley, Donovan, Williams. Backups: Holden*, Torres, Edu, Beasley, Jones, Beckerman, Kljestan, Ricardo Clark.

How different the Gold Cup could have been if Nuremberg had not told Tim Chandler to bypass the competition has been shown by his performances at left back. He had been considered a left-back candidate by Bob Bradley, who never got the chance to test him in that position.

He’s not a natural on that side, but tracks and tackles tenaciously. At age 21 there’s tons of room to mature and improve on his positioning and reading of the game. In his four appearances for Klinsmann (three at left back) he’s hit a number of good crosses with his right foot and a couple of decent efforts from the left.

Right now, the left-back job seems his to lose, though by the time World Cup qualifying starts next June Eric Lichaj should be healthy and fit enough to mount a challenge. Lichaj’s Gold Cup performances were mainly positive, and his move to right back early in the Gold Cup final when Cherundolo was injured opened the floodgates for Mexico. He is recuperating from a torn hip labrum that is projected to sideline him until January.

Edgar Castillo played left back in Klinsmann’s first two games in charge (Mexico and Costa Rica) and aside from great speed, didn’t show enough to merit serious consideration at the national team level. He’s also out of the mix at Club America. Michael Orozco Fiscal played in those two matches as well as the first half against Honduras; his departure in favor of Oguchi Onyewu at halftime of that match quite snugly delineates their positions on the depth chart.

It’s taken Onyewu nearly two years to fully recover from the ruptured patellar tendon he suffered in the Hexagonal finale against Costa Rica, and a stark measure of his progress should come next month against France. How well captain Carlos Bocanegra is keeping his form with a change of teams from the French League to Glasgow Rangers will also bear watching.

Other center back options are Clarence Goodson, who played decently in his only appearance for Klinsmann against Belgium, and Omar Gonzalez of the Galaxy. The exclusion of Gonzalez to date has generated an uproar of comical exaggeration, though much of that is rooted in Tim Ream’s struggles. (If Gonzalez isn’t summoned to the January camp, that will be cause for panic.)

Starters: Chandler, Bocanegra, Onyewu, Cherundolo. Backups: Goodson, Lichaj*, Orozco Fiscal, Ream, Jonathan Spector.

GOALKEEPER. The hiring of former England international Chris Woods, who counsels starter Tim Howard at Everton, as U.S. goalkeepers coach gives a clear indication of how this position shapes up.

Unless Brad Guzan can break into the starting lineup at Aston Villa or Marcus Hahnemann swoops back into the picture, Nick Rimando of Real Salt Lake will be the experienced backup and Bill Hamid gets the call from the youth contingent, of which there are prospects – Sean Johnson, Dan Kennedy, Tally Hall – but no serious candidates.

Starter: Howard. Backups: Guzan*, Rimando, Hamid.

UP NEXT. For the two proposed November games against France, on Nov. 11, and another opponent to be announced, four days later, Klinsmann is expected to rely mostly on European-based players, though he can call up any MLS player other than one whose team reaches the championship game. The conference finals will be played Nov. 5-6, and the league will sit out the following weekend during the FIFA dates.

13 comments about "The U.S. Depth Chart: Marked with many questions".
  1. Andrew Post, October 18, 2011 at 7:49 a.m.

    AHHHHHHHHHHHH are we still talking about the ricardo clark/ sasha Kljestan experiment. How many times does an experiment have to go wrong before it is abondoned all together? Both these players suck (for a lack of a better word), so why keep bringing them back?

  2. John Pomeroy, October 18, 2011 at 8:49 a.m.

    Let's have Landon Donovan up top. For long enough he's been asked to play midfield and play both ways. I just don't see him starring in that role in 3 years, but I do see him playing a crucial role in the offense: developing a rapport with the younger strikers and playing off of them. Using his experience to get in good positions. Empower him, Jurgen! Teach him the ways of the Force.

  3. Walt Pericciuoli, October 18, 2011 at 10:52 a.m.

    We are still 3 years away from WC time. Many things will happen between now and then including all of our players being 3 years older. Yes we will need our experienced players to help qualify, but we better be looking at and giving real playing time experience to our younger core of players.

  4. Chris Hoffmann, October 18, 2011 at 1:52 p.m.

    wondo deserves a 2nd look. he talks about European players having to be in form and playing, yet he brings in agudelo who is even starting in MLS. wondo may be only the third player in mls history to win back to back golden boots.

  5. John DiFiore, October 18, 2011 at 10:07 p.m.

    Herculez has more goals in less minutes than Jozy!!!


  6. Hal Hilger, October 18, 2011 at 10:09 p.m.

    Klinsman was a super Player in the German Bundessliga as well as for the German National Team. As Coach he did not succeed for the German National Team nor for Bayern Muenchen. He will run into the same problem in the US.
    The player are skilled enough to play with true professionals. If he really want to test his players, let them play Germany and see how good the US Team really is

  7. Mark Greenwood, October 19, 2011 at 1:12 a.m.

    For a starting XI I like Dempsey up top b/c he has a nose for the goal, Donavon as the second forward b/c he used to make those sharp diagonal runs when he played in Germany. I like Sacha at attacking midfield, Freddy Adu (a lefty) at left midfield, DeMarcus Beasley who is a much better player than Shea at right midfield, Michael Bradley at defensive midfield, Michael Parkhurst (technically skilled) at left center back, Bocanegra at left back, Aguche at right center back, Spector at right back with Howard in goal. Your players as substitutes would be Jones, Bocanegra, Goodsen, Edu, Holden, Torres, Altidore, Davies, Aguedelo, Kenny Cooper and Chris Klein along with two other goalkeepers. I think these are the players that Jurgen needs to keep together and no one else.
    One other thing I think is important is that the US team really does not need a style of play. I think they need a system of play. Three things here: 1) Positional passing, 2) Small-combination play (a. give n goes, b. overlaps, c. takeovers), 3)forward diagonal runs. Maybe there is a better word for it a functional system of play based on a 1998 USSF National 'D' license I received at Plymouth State College. skisea654

  8. Robert Kiernan, October 19, 2011 at 8:18 a.m.

    Well I've got to say there are several omissions from your list... first off no mention of Fabian Johnson who while injured clearly is in Klinsmann's plans for that left midfield spot, next no mention of Mikkel Diskerud who should be in the mix for a midfielders spot with Holden and Torres both out and Donovan questionable. Another player not mentioned but who can play at Fullback or Centerback is Michael Parkhurst who plays regularly in Scandinavia after being a perennial MLS all star...another possible candidate for the GK position is David Yelldell playing in Germany. ...Of the domestic based players you didn't include, defenders like George John and Geoff Cameron likely are also possibilities... and Bocanegra and Edu's teammate at Rangers Alejandro Bedoya likey is another one to include.
    It's a shame that Justin Gatt just tore his hamstring or he clearly would be in this list as well... certainly would have featured in the u-23 Olympic team.

  9. Philippe Fontanelli, October 19, 2011 at 3:30 p.m.

    Here goes Mahoney again with Bradley. Leaving Torres and Holden for Backups and placing Dempsey on the front so to make room for Bradley. I'd even take Edu and Beasley before Bradley in midfield. Not to mention that Diskerud should be there he is the future Donovan if anyone saw him play. Also we must not forget Gil for the future. But I would try Bradley in defense, I think that would be his true position, besides that line is shaky at the present. And what about George John in defense?

  10. Vic Flegel, October 19, 2011 at 5:41 p.m.

    Mark....Chris Klein is retired.

  11. Karl Ortmertl, October 20, 2011 at 4:25 p.m.

    Ditto to Antonio's comments. I'll just add a couple of things. I think Adu fits in there somewhere. I'd like to see Gil get a callup soon. Michael Bradley, if he can somehow abandon his father's dream of him being a midfielder, may not be bad as a defender - depth is certainly needed there.

  12. Hal Hilger, October 21, 2011 at 4:18 p.m.

    Superman- you are absolutely right, Bayern had problems within management and it reflected upon the players. Bayern, in their organization have more 6 to 18 years youth teams, U18 and U19 teams than the US has MLS teams, not countig minor teams, numberless lower amateur as well as top amateur team s, a regional and third division, a second Bundesliga Team
    and of course FC Bayern. With such recources of depth and being one of the richest Club in Europe being able to acquisition players has helped Klinsman greatly. But even with success for a couple of years his tenor as coach
    ended. If the US want to succeed in the game
    of soccer you need to establish a proven system like we have in Europe and South America, with relegation, a longer season and serious training, with certified coaches.

  13. Hal Hilger, October 22, 2011 at 10:02 p.m.

    Ditto to Antonio's comments: I have seen Adu play in Europe and he is not worth to be even mentioned. He does not have the mentality to fit into a professional team. He is to slow, looks lost on the field and is not in tune with the other players. He has had numerous chances with different team in Europe but was rejected by the most. He may have a chance in your country for the level of play compared to Europe is still minor league.

Next story loading loading..

Discover Our Publications