U.S. Positional Rankings: No question, Dempsey is top forward

By Ridge Mahoney

The delineation between forwards and strikers can be blurry, but there's no question Clint Dempsey is the top American up top.

Six goals in nine games for the USA last year confirmed his status as the most dangerous U.S. forward, and with Landon Donovan on hiatus, the focal point of its front-line attacking play.

In a traditional two-forward alignment, players of different abilities are often paired to present a more complex and difficult task to the opposing defense. Some players can swap roles comfortably, with one playing underneath the other, others are more limited even if they are effective. Teams that play with three forwards or one player alone up top add to the overlapping of assignments.

In the broadest terms, forwards are more versatile than strikers, who tend to play centrally in the restricted roles of posting up, playing one-twos, and getting shots on frame. Forwards have all of those responsibilities in addition to roaming side-to-side in search of space, floating into midfield to draw defenders and open up lanes, and using the wings to drive past opponents to serve crosses or take shots. The differences between a (second) forward and an attacking midfielder aren’t always clear, either.

These rankings are based on national team performances, future prospects, and other factors, such as club form.

Soccer America's Top 6 U.S. Forwards
1. Clint Dempsey (Tottenham), 91 caps
2. Chris Wondolowski (San Jose Earthquakes), 10.
3. Juan Agudelo (Chivas USA), 16.
4. Chris Rolfe (Chicago Fire), 10.
5. Teal Bunbury (Sporting Kansas City), 4.
6. Joe Gyau (St. Pauli), 1.
Also considered: Jesus Padilla (La Piedad)

His tally of five goals in 18 league matches isn’t all that impressive, yet Dempsey needed time to settle at Tottenham and convince Coach Andre Villas-Boas that he could play in support of teammates Jermaine Dafoe and Emmanuel Adebayor, or without them alone up top. His communication with winger Gareth Bale is also blossoming, as evidenced by his excellent headed goal against Coventry City in a 3-0 FA Cup win that was Deuce’s second of the game.

The main concern for Coach Jurgen Klinsmann, aside from injury, will be monitoring Dempsey’s energy levels, especially in the three Hexagonal qualifiers to be played in June after the English season has concluded. He will need plenty of support as opponents take their shots to stop him. His range of movement and variety of tricks gives him more attacking weapons than any other U.S. player.

Wondolowski’s frustrating stints with the national team -- no goals in 10 appearances that include a few glaring misses –- haven’t affected his MLS performances, though he’s also yet to net in a playoff game. The movement of the ball, the poise and balance with which he shoots, the exemplary commitment and workrate, and the attitude of a consummate pro would seem tailor made for the international game. He’s the top MLS forward yet is spinning his wheels for the USA.

After scoring on his debut in the post-2010 World Cup friendly against South Africa, Agudelo’s hit only one goal in the last 15 appearances. A move from the Red Bulls to Chivas USA didn’t revive his club career and a rumored transfer to Glasgow Celtic has further muddled his status. His only U.S. appearance last year produced an assist against Russia and though he looked capable in his 28 minutes of action he’s yet to prove that at age 20 he’s truly ready for this level.

Rolfe has been out of the national team since 2009 but there’s no doubt he’s among the most skillful and craftiest American MLS players. Whether that translates to call-ups from Klinsmann remains to be seen. His first season back in MLS following three up-and-down years in Denmark produced eight goals in 22 games; it’s not hard to see him in the Gold Cup squad this summer if he and the Fire start strongly.

Bunbury’s game features the pace and athleticism Klinsmann likes but a knee injury suffered in August limited him to just two U.S. games in 2012 and kept him out of the January camp. Once he recovers should be back on the U.S. radar screen by the back end of the Hexagonal schedule if not the Gold Cup.

A loan from Hoffenheim, which has replaced Fulham as the go-to club for American players, to St. Pauli in the German Bundesliga 2 is a key factor in the development of Gyau. He’s played for the U.S.-17s and U-20s, and last year played all four games for the U-23s in their failed attempt to qualify for the Olympic Games. Another player blessed with speed and skill, he needs some solid showings for St. Pauli to get a shot with the big team.

U.S. Positional Rankings:
Attacking Midfielders
Holding Midfielders

Left Midfielders
Right Midfielders
Left Backs
Center Backs
Right Backs

13 comments about "U.S. Positional Rankings: No question, Dempsey is top forward".
  1. Luis Arreola, January 23, 2013 at 7:53 p.m.

    Where is Hercules Gomez on this list? He should be in 2nd place. Seriously?? Can anyone explain this thinking?

  2. Vince Leone, January 23, 2013 at 8:24 p.m.

    Wondolowski has had very few minutes and very little service in those 10 matches, so I don't think we can judge him one way or the other at the national team level.

    Agree on Gomez.

    Alan Gordon should be given a look.

  3. Edward Grinnell, January 23, 2013 at 8:42 p.m.

    Being that Altidore was also left off the list and reading the article, I can only imagine that Gomez will be considered in a future article as a striker. I also assume that Alan Gordon will be rated as a striker.

  4. Adam Cohen, January 23, 2013 at 9:07 p.m.

    ouch that is not a very deep bench.

  5. ted b, January 23, 2013 at 9:23 p.m.

    No Altidore? No Herculez?

  6. Steven McDonald, January 23, 2013 at 10:21 p.m.

    Agreed , there has to another list. No Gomez(hasn't he started last 10 matches?) and Altidore. They have to be there. Still feel bad for Agudelo and his NY Redbulls de(backe)le. When Backe came and Angel wasn't in his plans it was last straw for me. Especially after selling Altidore years previously.

  7. Byron Clarke, January 23, 2013 at 10:30 p.m.

    If the world cup were tomorrow Dempsey would be in and not a single one of these players would get serious consideration. Altidore, Gomez, Terrance Boyd, and if Klingsman were to look at the MLS he would probably go with Eddie Johnson. This list is a joke and nothing but a plug for MLS. If you listen to Klingsman he says that the best players must be in Europe to be considered.

  8. Kent James, January 23, 2013 at 10:55 p.m.

    SA should include a list of all the positions that will be listed, to avoid the issue of looking like players are not being considered when they may be on another list. I'm guessing Altidore, Boyd & Gomez will be on that other list (since they're clearly more prominent players than some on this list).

  9. Mr G, January 24, 2013 at 9:45 a.m.

    You guys give Ridge too much credit. He is a joke - there is no other list of striker/forwards - and like you pointed out, glaring omissions. There are other lists for the other positions...
    Attacking Midfielders, Holding Midfielders, Left Midfielders, Right Midfielders, Left Backs, Center Backs, Right Backs and Goalkeepers

  10. Albert Harris, January 24, 2013 at 11:21 a.m.

    Oh please! Ridge starts off talking about the difference (often very fine) between forwards and strikers and leaves off Altidore, Boyd, and Gomez, all of whom tend to be creatures of the 18 yard box as opposed to Deuce who is more of a classic inside forward from the old days, and people throw an immediate hissy fit. Get a grip, people...the striker list will be out today or tomorrow, then we can all call Mahoney an idiot to our heart's content as we always do. LOL

  11. Luis Arreola, January 24, 2013 at 11:52 p.m.

    Byron, Not always European players are the answer. Mexico U23's won the Gold at Olympics against a Brazilian roster full of players signed in Europe's top clubs. Mexico had none playinmg in Europe. USA is getting many German based players that given the choice would pick to play for Germany as the first choice. I'm just sayin.

  12. Kent James, January 26, 2013 at 10:51 p.m.

    The other list is at:

  13. CHRISTIAN CARLOS, September 25, 2015 at 6:01 p.m.

    Hello, To properly introduce myself, I am Mr Christian Carlos a private lender i give out loan at 3% interest rate. This is a financial opportunity at your door step, apply today and get your fast loan. There are many out there looking for financial opportunity or assistance all over the places and still yet they are unable to get one. But this is a financial opportunity at your door step and as such you can't afford to miss this opportunity. This service is render to both individuals,companies,business men and women. The loan amount available ranges from any amount of your choice For more information contact us via email: LOAN APPLICATION FORM FILL AND RETURN. Full Name: Personal Phone Number: Country: Address: State: Age: Have you applied before?: Marital Status: Loan amount needed as loan: Loan Duration: Occupation: Monthly Income: In acknowledgment of these details, We shall send you our terms along with repayment schedule and If you agree to the terms and conditions ,you stand to get your loan within 24hours. This depends on your seriousness and urgency in obtaining the loan.( I gladly await your swift response, Yours Sincerely, Mr Christian Carlos

Next story loading loading..

Discover Our Publications