Commentary

Ref Watch: My least favorite things

The following is an excerpt from Ian Plenderleith's latest book, "Reffing Hell: Stuck in the middle of a game gone wrong." Illustrated by Tim Bradford (Halcyon Publishing)

What are the 10 things I least want to see or hear when I’m refereeing a game of soccer?

1. The shout for “Offside!” almost every single time a forward is through alone on goal. It comes from the defenders, it comes from the coaches, it comes from the spectators — a one-word verbal plague of ignorance upon the amateur game. During Saturday’s game, a goalkeeper saved a freekick and then complained that the player who followed it up to score was offside. How did he see that when he was saving the kick? He went on about it so much (and I tried to ignore him, but he ran after me almost all the way to the halfway line screaming, “Offside! Offside!”) that he ended up with a yellow card.

2. “You have to call fouls against both teams!” Usually from a losing coach or one of his players. Oh, really? I thought I was just supposed to call fouls against your team as a heaven-ordained test of your patience. And because I have a real and vested interest in who wins this U15 boys’ district league game. Sunday’s choleric coach, with his team several goals behind, bellowed this one at me. The obvious answer — I’m calling fouls against your team because it’s mostly your team that’s fouling. Perhaps because that’s the way you coached them.

3. “Ref, how much longer?” No matter how many times you call the answer out loud, there will be at least three players who didn’t hear it for every one that did. If you want to know how much longer, ask your coach. I’m watching the game, not my bloody watch. And what will you do with this knowledge anyway? Suddenly start giving 100% for the last 10 minutes after winging it for the first 80?

4. “Ref, their number 10 just called me a pig-shagger.” Or something. What the ref doesn’t see or hear, he can’t punish. And we’re not going to get involved in a conversation that starts with: “Did you just call FC Farmhands’ number 7 a pig-shagger?”

5. The halftime walk to the changing room when you see one of the coaches walking towards you. It’s usually not to see if you want a piping cup of hot chocolate (although — very occasionally — it is). Be prepared to account for a perceived foul you can’t even remember. Register the coach’s disgust and disbelief when you tell him your mind’s blank. Shame on me — another shocking injustice already lost to time and the dark, moist mud of the municipal field.

6. A straight red-card offense. You might think it’s an existential peak for any referee — the privilege of pompously holding up the plastic signifier for a big dismissal. But it’s the moment I hate most, because already I’m thinking, “That’s at least one hour of my Saturday/Sunday night gone writing up the disciplinary report for this dickhead.”

7. The off-the-ball shoving match. This one’s a particular specialty of teenage boys, usually when a bulky defender ushers the ball out of play while his skinnier opponent tries to flail and dance his way around him. Then they square up, push each other in the chest, pout at each other, and hope that I get there to intervene before — for the sake of pride — someone feels obliged to raise a fist. Then I give a lecture like a weary old teacher who’s seen it in the corridor a thousand times before.

8. The Parent With An Opinion.

9. Serious faces. I mean it. During the obligatory pre-match handshakes, I’ve taken to advising players that they are, in fact, allowed to smile. Go on, try it. Enjoy the sport. It’s the weekend in a free and democratic country and you’re playing football.

10. The absence of gratitude. I read an interview recently with an air hostess who said, “All we ask is for passengers to smile and say thank you. It’s not much, but it really means a lot to us.” Ninety per cent of players and coaches don’t bother. But they should. It’s not much, but it really means a lot to us. Thank you.

Ian Plenderleith’s new book reflects the recruitment crisis in refereeing across all sports, around the world. 'Reffing Hell: Stuck in the Middle of a Game Gone Wrong’ is available in the USA on Amazon Kindle from August 8. The book is also available in print directly from the Halcyon Publishing in the UK.

* * * * * * * * * *
Refereeing in Soccer America

Among our recent ref, rules and officiating coverage and commentary:

1. An extraordinary refereeing oversight By Paul Gardner 

2Soccer refereeing and artificial intelligence By Ahmet Guvener

3Referee Tales: Lips on the whistle By Ian Plenderleith

Ref Coverage around the Web

1. How 'Higuita's Rule' cut time wasting (or didn't) By David Salazar

2Semi-automated offside technology to be used in Champions League, UEFA Super Cup (Reuters) 

3Nigel Pearson: Bristol City manager wants referees to be given mics for more  'transparency' (BBC)

4PRO Inside Video Review with Greg Barkey

* * * * * * * * * *


The 2022-23 FIFA rulebook

The are various ways to access free digital versions of the 2022-23 FIFA Laws of the Game.

U.S. Soccer: 2022-23 rulebook (available in English, Spanish, German and French) in PDF form HERE. U.S. Soccer's Pocket Guide HERE.

IFAB: 2022-23 rulebook (available in English and various languages) HERE. IFBA changes to 2022-23 Laws of the Game HEREIFAB app.


Photo: Michael Janosz/ISI Photos

5 comments about "Ref Watch: My least favorite things".
  1. R2 Dad, August 19, 2022 at 6:37 a.m.

    I did not know pig-shagging was a thing in Germany. Q: why do Scottish farmers wear kilts? A: Sheep can hear a zipper from 20 yards away.

  2. Bob Ashpole, August 19, 2022 at 5:29 p.m.

    My personal policy was to thank the center for keeping everyone safe after the end of every half.

    It expressed my support and reinforced that safety was what was important. It was a little thing, but I thought the officials appreciated a thank you instead of the more common whining.

  3. Dan Woog, August 22, 2022 at 12:16 p.m.

    You nailed it, Ian. I'll add the passive-aggressive #11: "Oh, I guess it's okay now to push" (or trip, or shove, or whatever...).

  4. Valerie Metzler, August 23, 2022 at 9:58 a.m.

    This book is now on my reading list.

  5. Alan Blackledge, September 5, 2022 at 10:35 a.m.

    The call for offsides occurs all the way up the ladder, not just the amateur level...many of these things players and coaches simply emulating what they see at the higher levels...unfortunately.
    Forgot the famous "HANDBALL!!!!!"

Next story loading loading..

Discover Our Publications