Join Now | 
HomeAboutContact UsPrivacy & SecurityAdvertise
Soccer America DailySoccer World DailySpecial EditionAround The NetSoccer Business InsiderCollege Soccer ReporterYouth Soccer ReporterSoccer on TVSoccer America ClassifiedsGame Report
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalkSoccer America ConfidentialYouth Soccer InsiderWorld Cup Watch
RSS FeedsArchivesManage SubscriptionsSubscribe
Order Current IssueSubscribeManage My SubscriptionRenew My SubscriptionGift Subscription
My AccountJoin Now
Tournament CalendarCamps & AcademiesSoccer GlossaryClassifieds
The contrasting cases of Andy and Freddy
by Ridge Mahoney, April 16th, 2010 12:59PM

MOST READ
TAGS:  d.c. united, mls

MOST COMMENTED

By Ridge Mahoney

At the U.S. Soccer Development Academy finals last summer at Home Depot Center, I got my first look at a very talented, very young D.C. United player named Andy Najar.

His highlight moment, or nearly so, came when he controlled a difficult ball on his chest and while under pressure, first-timed a volley out of the air that a very sharp goalkeeper turned onto the post with an excellent save. But there were dozens of other moments in the games that I watched either live or on DVD where he astutely solved a tricky situation by instinct and reaction, nicking the ball out of a double-team and getting a second touch to retain possession, or using an unorthodox flick to control a crazy bounce or carom.

There were also times when his brazen dribbles ran aground, or a mis-read or rash decision lost his team possession or terminated a promising sequence. As with just about everything else, soccer education is as much failure as success, a relentless, demanding gauntlet of trial-and-error embedded with frustration and denial.

Najar, 16 at the time, stood out not because his skill shone through an otherwise moribund, lifeless team. United’s players were technically sound, tactically aware, and used their touch and savvy to keep the ball as they probed for spaces and angles to advance the ball toward the penalty area. They didn’t always succeed, of course, and there were a few hasty clearances and premature crosses, flubbed traps and communication breakdowns, but they played with a plan and brought ideas to the game.

In a competitive environment – each U-16 and U-18 team played four games in seven days against other regional champions -- Najar looked to be a player who had a real chance to make the first team someday and get a shot at MLS. That’s all he resembled; not a dead-certain national-team star, not a ten-figure European transfer target, not a future World Cup representative, not a global marketing icon. He wasn’t alone. There were a handful of players imbued not with marvelous skills, but rather a cognitive appreciation of everything a difficult, perplexing sport requires.

All of those things, and far more, were laid at the feed of another young United player, Freddy Adu, when he went pro at a much earlier age, 14, and jumped right into the starting lineup. Since then, a new term has crept into the league’s lexicon, “MLS-ready”, which Freddy certainly was not at the time, and what Najar – who crashed a shot off the crossbar in his MLS debut as a starter – is getting the chance to prove he might be.

By mandating teams field U-16 and U-18 academy teams, and offering them two additional roster spots for “HomeGrown” players, MLS is edging closer to a true commitment on developing players, in stark contrast to its absurd mega-hyping of Adu just six years ago. MLS needed the publicity, and got it, but denied Adu what he needed: the patient, demanding, and intelligent cultivation of talent and ambition and personality necessary to blossoming into a bona fide professional player.

By next season, if MLS has brought back something akin to the Reserve Division, which it scuttled after the 2008 season, it can give its “second-squad” players the same regular diet of competitive action that most of their U-16 and U-18 teams are now getting. If Najar proves he is “MLS-ready” at age 17, this tier wouldn’t serve his needs, but for many more players in this stage of development, it will be essential.



No comments yet.

Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now




AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent Soccer America Confidential
MLS teams San Jose and Houston in transition take on new identities    
The Quakes and Dynamo are linked by a common history and the return of Dominic Kinnear ...
Defending MLS champs seldom look the part in post-Donovan days    
Drab draw with the Rapids extended unbeaten run to four games, yet the Galaxy is still ...
Revs are running on all cylinders     
What other MLS team can afford to bring Jose Goncalves and Lee Nguyen, both MLS Best ...
MLS: The Best of April    
Great drama on the international stage brought MLS notoriety and many teams began to forge their ...
Impact players 'give it up' to Club America    
A 4-2 defeat in the second leg of the Concacaf Champions League final left Montreal players ...
Impact fans will get the last laugh at Big O    
Let's hope Wednesday night's Montreal Impact-Club America game for Concacaf supremacy lives up to the pregame ...
Sigi Schmid: MLS clubs are 'committed to win the CCL'    
Seattle Sounders head coach Sigi Schmid is looking forward to the big game in Montreal Wednesday ...
Chicago is on Fire, Accam puts MLS on warning    
The hottest team in MLS is the Chicago Fire. It took a gap of almost three ...
MLS = Mostly Low Scoring. That's a Problem.     
The American fan has an extensive menu of soccer available this and every weekend, as U.S. ...
Nice win underlines U-23 issues     
I didn't have great expectations Wednesday for the U-23 friendly between the U.S. and Mexico at ...
>> Soccer America Confidential Archives