Join Now | 
HomeAboutContact UsPrivacy & SecurityAdvertise
Soccer America DailySpecial EditionAround The NetSoccer Business InsiderCollege Soccer ReporterYouth Soccer ReporterSoccer on TVSoccer America Classifieds
Paul Gardner: SoccerTalkSoccer America ConfidentialYouth Soccer InsiderWorld Cup Watch
RSS FeedsArchivesManage SubscriptionsSubscribe
Order Current IssueSubscribeManage My SubscriptionRenew My SubscriptionGift Subscription
My AccountJoin Now
Tournament CalendarCamps & AcademiesSoccer GlossaryClassifieds
Can L.A. Galaxy duck Supporters' Shield stigma of defeat?
by Ridge Mahoney, October 10th, 2011 1:39AM

MOST READ
TAGS:  los angeles galaxy, mls

MOST COMMENTED

[MLS SPOTLIGHT] If the Los Angeles Galaxy parlays its fourth Supporters’ Shield trophy into its third MLS Cup title, it will buck the percentages. Seattle, the only team with a chance of catching the Galaxy for the best regular-season record, lost that chance Saturday when Philadelphia handed it a 2-0 defeat at CenturyLink Field. By doing so, in some bizarre way, the Sounders may have enhanced their odds of winning MLS Cup.

Of the previous 15 teams that posted the best regular-season record to win the Supports' Shield, five (33.3 percent) have gone on to double up as MLS Cup winners. Only one other team has gotten as far as the championship game.

D.C. United won both titles twice within three seasons (1997 and 1999), and Kansas City repeated the feat in 2000. Los Angeles, which roared through the 1998 season but fell in the playoffs to Chicago, posted the best record in 2002 and went on to edge New England, 1-0, at the Revs’ then-new facility, Gillette Stadium. (That is the only time in league history a team has won the title on the home field of its MLS Cup opponent.)

The Galaxy’s 2002 double marked the fourth time in the first seven years of league play that the best regular-season team also lifted MLS Cup, but it’s happened only once since then. The trend has been reversed: of the seven Supporters' Shield winners from 2004 to 2010, four have been knocked out in the first round.

Not until the Crew’s inaugural league title in 2008 did a Supporters’ Shield winner also capture the league championship. (In 2003, Chicago posted the best record and reached the title game, but fell to San Jose, 4-2, at Home Depot Center).

If the Galaxy can do the business at its Home Depot Center on Nov. 20, it will become the second team to host and win the title game after posting the best regular-season record; D.C. United beat Colorado at RFK Stadium in

If LA gets to the final and loses, the champion will duplicate the Galaxy’s triumph at Gillette nine years ago.

Here’s a complete list of regular-season champions and how they fared in the playoffs:

1996: Tampa Bay Mutiny – Lost to D.C. United*, two games to none, in Eastern Conference finals.

1997: D.C. United – Defeated Colorado, 2-1, in MLS Cup.

1998: LA Galaxy – Lost to Chicago*, two games to none, in Western Conference finals.

1999: D.C. United – Defeated the Galaxy, 2-0, in MLS Cup.

2000: Kansas City Wizards – Defeated Chicago, 1-0, in MLS Cup.

2001: Miami Fusion – Lost to San Jose*, six points to three, in MLS semifinals.

2002: LA Galaxy – Defeated New England, 1-0 (OT), in MLS Cup.

2003: Chicago Fire – Lost to San Jose, 4-2, in MLS Cup.

2004+: Columbus Crew – Lost to New England, 2-1 aggregate, in Eastern Conference semifinals.

2005: San Jose Earthquakes – Lost to Galaxy, 4-2 aggregate, in Western Conference semifinals.

2006: D.C. United – Lost to New England, 1-0, in Eastern Conference final.

2007:
D.C. United – Lost to Chicago, 3-2 aggregate, in Eastern Conference semifinals.

2008: Columbus Crew – Beat the MetroStars, 3-1, in MLS Cup.

2009: Columbus Crew – Lost to Real Salt Lake*, 4-2 aggregate, in Eastern Conference semifinals.

2010: LA Galaxy –Lost to FC Dallas, 3-0, in Western Conference final.

2011: LA Galaxy -- ????

*- asterisk denotes Supporters’ Shield winner lost to eventual MLS Cup champion.

+In 2004, the Crew and Kansas City both finished with 49 points; the Crew were named Supporters’ Shield winner by virtue of a tiebreaker.



2 comments
  1. Nick Bell
    commented on: October 10, 2011 at 10:17 a.m.
    the supporter's shield is still the odds on favorite to win the tournament. 5 championships is still the best percentage that any seed has enjoyed. By a lot actually, the 3rd seed has won 3 times, and the fifth and 8th seeds have both won twice. one thing is for sure, seattle, who seems destined for the 2nd seed, wont have better odds like you claim- the 2nd seed has only won once.

  1. Nick Bell
    commented on: October 10, 2011 at 3:20 p.m.
    I didn't say the 8th seed has a better chance than Seattle, I said Seattle's odds do not improve by failing to win the Supporter's Shield refuting what was claimed in the article, and I also said that the 8th place finisher has historically won more times than the 2nd place finisher. I swear, Seattle fans are so sensitive. The point of my comment was not to bash the Sounders, but rather to refute the article by pointing out that the Shield winner has actually done well historically.


Sign in to leave a comment. Don't have an account? Join Now




AUTHORS

ARCHIVES
FOLLOW SOCCERAMERICA

Recent Soccer America Daily
Guardiola: Bayern Munich deserved to win    
[UEFA CHAMPIONS LEAGUE: Wednesday] Off to a relatively quiet start to its league season, German champion ...
Impact edges Red Bulls to take command    
[CONCACAF CHAMPIONS LEAGUE: Wednesday] In a Concacaf matchup of MLS teams, Montreal went with its stars, ...
Lichaj's Nottingham Forest stays on top    
[AMERICANS ABROAD] Eric Lichaj, one of the few available European-based U.S. internationals not called into the ...
Women take to turf for final qualifying warmup    
[USA-MEXICO] With the threat of U.S. women's national team players to sue FIFA over the issue ...
Soccer America Men's Top 25 Scoreboard    
[ROUNDUP: Midweek] In 2013, North Carolina came up against William & Mary as the No. 1 ...
Soccer America Women's Top 25 Scoreboard    
[ROUNDUP: Midweek] No. 2 Virginia improved to 8-0-0 with a 5-0 victory over Old Dominion. The ...
A neat free-kick goal from Down Under     
[VIDEO PICK: Golazo] Choreographed free kicks usually don't work out better than a simple shot on ...
Charlotte gains Independence as Eagles' successor    
[USL PRO] The Charlotte Independence will take the place of the Charlotte Eagles in USL PRO ...
What They're Saying: Clint Dempsey    
"We talked about trying to win the U.S. Open Cup, Supporters' Shield and MLS Cup. This ...
D.C.'s Espindola shows off stuff, Timbers refuse to wilt    
[CONCACAF CHAMPIONS LEAGUE: Tuesday] D.C. United all but clinched a berth in the quarterfinals of the ...
>> Soccer America Daily Archives