Red Bulls-Crew SC Takeaways: Columbus holds on, barely

A 2-0 lead from the first leg proved to be just enough for Columbus to capture the Eastern Conference title despite losing the second leg, 1-0, at Red Bull Arena Sunday. The Red Bulls couldn’t break through until the third minute of stoppage time, when substitute Anatole Abang headed in from close range. They nearly equalized in stoppage time when a Bradley Wright-Phillips attempt dribbled off the base of the post.



Here are three takeaways from a dramatic night at Red Bull Arena:

1. Columbus shows how to neutralize Red Bulls' pressure.

The Red Bulls were pushed back by Crew SC for most of the first half and only a pair of excellent Luis Robles saves on Kei Kamara and a crucial block by Matt Miazga kept the score 0-0.

Robles thwarted Kamara with a kick save in the eighth minute and dove to his right to push away a long, low shot in the 38th. In between, Miazga stopped Kamara from close range after Ethan Finlay had cut back a ball from the byline that Kamara hit first-time.

Runs forward by right back Harrison Afful set up the two shots that were saved, and the Miazga block resulted from a ball played through midfield by Tony Tchani after he’d escaped a challenge from Mike Grella.

A recurring theme of both legs was Crew SC’s ability to neutralize the vaunted Red Bull pressure by avoiding tackles and double-teams and quickly finding teammates running into vacant spaces.

2. This Red Bull is not a good chaser.

After conceding the earliest goal in MLS playoff history nine seconds into the first leg, the Red Bulls played more than two full games before Abang scored in the 93rd minute of the second game.

New York’s attack improved in the second half on Sunday; it took 15 shots after producing just two in the first 45 minutes. Yet before New York’s very late flurry the only truly dangerous threat was a long shot by Sacha Kljestan that skipped in front of keeper Steve Clark as he dove to his right to push it away. A minute before Abang’s goal, the ball ping-ponged around the penalty area and bounced off Crew SC defender Michael Parkhurst twice before it was cleared.

Grella was seldom a threat in either game. Lloyd Sam sharpened his game in the second leg and lobbed in a few dangerous crosses but found very little success when he cut inside to shoot. He shot wide on a setup from Kljestan. Wright-Phillips and Abang both headed over the crossbar on good serves.

Some smart, composed defensive play by Crew SC shut down much of what the Red Bull attack likes to do, but New York didn’t lack for chances in either leg. What it did lack was the crisp, sharp finishing that helped amass a league-leading 62 goals in the regular season. New York netted just three times in four playoff matches.

3. Berhalter leads rebound after 2014 playoff collapse.

After serving as a Galaxy assistant coach as he wound up his playing career in 2011, Crew SC head coach Gregg Berhalter took up the mantle of another Anschutz Entertainment Group sports property, Swedish club IF Hammarby. He lasted a year and a half; the club dismissed him in July 2013, and he was among the candidates interviewed by Columbus after it fired Robert Warzycha two months later.

Former Crew SC players Guillermo Barros Schelotto and Brad Friedel were among those considered for the job. Also on the list were Jesse Marsch, Tab Ramos, Richie Williams and Frank Yallop. Instead, majority owner Anthony Precourt opted for Berhalter, who last year guided the Crew into third place with a 14-10-10 record (52 points) and in 2015 took second at 15-11-8 (53 points). He was a Coach of the Year finalist in 2014 but lost out to Ben Olsen of D.C. United.

In last year’s playoffs New England blasted Columbus, 4-2, in the first leg and went on to win the series, 7-3, on aggregate. Berhalter downplayed that failure as motivation for this season, yet midfielder Justin Meram in his postgame comments did allude to 2014.

“We put ourselves in great position being the third seed last year and we're like alright, here we go, and we came out with a stinker,” he said. “This year, we do the same thing, put ourselves in the same position and we knew that all that's behind us. Now it's time to really focus and you know we played against two really incredible teams.”

TRIVIA. Of the nine surviving MLS teams that started up with the league in 1996, the Red Bulls are one of three to reach just one MLS Cup final (2008). The others are Colorado (1997) and FC Dallas (2010).

Nov. 29 in Harrison, New Jersey
NY Red Bulls 1, Columbus 0. Goal: Abang 90+3.
NY Red Bulls – Robles; Zizzo, Zubar, Miazga, Lawrence (Abang, 72), Felipe (S. Wright-Phillips, 82), McCarty, Sam, Grella (Veron, 62), Kljestan. B. Wright-Phillips.
Columbus – Clark; Afful (Klute, 77), Sauro, Parkhurst, Francis; Tchani, Trapp, Meram (Saied, 86), Finlay (Wahl, 89), Higuain, Kamara.
Yellow Cards: NY Red Bulls – Felipe 28, Zizzo 85; Columbus – Sauro 67.
Referee: Baldomero Toledo.
Att.: 25,219.
(Columbus wins 2-1 on aggregate.)
5 comments about "Red Bulls-Crew SC Takeaways: Columbus holds on, barely".
  1. Gus Keri, November 30, 2015 at 10:50 a.m.

    The New York Red Bulls will never win MLS Cup until the New York Cosmos is restored to its rightful place in the top tier of the US soccer. It's written in soccer's heavens.

  2. Mark Buckley, November 30, 2015 at 12:13 p.m.

    The title of this article should have been "Red Bulls had a chance - Barely" I watched the game with the sound off because I couldn't listen to anymore pro-metrostars/redbulls commentary. Listening to Taylor Twellman on ESPN in the first leg you would have thought the Red Bulls were winning. Total NY bias. In the "deserved to win" category the Crew were winners hands down over 2 legs. In the "mentality" category, the Crew still came out on top over 2 legs. Bradley Wright Phillips is fine in the regular season but is non-existent in the playoffs. He is the Kevin McHale of the MLS, good sometimes, stomping his feet and childish the rest of the time. Thank God the "town meeting" story is dead.
    But NY you have a champion - The New Your Cosmos! Congratulations Cosmos! NASL Champions.
    Yes I am a DC United fan. We have 4 stars on our uniform. (4 MLS Cups)

  3. Ric Fonseca replied, November 30, 2015 at 5:57 p.m.

    Mark, I couldn't agree with you more!!! I always thought that these guys, color commentators (whatever the heck this means!) and the other guy announcing were/are supposed to be non-partisan and put any biases aside. Yet, know what, I heard the same thing while watching regular "football" between two colleges, and once again I had to turn the volume off as the announcers were so blatantly biased in favor of one team over the other. Final: Portland 2-0.

  4. Scot Sutherland, November 30, 2015 at 1:59 p.m.

    The MLS has finally reached a level where flexibility is the key. Columbus were more flexible than NYRB. Marsh appears to be a system coach that is unlikely to stray from the system even when it is not working. Berhalter seems to have a broader understanding. The Crew did quite a few different things this year, most of which was easy on the eyes.

  5. beautiful game, December 1, 2015 at 9:31 a.m.

    Both teams sucked in the efficacy department and shined in the giveaway part. It was obvious that the Crew had the upper hand on scoring opportunities in the first half; and mediocrity took over for efficacy. As usual a few rugby challenges were unpunished. The ratio of giveaways to good plays by both team was about 7-1. No player on the pitch stepped up to the plate with a solid performance. None deserved better than a 4 and most deserved a 3 or less. In the second half Crew had several counters which cemented their mediocrity and no efficacy; IQ2 soccer mentality. FIFA better look into the laser issue; I saw a red and green laser being flashed at a Crew defender who suffered an eye problem. The commentary was just as bad as the contest; total NONSENSE.

Next story loading loading..

Discover Our Publications