Commentary

Yes, USMNT has lots of work to do. Is that shocking? Not exactly

"We've got work to do."

You think?

Those words from U.S. national team coach Gregg Berhalter following Friday's 2-0 loss wouldn't necessarily be alarming if they were uttered two or three years out from the start of the World Cup.

But we're talking about less than two months before the USA opens the 2022 World Cup in Qatar against Wales.

On a certain level, the result is not shocking.

Thanks to Covid-19 and the fencing of national team play behind confederation competitions, the USA has rarely had a chance to play teams from outside of Concacaf. Its only good result was the 3-0 win over World Cup-bound Morocco in June, yet we now know the Lions of Atlas were a team in chaos, firing head coach Vahid Halilhodzic in August.

Within Concacaf, the USA beat archrival Mexico three times in 2021, to win the Nations League and Gold Cup and to put it in good shape to qualify for the World Cup with its 2-0 win over El Tri in Cincinnati, but it didn't exactly crush it, finishing third in the Octagonal and needing goal difference to edge Costa Rica after blowing the eight-point cushion it had over the Ticos at the beginning of the year. The 2-0 loss in San Jose on the final day of qualifying was certainly a wake-up call and underscored the USA's concerns at key positions like goalkeeper and center forward.

But the performance against Japan went much further than that. How many players, based on how they played against Japan, would you feel confident today about starting for the USA at the World Cup?

The isolation of national teams within their confederations means you rarely get to see a team like Japan, which is a good squad.

As a starting point, the Japanese underscored the gap in technical proficiency between players from the two teams. If the U.S. players are incapable of holding the ball and hitting crisp passes, they're rarely going to able to make that up against a good team with intangibles like intensity or commitment or any of the characteristics so often attributed to American players.

The USA gave the Japanese a ton of opportunities with turnovers in its own half. Walker Zimmerman and Aaron Long were among the worst offenders — when has the USA produced a central defender with a high comfort level on the ball? — but Weston McKennie and Tyler Adams — not exactly Xavi and Andres Iniesta on a good day in midfield — were just as bad.

In his post-game remarks, Berhalter lamented the lack, among other things, of intensity in his team. Its hard to expect sharp play when he has to resort to starting players like Luca de la Torre, who has not started a competitive club match in four months, or Sergino Dest, whose last competitive club start was more than five months ago, or Gio Reyna, who made his first competitive start for Borussia Dortmund in five months last week at Manchester City in the Champions League.

But you would expect more out of players like Adams and McKennie, who normally set the tone for the USMNT, on and off the field with their intensity and personality (two of Berhalter's post-game buzzwords).



Where does the USMNT go for here?

Berhalter said last week he was 80 percent done picking his team for the World Cup. That 80 percent has got to include a bunch of players who had real stinkers on Friday. None of the remaining 20 percent stepped up and booked a ticket to Doha.

The first thing is, the USA must hope that injured players Antonee Robinson, Chris Richards, Yunus Musah, Christian Pulisic (injured in practice) and Tim Weah get healthy. All were sorely missed against Japan and would be expected to make significant contributions in Qatar.

Besides Richards, Berhalter has no one at center back who can comfortably advance the ball, but Richards has missed the last three windows (March, June and September) with injuries. Does Berhalter bite the bullet and bring back Tim Ream even though he has said the Fulham captain doesn't fit into his game model? John Brooks? (That would be the about-turn of all about-turns in national team history.)

Jesus Ferreira and Josh Sargent didn't exactly cover themselves in glory against Japan. In his recent remarks, Berhalter has seemed less committed to moving on from Jordan Pefok than Ream, but the center forward remains a huge concern.

A complete overhaul of the USMNT's tactics? A game model based on pressing isn't going to work if you're constantly being beaten at your own game. (It wasn't until about the 20th minute that the USA forced a turnover in the Japanese third.)

There will have to be some tweaks and better in-game adjustments, but major changes in how the USMNT plays simply isn't going to happen, given the time-frame it is working with.

In 2002, U.S. Soccer sporting director Earnie Stewart, USMNT GM Brian McBride and Berhalter were part of the team that upset Portugal in the opening game and reached the quarterfinals at the World Cup. It had five weeks to prepare.

In November, the USMNT will have all of one week to prepare for the Wales opener after all its players arrive at its Al Gharafa base camp.

Photo: John Dorton/ISI Photos

10 comments about "Yes, USMNT has lots of work to do. Is that shocking? Not exactly".
  1. R2 Dad, September 23, 2022 at 4:16 p.m.

    What has become apparent is GB's inabilty to make mid-game corrections to match situations, as well as slavish adherence to his playing-out-of-the-back strategy. If Carlo Ancelotti isn't too proud to change formations and tactics, maybe GG could be more flexible as well.

  2. Toby Rappolt, September 23, 2022 at 7 p.m.

    What is the definition of "technical proficiency"?

  3. Santiago 1314, September 23, 2022 at 7:30 p.m.

    Did anyone get Injured, and will Miss the WC.??!
    NO.!?!?!?
    Successful Game then.!!!
    This is the World Cup cluster "F"... you get it...
    Six starters out and we expect the others to carry the team??
    On a crappy field??

  4. humble 1 replied, September 26, 2022 at 10:54 a.m.

    100% agree.  We have a context over the last two years to draw on, true, only as good as your last game, but also true, the context is there, and so are we this time, we are there, with a very young team.  At least we did not get relegated like the islanders we'll play, Wales or England.  Keep your heads up!  Make it happen boys!

  5. frank schoon, September 24, 2022 at 10 a.m.

    What worries me if we beat Saudi Arabia then all of a sudden the problems we have are forgotten, when ,in fact, WE HAVE PROBLEMS, and that it runs deeper then just the coaching of this team. And until we begin to see and do something about it, we'll continue playing at the level of how we played against Japan, who seem to be light years ahead in player development...

  6. James Balthazar replied, September 24, 2022 at 11:22 a.m.

    Go out and watch youth soccer and see your technically proficient player getting bypassed for your more athletic, faster player with little to no actual soccer lnowledge. Then you'll see why we lose to the smaller, slower Japan team.

  7. R2 Dad replied, September 24, 2022 at 12:13 p.m.

    If our kids came up through futsal teams before transitioning to fields at 14, the player pool would look much different and the ball skills would be much higher.

  8. frank schoon replied, September 24, 2022 at 12:49 p.m.

    James, that's the story of soccer development in the states. And worse those coaches with their athletes are known as good coaches/recruiters because they win games

  9. humble 1 replied, September 26, 2022 at 10:49 a.m.

    We have the normal issues a nation our sizing growing into the sport would have.  A lot of work is bing done, new leagues, galore, our new pioneers in Europe. Futsal is a good example of our state of futbol being, nevern entirely the answer, part of the solution, yes.  About futsal, yeah, can help, and remember, with futsal, several things, first change of ball to weighted ball, took away the carress, futsalers used to learn, just ask Brazilians.  Then you need coaches and refs that know futsal.  Where you gonna find those here?  My son played boatl load of futsal, refs have not clue, not same game.  Only Latinos have experience, and we already knew struggle to integrate them in our futbol referee and coaching contexts.  So the key as always here is we need to do better job integrating latinos, lots of barriers to this, focus on the game, not the politics, and please,making coach and referee training easier, better and cheaper.  Invest in the people that make the game possible.  There, we do far less than we should.  Have a nice day!  Go USA!

  10. Kevin Leahy, September 25, 2022 at 2:45 p.m.

    It would be very difficult to be covered in glory as a 9 in this team. There is very little service, creativity or cohesion. Mush is probably the most creative at the moment and he isn't playing. Really wish Hugo Perez was coaching this group

Next story loading loading..

Discover Our Publications