2017. Reading United AC, Chicago FC United, Christos FC, Michigan Bucks.
2018. Ocean City Nor'easters, Jacksonville Armada, Mississippi Brilla, NTX Rayados, FC Wichita, Sporting Arizona FC, FC Golden State Force.
2019. Florida Soccer Soldiers, Orange County FC.
2022. FC Motown, North Carolina Fusion U23.
2023. Tulsa Athletic,
*Chicago House AC.
*Amateur teams over pro teams.
Note: Chicago House AC came back from 2-0 down to beat Forward Madison, 3-2, in overtime.