Commentary

Brad Friedel: Youngsters deserve more MLS playing time

By Mike Woitalla

The USA, coached by Tab Ramos, reached the quarterfinals of the 2015 U-20 World Cup, falling in a penalty kick shootout to eventual champion Serbia.

Since then, U.S. Soccer has ramped up preparations for the 2017 U-20 World Cup in South Korea (May 20-June 11) by creating a U-19 national team, whose reins it also handed to former U.S. national team star, Brad Friedel.

Since the U-19 launch in January, Friedel has taken his team of 1998-born players to tournaments in the Canary Islands, Slovakia, Spain and most recently Serbia, where the USA lost 2-1 to the host, fell 2-0 to France and beat Hungary, 2-1.

“This time around there’s more opportunity for younger players to prove themselves,” says Friedel. “By having a U-19 team we close the gap year and put the 98s into more situations to see if they can get into the 97 group.”


Brad Friedel (Photo courtesy Fox Sports)

Several of the 98s have already played for Ramos’ U-20 team: Marlon Foosey, Luca de la Torre, Hugo Arrellano, Isaiah Young, Brandon Vasquez and Auston Trusty. Weston Mckennie, who recently left FC Dallas’ academy for Schalke 04 and was MVP of the Slovakia Cup the U-19s won, is also on his way up. Of those, only Vasquez went on the Serbia.

Friedel says that players who played particularly well at the Stevan-Vilotic Cele tournament in Serbia were Clemson defender Tanner Dieterich; Sporting Kansas City midfielder Felipe Hernandez, who was making his first appearance with the U-19s; Danny Barbir, the 2015 U-17 World Cup central defender whom Friedel used as defensive midfielder against Hungary; and Chicago Fire midfielder Djordje Mihailovic.

Club Tijuana forward Vazquez, also a 2015 U-17 World Cup player, scored in the loss to Serbia. He scored the gamewinner in the U-19s 1-0 win over Spain in Valencia in July.

“If we put out our best 11, 1998-born players – they’re very, very good,” says Friedel. “Remember, the 98 group includes Christian Pulisic.”

Friedel, who started his coaching career in the Tottenham Hotspur youth program while still a player, believes the USA is rife with talent but is concerned that they aren’t getting pro experience early enough.

“I think right now in a lot of MLS’s coaches' heads a young player is 22 to 25, but a young player is 16 to 19,” Friedel says. “I think these coaches would be surprised at how good these young players would be if you gave them 10, 15, 20 games. And yes they’re going to make mistakes along the way, but I bet they’ll be surprised at how good some of them can be.”

Friedel doesn’t accept as an excuse that MLS coaches would be taking a risk by fielding young Americans.

“There’s no relegation,” he says. “Of all the leagues in the world, your coaching job is the most stable in MLS. I’m not saying that every single young player they put on the field is going to be great. I’m saying if you had the right person in charge of development at your academy, with a population we have in the United States, there would be a few young players on each club playing more than they do now.”

Friedel says that a number of MLS clubs, such as FC Dallas, are doing excellent work with their youth program, but that the nation still needs to take a different approach at the younger ages.

“One thing is for sure,” he says. “We have the talented players in this country. Where we lack top to bottom is the way we develop the players. I think the culture at the real young level of win-at-all costs is hurting the kids’ development.

“I also think at a certain age winning becomes paramount to their development. I just think we have it backward in this country. I think we focus on winning way too much, in all sports, at the younger ages, and when winning does become important, at 14, 15, 16, some of the kids will either be burned out, or they never learned the basics or are technically not good enough. ... But no one can tell me we don't have the talent."


Standing (L-to-R): Sam Golan, Adam Ozeri, Ethan Zubak, Tanner Dieterich, Brady Scott, Danny Barbir.
Front row: Jake Morris, Eddie Munjoma, John Nelson, Djordje Mihailovic, Felipe Hernandez.

Stevan-Vilotic Cele Tournament in Serbia
Sept. 5 in Topola, Serbia
USA 2 Hungary 1. Goals: Zubak (Hernandez) 51, Mihailovic 53; Kovacs (Biro) 75.
USA -- Scott; Munjoma, Dieterich, Golan, Nelson; Ozeri (Calvillo, 77),  Barbir; Hernandez, Mihailovic, Morris; Zubak (Vazquez, 77).
Hungary -- Demjen; Szalai, Toth, Nagy, Gergenyi; Szabo (Toth, 61), Kleisz, Kamaras (Dragoner, 69); Tomosvari (Kovacs, 61), Takacs, Biro.

Sept. 2 in Senta, Serbia
USA 0 France 2. Goals: Callegar (Maurice) 22, Janvier (Georgen) 57.
USA -- Scott; Munjoma, Dieterich, Barbir, Nelson; Da Silva (Hernadez, 61), Mihailovic (Calvillo, 61), Barry (Ozeri, 45), Perez; Rice (Wright, 45), Vazquez (Zubak, 67).
France -- Zidane; Danger (Georgen, 45), Souici, Fischer, Maoussa; Callegari (Sissako, 67), Ruiz; Ikone (Camara, 45), Maurice (Reine, 45), Janvier; Abdalha (Eduardo, 67).

Sept. 1, 2016 in Subotica, Serbia
Serbia 2 USA 1. Goals: Petroc (Racic) 28, Zlatanovic (Popovic) 88; Vazquez (Da Silva) 40.
Serbia -- Illic; Gojkov (Radic, 45), Dinga, Masovic, Bosnjak; Petrovic, Nikoljic (Mesarovic, 45), Terzic; Racic (Popovic, 71), Vlahovic (Zlatanovic, 78), Petrov (Romanic, 60).
USA -- Scott; Munjoma, Dieterich, Barbir, Nelson (Morris, 45); Ozeri, Calvillo; Da Silva (Hernandez, 45), Mihailovic (Perez, 45), Wrght (Zubak, 82); Vazquez (Gallardo, 62).

U.S. U-19 men national team (Serbia trip)
GOALKEEPERS (2): Brady Scott (De Anza Force; Petaluma, Calif.), Colin Shutler (Loudoun Soccer Club; Broadlands, Va.).
DEFENDERS (6): Danny Barbir (West Bromwich Albion/ENG; Allentown, Pa.), Tanner Dieterich (Univ. of Clemson; Nashville, Tenn.), Sam Golan (Loudoun Soccer Club; Great Falls, Va.), Jake Morris (Seattle Sounders FC academy; Fort Lauderdale, Fla.), Eddie Munjoma (SMU; McKinney, Texas), John Nelson (Internationals SC; Medina, Ohio).
MIDFIELDERS (6): Habib Barry (Seattle Sounders FC academy; Seattle, Wash.), Eric Calvillo (New York Cosmos; Palmdale, Calif.), Pierre Da Silva (Orlando City B; Port Chester, N.Y.), Felipe Hernandez (Sporting KC academy; Murfreesboro, Tenn.), Djordje Mihailovic (Chicago Fire academy; Bridgeview, Ill.), Adam Ozeri (Banfield/ARG; New York, N.Y.).
FORWARDS (6):  Joe Gallardo (Unattached; San Diego, Calif.), Josh Perez (Fiorentina/ITA; La Habra, Calif.), Elijah Rice (Univ. of Washington; Las Vegas, Nev.), Brandon Vazquez (Tijuana/MEX; Chula Vista, Calif.), Haji Wright (Schalke 04/GER; Los Angeles, Calif.), Ethan Zubak (LA Galaxy II; Los Angeles, Calif.).

12 comments about "Brad Friedel: Youngsters deserve more MLS playing time".
  1. Bob Ashpole, September 14, 2016 at 11:13 p.m.

    I will go farther than what Friedel said. The USSF DA is not the "solution" to development of professional players that some people think it is. They are amateur teams and will produce elite amateur players, but is that USSF's goal? U18s should be playing professionally. U14s and U16s should be playing up. That is a professional player development track. The fact that some US players join MLS at age 23 after playing amateur soccer up to then, doesn't mean that is the best development path.

  2. R2 Dad, September 15, 2016 at 12:23 a.m.

    Common sense from Friedel, but that's not how MLS works. With the exception of FCD, the programs aren't investing (ie playing) their youth academy prospects. It will take (another) dictate from Sunil/Garber along the lines of X minutes required per season from registered U-19 academy players, in order that sufficient development actually extend to match day.

  3. Bob Ashpole replied, September 15, 2016 at 2:54 a.m.

    U19 academy? I assume you are referring to the MLS reserve teams. Reserve teams and competitions are what is needed for development as a stepping stone to the senior teams, but I don't think mandating a minimum number of minutes for reserve team players to play with the senior teams is a suitable solution. The senior teams are not development teams.

  4. R2 Dad replied, September 16, 2016 at 12:28 p.m.

    That's funny, Bob, because Dortmund disagrees.

  5. Bob Ashpole replied, September 16, 2016 at 3:17 p.m.

    Please give me a reference for that. If true, I want to read what they say about it.

  6. Bob Ashpole replied, September 17, 2016 at 7:01 a.m.

    R2 Dad, I have concluded that your opinion is merely based on the fact the Pulisic has played for Borussia Dortmund this year, but he is not a U19 Youth Academy player being gifted with some minutes with the senior team. He is a member of the senior team this year. Apparently there are some U19 youth academy players also playing on the reserve team. That is what I think of as typical. The reserve team is a development team.

  7. Bob Ashpole, September 15, 2016 at 12:26 p.m.

    AA, I hope you realize that I agree with most of what you said, but I don't draw some of the conclusions you do.

  8. Fire Paul Gardner Now replied, September 15, 2016 at 12:59 p.m.

    I hope you realize that when you don't agree with AA about anything he becomes extremely upset and agitated.

  9. Bob Ashpole replied, September 15, 2016 at 2:54 p.m.

    It would be a waste of my time to only correspond with people who agree with me. I would never learn anything that way.

  10. John Roode, September 15, 2016 at 12:26 p.m.

    Preach on Coach Friedel! I've said for years that the US can compete with any youth program in the world until Age 16. At that point, Euro and Latin players continue to progress while our players' development typically goes into decoine. Why? Because we don't put them in situations where they have to be mature about anything in their life. Euro kids are already being given chances and opportunities at age 16, and are expected to take advantage of them... while US kids are still being coddled even through their college years. It's the difference in cultures and when "the age of maturity" is reached. In Europe, at 16, you are expected to act like an adult. In the US, you aren't expected to act like an adult until you are 21... and in some cases, beyond. It's kinda sad, really.

  11. Fire Paul Gardner Now, September 15, 2016 at 1:01 p.m.

    “I think right now in a lot of MLS’s coaches' heads a young player is 22 to 25, but a young player is 16 to 19” - Brad is 100% spot on with this assessment. Hopefully, as we move away from NCAA ball as a major part of our development system, this mindset will change. I still hear people talk about 24 year old players (like Zardes for example) as a young player. Nowhere else in the world is a 24 year old soccer player considered young.

  12. Bob Ashpole, September 15, 2016 at 2:58 p.m.

    At my age anyone under 50 is young :)

Next story loading loading..

Discover Our Publications